Revenue recognition methods

Assignment Help Accounting Basics
Reference no: EM13860978

By 2008, U.S. GAAP included more than 200 different revenue recognition guidelines, rules and regulations. The most straightforward sale is a retail sale for cash, such as a consumer paying cash for groceries. As business became more complicated, so did revenue recognition. Transactions involving multiple elements are common. A computer manufacturer may sell a package of hardware, software, warranties, and telephone support. It is unclear how a one-time initial payment should be allocated among these four elements and unclear how an initial payment - combined with a monthly fee over some period - should be allocated among the four elements. 

In response to many questionable revenue recognition practices, in December 1999, the SEC issued Staff Accounting Bulletin (SAB) 100 to express their views on revenue recognition. In December 2003, the SEC issued a revised and expanded version of that bulletin, SAB 104, Revenue Recognition, Corrected Copy. SAB 104 includes four revenue recognition criteria that are widely quoted by U.S. firms in their revenue recognition note in Annual Reports. Based on these guidelines revenue should be recognized until it is realized or realizable and earned. 

The SEC believes that revenue generally is realized or realizable and earned when all of the following criteria are met:

1. Persuasive evidence of an arrangement exists,

2.  Delivery has occurred or services have been rendered, 3.The seller's price to the buyer is fixed or determinable, and 

4.Collectability is reasonably assured.

The following are notes from two publicly traded U.S. firms which cover a few of the revenue recognition issues:

General Motors Automotive Revenue Recognition

We recorded an adjustment to correct deferred revenue related to data disks provided to customers to update their vehicle's navigational system. We did not compute deferred revenue using fair value as determined by vendor specific objective evidence as required by EITF 00-21, Revenue Arrangements with Multiple Deliverables, Additionally, we did not defer revenue on the correct number of 2006 models containing navigation systems. As part of our restatement, pre-tax earnings were decreased, through a reduction of Automotive sales, by $33.1 million ($21.5 million after tax) in 2005.

In addition, we incorrectly recognized revenue for our sponsorship of the GM Card program, which offers rebates that can be applied primarily against the purchase or lease of GM vehicles. We corrected this accounting by deferring and recognizing additional revenue over the average utilization period of points earned by retail customers. As part of our restatement, pre-tax earnings were increased, through an increase to Automotive sales, by $42.3 million ($27.5 million after tax) and $19.7 million ($12.8 million after tax) in 2005 and 2004, respectively, and retained earnings was decreased at January 1, 2004 by $147 million.

Target Corporation

Revenues

Our retail stores generally record revenue at the point of sale. Sales from our online business include shipping revenue and are recorded upon delivery to the guest. Total revenues do not include sales tax as we consider ourselves a pass through conduit for collecting and remitting sales taxes. Generally, guests may return merchandise within 90 days of purchase. Revenues are recognized net of expected returns, which we estimate using historical return patterns. Commissions earned on sales generated by leased departments are included within sales and were $16 million in 2007, $15 million in 2006 and $14 million in 2005. 

Revenue from gift card sales is recognized upon redemption of the gift card. Our gift cards do not have expiration dates. Based on historical redemption rates, a small and relatively stable percentage of gift cards will never be redeemed, referred to as "breakage". Estimated breakage revenue is recognized over a period of time in proportion to actual gift card redemptions and was immaterial in 2007, 2006 and 2005.

Required:

For each note above:

1. Explain the revenue recognition rules used by the firm. As part of your explanation, prepare journal entries for each described method.

2. For each firm, are the revenue recognition methods described reasonable? Explain in detail.

3. In most cases, IFRS accounting rules provide only general revenue recognition guidelines. For the two firms above, discuss whether detailed revenue recognition rules are needed.

Reference no: EM13860978

Questions Cloud

How do i display a message in the browsers status bar : How do I display a message in the browser's status bar? What are the main differences between applets and applications?
How successfully manage conflict in organizations : What types of skills do managers need to successfully manage conflict in their organizations. Which of these skills do you possess
If the labor supply curve is very elastic : If the labor supply curve is very elastic, a tax on labor:
The deadweight loss from the new tax : Suppose a tax of $.10 per unit on a good creates a deadweight loss of $100. If the tax is increased to $0.30 per unit, the deadweight loss from the new tax would be:
Revenue recognition methods : For each firm, are the revenue recognition methods described reasonable? Explain in detail. In most cases, IFRS accounting rules provide only general revenue recognition guidelines. For the two firms above, discuss whether detailed revenue recognit..
Efficiency refers to whether market outcome is fair : Efficiency refers to whether a market outcome is fair, whereas equality refers to whether the maximum amount of output was produced from a given number of inputs. When a good is taxed, the tax revenue collected by the government equals the decrease i..
How can i connect from an applet to a database on the server : 1) How do I create an applet that accepts an unlimited number of parameters? 2) How can I connect from an applet to a database on the server?
What is the equilibrium outcome in the game? : What is the equilibrium outcome in this game?
Create a marketing letter that would be suitable for mailin : In this activity you are to create a marketing letter that would be suitable for mailing to list of customers. You may have a detailed mailing list of your network. Connect to the online help of Microsoft Word and take the Mail Merge I: Use Mail Merg..

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Accounting Basics Questions & Answers

  Jimmy co is considering a 12-year project that is estimated

jimmy co. is considering a 12-year project that is estimated to cost 900000 and has no residual value. jimmy co. seeks

  The current period statement of cash flows includes the

the current period statement of cash flows includes the flowing cash balance at the beginning of the period 409967 cash

  Rodeo corporation amended its defined benefit pension plan

rodeo corporation amended its defined benefit pension plan on january 31 2011 ti increase retirement benefits earned

  At least three recommendations you can make within the

At least three recommendations you can make, within the context of law and ethics, so each company can improve its financial health.

  Fundamental concepts and principles in accounting

Identify and explain the fundamental concepts and principles in accounting, the components of the accounting equation, the primary financial accounting equation, and financial statements and reports.

  A television set costs 500 in the united states the same

a television set costs 500 in the united states. the same set costs 550 euros in france. if purchasing power parity

  Sell or process further

Sell or Process Further

  In a process cost system costs are tracked through a

in a process cost system costs are tracked through a series of connected manufacturing processes or departments rather

  Use apa style on margins, fonts

Write a memo identifying the legal ISSUE(s), conclusion, list of relevant authorities, discussion of the law, and the application of the law. Use the headings on page 149 of the text.

  System of internal accounting control

The FCPA requires that a system of internal accounting control:

  Costs incurred to date 280000 600000 785000 estimated costs

costs incurred to date 280000 600000 785000 estimated costs yet to be incurred 520000 200000 0 customer billings to

  Destruction of properties due to war revolution and other

some of the risks that a u.s. based mnc can encounter in its foreign investments arei- an increase in the cost of

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd