Management are two distinct but complementary systems

Assignment Help Operation Management
Reference no: EM131133459

Read the mini-case, Leadership and Management *BELOW* answer the questions at the end:

"Leadership and Management are two distinct but complementary systems. While managers promote stability, leaders press for change. Only organizations that can embrace both sides of that contradiction can thrive in turbulent times" (Kotter, 1995)

1. Describe a position that you believe calls for leadership. Describe a position that you believe calls for management.

2. Make a list of what you believe are leadership task and another list of what are management tasks.

3. Evaluate the two lists. Do you find it difficult to clearly separate the lists or do some tasks seem to fit on both lists? Explain.

*TEXT BELOW*

Leadership and Management

In trying to answer “What is leadership?” it is natural to look at the relationship between leadership and management. To many, the word management suggests words like efficiency, planning, paperwork, procedures, regulations, control, and consistency. Leadership is often more associated with words like risk taking, dynamic, creativity, change, and vision. Some say leadership is fundamentally a value-choosing, and thus a value-laden, activity, whereas management is not. Leaders are thought to do the right things, whereas managers are thought to do things right. Here are some other distinctions between managers and leaders:

• Managers administer; leaders innovate.

• Managers maintain; leaders develop.

• Managers control; leaders inspire.

• Managers have a short-term view; leaders, a long-term view.

• Managers ask how and when; leaders ask what and why.

• Managers imitate; leaders originate.

• Managers accept the status quo; leaders challenge it.

Zaleznik goes so far as to say these differences reflect fundamentally different personality types: leaders and managers are basically different kinds of people. He says some people are managers by nature; other people are leaders by nature. One is not better than the other; they are just different. Their differences, in fact, can be useful because organizations typically need both functions performed well. For example, consider again the U.S. civil rights movement in the 1960s. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. gave life and direction to the civil rights movement in America. He gave dignity and hope of freer participation in national life to people who before had little reason to expect it. He inspired the world with his vision and eloquence, and he changed the way we live together. America is a different nation today because of him. Was Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. a leader? Of course. Was he a manager? Somehow that does not seem to fit, and the civil rights movement might have failed if it had not been for the managerial talents of his supporting staff. Leadership and management complement each other, and both are vital to organizational success.

Reference no: EM131133459

Questions Cloud

Take few moments to bring to mind managers : Take a few moments to bring to mind managers with whom you have worked over the years. Which of those managers do you consider to have been the best decision manager? Label this manager BDM, for obvious reasons. Which of those individuals do you rega..
Explain the terms products-services and experiences : Explain the terms Products, Services, and Experiences. What do you understand by Levels of Product and Services. Identify and explain The new-product development process.
Equity alliance and nonequity alliance-joint venture : Nonequity Alliance - Cooperation between firms is managed directly through contracts, without cross-equity holdings or an independent firm being created. Equity Alliance - Cooperative contracts are supplemented by equity investments by one partner in..
Identify and draw an improved layout : The administrator of the Life-Time Insurance Company HMO, Ms. Taylor, was anxious to solve potential problems before their new clinic opened in Austin, Texas. In Buffalo, New York, where the original clinic is located, the pharmacy had been extremely..
Management are two distinct but complementary systems : "Leadership and Management are two distinct but complementary systems. While managers promote stability, leaders press for change. Only organizations that can embrace both sides of that contradiction can thrive in turbulent times"  Describe a positio..
Traditional major in marketing or accounting : For students not wanting a traditional major in marketing or accounting, for example, the college decided to create a general business major, which allowed any combination of the easiest business courses to comprise the program. The competitive prior..
Business focusing on increasing the efficiency : A business focusing on increasing the efficiency of its operations is more directly addressing:
The foundations of modern manufacturing : The foundations of modern manufacturing and technological breakthroughs were inspired by the creation of the mechanical computer by:
Competitive priorities : Competitive priorities:

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Operation Management Questions & Answers

  Discuss whether or not there is an enforceable contract

The Writing Requirement: Jason Novell, doing business as Novell Associates, hired Barbara Meade to work for him. The parties orally agreed on the terms of employment, including payment of a share of the company's income to Meade, but they did not put..

  What amount of safety stock is necessary for the fastener

An automobile manufacturer orders a specific fastener from the same supplier every 4 weeks. Lead time is 1 week. The supply chain manager must determine how many fasteners to order. A check of stock reveals 10 boxes on hand, each containing 200 units..

  What role does corporate governance play in strategic plan

What is corporate governance? need help with this part - What role does corporate governance play in strategic planning? Why is it important?

  Under armor manufacture to maximize the total profit

Under Armour manufactures two kinds of sneakers, each requiring a different manufacturing technique. Each male sneaker requires 25 hours of labor, 8 hours of testing, and yields a profit of $350. How many of each kind of sneaker should Under Armor ma..

  The aviation industry has several distinct segments

The aviation industry has several distinct segments. Briefly describe the segments and the labor laws and practices identified with each.

  A basic requirement for operating with the low inventories

A basic requirement for operating with the low inventories present in lean systems is. inventory space must be increased. inventory investment must be increased. major problems must be identified.

  He then sells the crop at the local farmers market

Felicien grows mirlitons (that's Cajun for Chayote squash) in his 100 by 100 foot garden. He then sells the crop at the local farmers' market. Two summers ago, he was able to produce and sell 1200 pounds of mirlitons. Last summer, he tried a new fert..

  What were the reasons for the change

Discuss a situation when a leader refused to change their leadership style or did not recognize a need for change in order to achieve desired results. What were the reasons for the change? What were the results?

  What is the appropriate reorder point quantity

A newspaper publisher uses roughly 820 feet of baling wire each day to secure bundles of newspapers while they are being distributed to carriers. The paper is published Monday through Saturday. Lead time is six workdays. What is the appropriate reord..

  Would an increase in european wealth

Would an increase in European wealth, all other factors held constant, cause the dollar to depreciate or appreciate in the foreign exchange market?

  Determine the economic order quantity

A jewelry firm buys semiprecious stones to make bracelets and rings. The supplier charges $20 per stone, annual carrying costs are 50%, and the cost of processing orders is $40. The jewelry firm operates 200 days per year and their usage rate is 3..

  Discuss the concept of transportation demand

Discuss the concept of transportation demand in relation to derived demand and its importance in the area of transportation for shippers and carriers. Provide at least two examples. Explain the difference between elastic and inelastic demand.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd