Should carlos have been discharged

Assignment Help HR Management
Reference no: EM131235455


The following case illustrates the off-duty privacy claim of an employee and management's right to uphold the reputation of the company.
Before his termination on Monday, March 9, 2015, Carlos Hilliard worked as a senior sales representative for Davey Duck Publishing (DDP), a provider of educational books and supplies to secondary schools. During his ten years of employment, Carlos was recognized as an outstanding employee with close working relationships with the schools he served. His sales record was excellent. His discharge resulted from what DDP claimed was a serious breach of its code of conduct for employees.

On Saturday, March 7, 2015, due to a chance meeting between Carlos and his manager, Sylvia Green, Carlos was observed leaving an adult video store carrying what his manager described as pornographic magazines and an X-rated video. The following Monday, Sylvia discussed the incident with DDP's vice-president for sales and a representative from HR.

All agreed that Carlos's off-duty behavior constituted a serious violation of the company's code of conduct for employees, which read, in part, "Employee off-duty behavior in no way should reflect unfavorably upon the company, its employees, or sales of any educational materials:' AEM has traditionally held its sales representatives to high moral standards because the company sells extensively to public school administrators and teachers.

At his discharge meeting, Carlos vigorously opposed his firing. While he acknowledged making the purchases, he argued strongly that what he did on his personal time was "no business of the company's" and his behavior in no way reflected unfavorably upon AEM or the sales of its products. Besides he said "The purchases were made as jokes for a stag party."


1. Given the facts of this case, should Carlos have been discharged? Why or why not?

2. Should employees of DDP be held to a higher standard of personal conduct than ?employees for other types of organizations? Explain.

3. Should management have considered Carlos's past work record before deciding on ?discharge? Explain.

Reference no: EM131235455

Arrange an interview with the head of human resources

Arrange an interview with the head of human resources at a local health care organization - Write a report (1300 words) on your interview that reviews the organization's human

Describe methods to deal with high employee turnover

Examine the significant effect of each identified staffing model on processes that may be occurring within the organization (e.g., outsourcing, contingent workers, consultin

Share at least one personal example in current employment

Share at least one personal example, in current employment or past employment, of a Knowledge Management System that you have used. Share briefly if they were successful or

Find an article that is hr-related sexual harassment

Find an article that is HR-related (for example, "women abuse in India" is not HR-related, but "women in organizations in India" is.Use a reputable source for retrieving your

Expected values-payoff tables-hotdogs

You own the rights to sell hot dogs at the local ballpark, The weather network predicts the probability of rain at 60% for the next game coming up tomorrow. You have to deci

Goal-setting and company strategy

Imagine that you are a manager in an organization, and your employees are not achieving stated goals. Suggest key strategies that you would use in order to determine and the

Provide a brief description of the selected manuscript

Identify the selection criteria and methods, and discuss how they relate to the needs of the organization in the case. Include an analysis of the criteria and methods used for

Define type of behavior that would characterize application

Experiences play an important role in how future leaders will run the organization. Give three examples of how effective competencies, relationships, and learning capabiliti


Write a Review

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd