Role of the probity auditor

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics
Reference no: EM13823554

Summary of case

In December 1999, IBM-GSA was one of three tenderers for the IT outsourcing contract for the Departments of Health, Aged Care and the Health Insurance Commission (the Health Group), along with CSC and EDS. During the tender process, IBM-GSA was supplied with computer disks containing critical information relating to final pricing of their rival tenderers. IBM-GSA subsequently revised its tender after the due deadline and the minister announced they were the successful bidder.

At the time, the Office of Asset Sales and Information Technology Outsourcing (OASITO) described giving IBM-GSA details of their rival's bids as an ‘inadvertent error'. The minister dismissed the Opposition's call for an immediate halt to the tender process. Three years later, the minister, now retired, admitted that the $350 million tender should have been cancelled. He told the Audit Office in September 2002:

"When the disc containing all three bids was delivered to IBM GSA in error my reaction on being informed directly by OASITO was to cancel the tender. I could not see that a tender process with integrity could continue. At the conclusion of the tender I was both disappointed and annoyed at the limited role of the Probity Auditor and the absence of a separate report on the issue."

Not only did the tender continue, with IBM-GSA being awarded the contract, but the minister's claim that the Probity Auditor's role was limited was contradicted by evidence provided by OASITO to a Senate Estimates hearing on 8 February 2000. OASITO representatives told Senate Estimates that the management of the tender:

"...was conducted in accordance with the advice from both the probity auditor and our legal advisers engaged for the initiative. All parties concurred at the time that the process could continue unchanged [OASITO] briefed the probity auditor in person [who] immediately came back to us with a proposed course of action...We engaged the probity auditor to participate in all of our discussions to make sure that he fully witnessed the nature of the discussions...and he was happy that we had delivered the messages in accordance with his proposed course of action."

1.2.1 Public Interest

b) raise with stakeholders any potential conflicts between your professional activity and legal or other accepted public requirements;

c) advise your stakeholders as soon as possible of any conflicts of interest or conscientious objections that you have;

e) endeavour to preserve the integrity, security, continuity and utility of ICT;

f) respect the intellectual property of others;

g) endeavour to preserve the confidentiality and privacy of the information of others.

1.2.2 Quality of Life

b) protect and promote the health and safety of those affected by your work;

1.2.3 Honesty

a) reject, and will not make, any offer of bribery or inducement;

1.2.4 Competence

c) make yourself aware of relevant standards and legislation, and act accordingly;

d) respect and protect your stakeholders' proprietary interests;

1.2.6 Professionalism

b) take appropriate action against members who engage in behaviour contrary to this Code;

e) neither require, nor attempt to influence, any person to take any action which would involve a breach of this Code;

f) refrain from any conduct or action in your professional role which may tarnish the image of the profession or detract from the good name of the ACS;

i) have pride in your profession, and protect and promote professionalism and trustworthiness in ICT.

Reference no: EM13823554

Questions Cloud

Continuous quality improvement programs : What factors are associated with successful Continuous Quality Improvement programs and what are barriers in CQI and what are some recommendations to overcome the challenge? ( I would like Staralex52 to answer this question)
What is continuous quality improvement : What is Continuous Quality Improvement (CQI)? Provide examples of the types of CQI programs a health care organization may have. For example CQI to address patient times, CQI to address issues in the emergency room, CQI to address annual flu shots.
The container is dropped and the package begins to leak : As a container of hazardous materials is being unloaded from a deviery truck, the container is dropped and the package begins to leak. Is this a transportation accident? Why, or why not? Explain the actions required to be taken by the driver in such ..
Identify two areas of nursing practice : Identify two areas of nursing practice, which evidence-based practice has improved patient outcomes. State the study and its impact on patient care. How have these findings changed your nursing practice? Please support your response with a minimum of..
Role of the probity auditor : In December 1999, IBM-GSA was one of three tenderers for the IT outsourcing contract for the Departments of Health, Aged Care and the Health Insurance Commission (the Health Group), along with CSC and EDS
Transpersonal development map : Create a 2-page transpersonal development map. Use one or more of the theories of spirituality from the Health of the Human Spirit text along with the 10 metaphors of spiritual growth on pages 23-24 of the Essential Spiritualty text to create a plan ..
The policies of the urban geography of latin america : The policies of both Import-Substitution Industrialization and Neoliberalism strongly influenced the urban geography of Latin America, but in profoundly different ways. First, differentiate between the two policies and then compare and contrast t..
Unit provides support to minors : Question 1 The __________ unit provides support to minors, including advice and referral services. juvenile services traffic services patrol services administrative services 4 points Question 2 In the present day, most probationary periods in a polic..
Write about marketing failure in japanese gaming industry : Write a paper about One Marketing Failure in Japanese Gaming Industry.

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Business Law and Ethics Questions & Answers

  Explain case study decision- change in circumstances

Explain Case Study Decision- Change In Circumstances - Gagnon v. Coombs (Agency Relationship) and Did Joan have the right to convey the Shelburne farm to a trust that she had established

  What is the hierarchy

When a company goes into liquidation there is a hierarchy of creditors as to who gets paid first. What is the hierarchy

  Ball and lynch were partners in a new york law firm lowe

case study 1lowe ball and lynch were partners in a new york law firm. lowe who was in failing health advised the

  How does the law define in tell ectual propertywhat are all

how does the law define in tell ectual property?what are all of the different types of intellectual property held by

  What did these data sources andor information reveal to

write a 2 - 4 page paper responding to the followingreview and summarize the relevant prior research relating to your

  Discussing social responsibility

Create a 6 - 8 slide Microsoft PowerPoint presentation discussing social responsibility, what it means, and its role in business

  Discussnbsptwonbspof the following statementnbsp assume

discussnbsptwonbspof the following statement.nbsp assume the role of one of the five parties in the globe project

  How the program is evaluated

Write a 1,000- to 1,450-word report about your selected program that addresses the following: The type of family system in crisis the program was designed to help, The mission of the program, How the program was designed, How services are delivered

  Summarize your working definition of ethics

Summarize your working definition of ethics. Define ethics within the context of criminal justice

  Wat changes would you have to make what level of

in your initial post summarize the article you selected from the list above by first identifying the articles title

  How can gloria continue to protect herself and her family

How can Gloria continue to protect herself and her family from personal liability if she obtains her widgets from a foreign manufacturer? Use your textbook and library references to answer these questions. Evaluate each proposal. Does it constitute a..

  Investigate the validity of patients claims

Devise a plan to investigate the validity of patients' claims of denial of services. This plan should include, but not be limited to, establishing mechanisms to address service denial claims, a human resources component, and a review of related polic..

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd