Should a multinational firm risk overhedging

Assignment Help Financial Management
Reference no: EM13208726

Discuss the following topic: "Should a multinational firm risk overhedging?" Some have argued that exchange rate risk is irrelevant. One argument for exchange rate irrelevance is that according to purchasing power parity theory, exchange rate movements are just a response to differentials in price changes between countries. Therefore, the exchange rate effect is offset by the changes in prices. A second argument for exchange rate irrelevance is that investors in multinational firms can hedge exchange rate risk on their own. Another argument is that if a U.S.-based multinational firm is well diversified across numerous countries, its value will not be affected by exchange rate movements because of offsetting effects. Some critics also argue that if stakeholders (such as creditors or stockholders) are well diversified, they will be somewhat insulated against losses experienced by a multinational firm due to exchange rate risk.These contentions, in turn, have resulted in counterarguments from multinational firms. They argue creditors that provide loans to multinational firms can experience large losses if the multinational firms experience financial problems. Thus, creditors may prefer that the multinational firms maintain low exposure to exchange rate risk. Consequently, multinational firms that hedge their exposure to risk may be able to borrow funds at a lower cost.

Instructions:

1- To read the point and counter-point of this argument and express your own opinion on this topic :

Point: Yes

Multinational firms have some "unanticipated" transactions that occur without any advance notice. They should attempt to forecast the net cash flows in each currency due to unanticipated transactions based on the previous net cash flows for that currency in a previous period. Even though it would be impossible to forecast the volume of these unanticipated transactions per day, it may be possible to forecast the volume on a monthly basis. For example, if a multinational firm has net cash flows between 3,000,000 and 4,000,000 Philippine pesos every month, it may presume that it will receive at least 3,000,000 pesos in each of the next few months unless conditions change. Thus, it can hedge a position of 3,000,000 in pesos by selling that amount of pesos. Any amount of net cash flow beyond 3,000,000 pesos will not be hedged, but at least the multinational firm was able to hedge the minimum expected net cash flows.

Counter-point: No

Multinational firms should not hedge unanticipated transactions. When they overhedge the expected net cash flows in a foreign currency, they are still exposed to exchange rate risk. If they sell more currency short from forward contracts than their net cash flows, they will be adversely affected by an increase in the value of the currency. Their initial reasons for hedging were to protect against the weakness of the currency, but the overhedging described here would cause a shift in their exposure. Overhedging does not insulate a multinational firm against exchange rate risk. It just changes the means by which the multinational firm is exposed.

Reference no: EM13208726

Questions Cloud

Write some code that exchanges their values : There are two string variables, s1 and s2, that have already been declared and initialized, write some code that exchanges their values.
State what is the change in the entropy of the surroundings : A phase change occurs at 298 K and deltaS system - -13.5 J/K. What is the change in the entropy of the surroundings?
Draw a flow chart and hierarchy chart : Draw a flow chart, hierarchy chart, and write pseudocode for the following problem. • A weather sensing system calculates & prints a report on the following: ? Average temperature ? Highest temperature ? Lowest temperature ?
By how much would v have to fall to offset the increase : A) What is the real value of output (Q) Now assume that the Fed increase the money supply by 10 percent and velocity unchanged. B) If the price level remains constant, by how much will real output increase
Should a multinational firm risk overhedging : Discuss the topic-Should a multinational firm risk overhedging - creditors may prefer that the multinational firms maintain low exposure to exchange rate risk. Consequently, multinational firms that hedge their exposure to risk may be able to borro..
Explain sodium borohydride is a strong base : Sodium borohydride is a strong base as well as a reducing agent. Why would it be better to add the NaBH4 solution to a base-sensitive substrate
Explain why the growth rate have changed recently : How have these aggregates been growing in the past year compared with the value if you can, download the data from the internet , or enter them by hand into a spreadsheet, and see if you can plot the data to compare.
Propose three to five additional activities : Propose three to five additional activities you think should be added to a Gantt chart to help you estimate resources and durations. Write a one-page paper describing these new activities.
Describe the main items in a gantt chart : Do you think many organizations use critical path analysis? What about critical chain scheduling? Justify your responses.

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Financial Management Questions & Answers

  Inventory driven costs

ABC analysis, standardisation and variety reduction, Inventory Driven Costs, EDI works, Just in Time, dependent and independent demand

  Financial decision-making techniques

Complete a project that helps you apply theoretical knowledge of financial planning to practical applications. It is a proven fact that learning by doing is more effective than reading theory.

  What are the no-arbitrage boundary conditions

What are the no-arbitrage boundary conditions for the value of a European vanilla Call option with strike price K1  - boundary conditions for the value of the European vanilla Call option

  Importance of a balanced capital structure and the problems

The importance of a balanced capital structure and the problems which are associated with high levels of gearing.

  Explain the alternative risk management approaches

Explain the alternative risk management approaches and their advantages and disadvantages for a medium-sized gold producer such as Mesa. State which approach you think is appropriate for Mesa and why.

  Capital budgeting case

Your company is thinking about acquiring another corporation. You have two choices—the cost of each choice is $250,000. You cannot spend more than that, so acquiring both corporations is not an option. The following are your critical data:

  Long term financial planning

This assignment is designed for analyze Long term financial planning begins with the sales forecast and the key input in the long term fincial planning.

  Herrings stock price after the planned dividend payout

Suppose the company cancels the dividend and announces that it will use the money saved to repurchase shares. What happens to the stock price on the announcement date?

  What will the adjusted eps and dps

What will the adjusted EPS and DPS be (rounded to the nearest cents)? And what would the stock price be (rounded to the nearest cent)?

  What is the implied coupon

If the promised payment on the bond is the same as the issue price of $100, what is the implied coupon if effective interest rates are 3.0% and the bond has a 1-year maturity?

  Prepare a wac io and po tranche

Prepare a WAC IO and PO tranche to give a 5.75% deal coupon. Create a PAC class (A-1) with an initial collar of 50%-200% PPC, assuming base case defaults.

  Compute the projects payback period

Draw a time line to show the cash flows of the project and compute the project's payback period, net present value (NPV), profitability index (PI), and internal rate of return (IRR).

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd