Item is to identify causes of erp implementation

Assignment Help Basic Computer Science
Reference no: EM13936652

This assessment is worth 45% of the total available marks for this course. The purpose of this assessment item is to identify causes of ERP implementation failure at Waste Management Company and provide possible solutions which can be used for future implementations.

Background to the Case Study

Be aware that the case outline below is brief. This has been done on purpose to challenge you to research and investigate the case as thoroughly as possible in order to mount and justify your argument. You should find the web useful in this regard. However, you are also required to investigate and use other sources including academic literature.

The Case

A Houston-based Waste Management Company (WMC) signed a purchase agreement for a new revenue management system (ERP) in October 2005 with a well-known ERP vendor SAP AG. In 2006, WMC filed a case against the ERP vendor SAP for a complete failure of a $100 million ERP software implementation. It also alleged that SAP executives participated in a fraudulent sales scheme by describing the Waste and Recycling version of its ERP application as "tested, working solution" and this product would be delivered within 18 months from the purchase date. However, SAP fired back, claiming that Waste Management violated its contractual agreement with SAP by "failing to timely and accurately define its business requirements" and not providing "sufficient, knowledgeable, decision-empowered users and managers" to work on the project.

WMC claimed it suffered significant damages, including more than US$100 million it spent on the project, as well as more than $350 million for benefits it would have gained if the software had worked as intended. In the end, SAP made a one-time cash payment to Waste Management under the confidential settlement's terms.

In general ERP vendors provide basic software that can be modified to suit existing business processes "OR" modify their own business processes to suit the proposed system. Claims made by WMC indicate that they were expecting SAP to deliver already developed product without realising that it was a prototype. As we are not clear about the facts, it can be assumed that SAP was planning to develop a customised solution to meet WMC's needs, but failed to deliver a customised solution within 18 months, due to lack of support and information about current business practices at WMC.

Your Task

You have been asked to prepare a report identifying the causes of failure and recommendations to adopt a new ERP system.
You need to thoroughly research, mount and justify proposed solutions for successful implementation of an ERP system. Your report should include discussion and arguments with suitable evidence about the following:

a) Major causes of ERP implementation failure
b) Use of prototype in ERP selection process, benefits and challenges with converting prototype into a working system.
c) Detail the importance of Introducing an ERP that requires changing business processes to match the system functionality, or
d) Customise the software to match the business processes.

In justifying your argument you need to take into consideration the problems experienced by Waste Management Company. Successful arguments can be made both ways.

Your task is simply this: to present a persuasive and argumentative piece of writing in report form. The report should be directed at senior managers with a limited understanding of technology and ERP systems. The report should contain information pertaining to the risks and benefits of your selected option, from which you are expected to draw and justify your own conclusion.

Hints
Your report should follow the following structure:
Executive Summary
This is a concise summary of the purpose of the report. It includes brief recommendations / conclusions.
Introduction
This section describes purpose and structure of the report: it sets out how the report is to be presented and what will be discussed. You need to clearly state which option you will be arguing for.

Discussion

This section should begin with a brief outline the two options and what the key impacts of each would be. You should then present a detailed analysis of the risks and benefits of your preferred option. Suitable examples and information from academic and trade literature should be used to illustrate and support your discussion. The aim of the discussion is to prove the case for your argument: it is important that the argument and supporting literature is relevant. Remember, as you build your discussion, you need to build the argument for your preferred option.

There are a number of points that you may want to consider in order to fully explore the risks and benefits of your preferred option, including (but not limited to):
· Technical Benefits
· Organisational Benefits
· Cost Benefits
· Operational Benefits
· Future Benefits
· Implementation Challenges
· Technical Challenges
· Change Challenges
· Operational Challenges
· Future Challenges

Those students focusing on achieving very high marks may wish to explore some of the socio-technical impacts of the case. These may include issues relating to power, politics, control, culture and change.

Reference no: EM13936652

Questions Cloud

The cost of having the tree removedwould : Suppose that your neighbor owns an old tree, with branches that extend over yourlawn. He enjoys having the tree, getting utility of $100, and incurring $65 ofcleanup costs on his own lawn. However, the tree drops leaves and crabapples onyour lawn, wh..
Identify structure and function of main organs in organisms : Identify the structure and function of the main organs in two organisms that live in the Great Barrier Reef, and indicate why are they suited for that environment.
What is an adaptive radiation : What is an adaptive radiation? Whey did reptiles undergo an adaptive rediation about 250 million years ago? What anatomical and physiological characterics, which amphibians don't possess, enabled reptiles to more fully take advantage of terrestial..
Program that is supposed to search message.txt and print out : I'm having trouble with a program that is supposed to search message.txt and print out the message. i will upload instructions. We must use functions, and we were not instructed on how to search char arrays for this purpose and I am lost. Your hel..
Item is to identify causes of erp implementation : This assessment is worth 45% of the total available marks for this course. The purpose of this assessment item is to identify causes of ERP implementation failure at Waste Management Company and provide possible solutions which can be used for fut..
What is the selling price per unit : What operating profit percentage on revenues is needed to attain the target return on investment of 20%? What is the selling price per unit?
Compare the designations of threatened, endangered : Identify and discuss four ways in which forest trees are currently harvested. Which method is the most ecologically sound, and why? Which method is the most economical?
Set of experience knowledge structure : Set of Experience Knowledge Structure (SOEKS) is knowledge representation in an artificial system that would support discovering, adding, storing and sharing knowledge through experience in a similar way that humans DNA do. SOEKS is then later car..
Write a program to do calculations with a 2-d array : You are to development the following functions to support this effort. Write a function for each of the following actions.

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Basic Computer Science Questions & Answers

  Discuss and explain the emerging information needs

Discuss and explain the emerging information needs

  Write a select statement that returns four columns

Write a Select statement that returns four columns from the Invoices table, named Number, Total, Credits, and Balance

  Provide a money transfer system using sms technology

Instructions: Your financial firm has a contract to provide a money transfer system using SMS technology for a global retail outlet chain. You have been selected to create a draft security policy for the new system utilizing the CIAA strategy. ..

  Which interarrival time gives the maximum throughput

Which interarrival time gives the maximum throughput?

  Two instance variables

Two instance variables

  Solve the following logcal problems

Solve the following logcal problems: a. 10110001 OR 00011010 b. 11100110 XOR 10111011

  What is the paintcomponent method

How does a program intentionally cause the paintComponent method to execute?

  Design a step by step algorithm

Design a step by step algorithm, keeping in mind the limitations of assembly language, to determine the physical address of the 3rd byte of the data segment variable LIST in the following code example.

  Make the table in the format

Make the table in the format : table_name

  Analyze hardware virtualization

Determine if you would prefer a virtualized environment to a non-virtualized environment for a midsized business or organization and explain why or why not. Compare the cloud computing cost models used by Amazon EC2 and Microsoft Azure.

  Compare the it field with at least one other field

In relation to the IT field, what benefits and problems do you foresee in using e-mail and text messaging as the main source of communication? Compare the IT field with at least one other field.

  The capabilities of today''s smartphones

20 years ago, no one could have predicted the capabilities of today's smartphones. 10 years ago, when the smartphones of today were in their infancy, there were hints and clues about the future, but no one knew for sure exactly how it would all devel..

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd