Is the article scientifically accurate

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM131010947

You must complete peer reviews for TWO different articles. To complete a review, log onto Box (https://box.osu.edu), go into our class folder named "ScienceBite Articles ENR2100 Sp16" and locate the article that you were assigned to review (see Excel Spread Sheet titled "Assigned Peer Reviews"). If you cannot find the article PDF that you were assigned, try to find the PDF again. If you still cannot find the article it likely means that it was never submitted so you must pick another article to review. Pick any article you want.

Open the article that you were assigned in Box and read the article. As you read the article, answer all the questions (A-D) listed below. Enter all of the questions (A-D below) and your responses using the Comments Tab of Box. To do this, simply click the Add a comments tab at the top right and Enter Comment. Type your comments and then click the Post Comment button when you're done and you have successfully completed one review.

Below are the questions that you should address in your peer review. You MUST answer ALL the questions (A-D) below as you write your comments. Your comments should NOT be a one or two word response, but rather should be complete sentences that are thorough and detailed in the feedback that they provide.

A. Intellectual Impact of the Article

1. How well does the article function as a piece of writing (i.e. quality of language, exposition, description, voice)?

2. Is the article scientifically accurate?

3. Does the design, flow and the creativity of the article encourage learning?

B. Broader Impact of the Article

1. How well does the article function as a piece of teaching (i.e. quality of pedagogy, clarity of explanations)? Does the article tell a nice story and teach you something new? Is the article too general and/or lack details that would make the story more educational?

2. Does the article contain all the necessary components needed to describe the story or are some things missing that could enhance the story?

C. Technical Details of the Article

1. Has the author included at least ten sources and at least 6 from primary journals?

2. Has the author included at least 4 high-quality figures and/or tables? Did the author provide a reference for each and every figure and/or table? Could the figures be improved, if so how can they be improved?

3. Has the author properly referenced their sources throughout their article with either a number or using author's last name?

4. Is the article approximately 1,000 words long?

D. Based on your answers above, what is your final recommendation?

1. Publish the article in its current state (the article is excellent).

2. Publish the article with minor revisions (the article is very good).

3. Publish the article after major revisions are made to it. The article needs substantial work before it is ready for publication. This could include major changes required to fix figures and tables, or major changes required to large portions of the text. Does the author need to start over completely?

Attachment:- Article.rar

Reference no: EM131010947

Questions Cloud

What is its expected dividend payout ratio : Flavortech expects EBIT of $2,000,000 for the current year. The firm's capital structure consists of 40% debt and 60% equity and its marginal tax rate is 40%. The cost of equity is 14% and the company pays a 10% rate on its $5,000,000 of long term de..
What is its economic value added : Spencer Inc has the following information for the current year: Net income=$600; Net operating profit after taxes (NOPAT) = $600; Total assests = $4,000; short term investments = $500; stockholders equity =$2000; debt=$1000; and total net operating c..
Face value zero-coupon bonds : The MerryWeather Firm wants to raise $29 million to expand its business. To accomplish this, the firm plans to sell 15-year, $1,000 face value zero-coupon bonds. The bonds will be priced to yield 7 percent. What is the minimum number of bonds the fir..
What is the default risk premium : 10-year T Bonds have a yield of 5.3% and 10 year corporate bonds yield 6.75%. Also, corporate bonds have a .25% liquidity premium versus a zero liquidity premium for T-bonds, and the maturity risk premium on both Treasure and corporate 10 year bonds ..
Is the article scientifically accurate : Intellectual Impact of the Article: How well does the article function as a piece of writing (i.e. quality of language, exposition, description, voice)? Is the article scientifically accurate
What is the free cash flow for the current year : Bates Motors has the following information for the previous year: net income = $200; net operating profit after taxes (NOPAT) = $300; Total assets = $1,000 and total net operating capital = $800. The information for the current year is: net income =$..
Target capital structure-marginal cost of equity capital : allison Engines Corporation has established a target capital structure of 40 % debt and 60% common equity. The firm expects to earn $600 in after tax income during the coming year and it will retain 40% of those earnings. the current market price of ..
Implementation of the law of comparative advantage : Evaluate the extent to which the bargaining model can be viewed as a practical implementation of the law of comparative advantage - The ability to be selective rather than just descriptive.
Explain how the services and products are financed or paid : Identify the roles of various stakeholders and emerging roles within the health care service provider selected.  Explain how the services and products are financed or paid

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Develop marketing plan for product or service of your choice

Develop a marketing plan for a product or service of your choice offered in the Northern Territory.

  Explain the importance of active listening in the workplace

Write a 700- to 1,050 word essay in which you do the following: Explain the importance of active listening in the workplace. Explain how supportive and defensive climates can improve relations in the workplace

  Briefly explain how earths atmosphere is heated

Briefly explain how Earth’s atmosphere is heated. What are the two gases that absorb most of Earth's outgoing radiation? In general, what wavelength of radiation do they absorb? What were the starting and ending temperatures you obtained for the wate..

  Among twin- income and dual-career families do you think

respond to the following questions among twin- income and dual-career families do you think there will ever be an equal

  Similar prenatal environment

Identical twins are most likely to share a similar prenatal environment if they share the same. Children tend to organize their words into male and female categories. This best illustrated their use of

  Health promotion and wellness

Health Promotion and Wellness

  Analyze the symbolism and imagery in the swimmer

analyze the symbolism/imagery in "The Swimmer." You could go a lot of different directions with this topic, but you might consider relating the symbolism to Neddy as a character and/or to his journey.

  Influence the relationship to serves shareholders interests

There is evidence that there is a direct and positive relationship between a firm’s size and top-level manager’s compensation what advantages, benefits, or incentives what relationship provides to upper-level executives, recommend what could be done ..

  Who studies personality

Who studies personality? Give a brief description of each of the 6 theoretical approaches (i.e., psychoanalytic – Freudian & neo-Freudian, trait, biological humanistic, behavioral/social & cognitive)

  Peripheral consideration of personal liability protection

What is the negative or downside to personal liability protection? What is one peripheral consideration of personal liability protection? Define the concept of “going naked” in terms of personal civil liability protection.

  Rogers and freud disagree

About which of the following statements would rogers and Freud disagree?

  Explain the significance of the cobbler and the machine

Compare the messages about the influence of power on innocent people using "The Old Chief Mshlanga" and "I'm Not Talking About That, Now". Explain the significance of "The Cobbler and the Machine" as it represents the realities and consequences of ..

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd