Identify the tax issues
Course:- Taxation
Reference No.:- EM13407

Assignment Help
Assignment Help >> Taxation

Part A

Explain why the payment to the taxpayer in FCT v Dixon (1952) 86 CLR 540 was assessable income but the payment in Scott v FCT (1966) 117 CLR 514 was not.

In your answer you should include (but not necessarily be limited to) the following:

i) A brief statement in your own words of the facts of the cases.

ii) Identify the issues raised and the relevant legislation in the context of ITAA97.

iii) Identify any cases and other sources of information relevant to the issues and legislation.

iv) Apply the law to the facts stating clearly why one taxpayer was assessable and the other was not.

Part B

Nigel is a professional percussionist and performs with a number of bands and orchestras. In order to practice, he set aside a special room in his house that is soundproof and contains a variety of electronic sound equipment. The room is used only for practice or performance related purposes. He pays council rates, interest on the house mortgage, repairs and maintenance, electricity and telephone expenses in connection with the house. He believes he should be able to claim tax deductions for all these costs together with depreciation on the room and equipment.

Explain the tax position to Nigel. In you answer you should:

i) Identify the tax issues that are raised and the relevant sections of the legislation.

ii) Identify any cases and other sources of law or information that apply.

iii) Apply the law to the facts.

iv) Express a conclusion in regard to the issues identified and indicate any other information required.

Put your comment

Ask Question & Get Answers from Experts
Browse some more (Taxation) Materials
Discuss whether or not the three payments are income from personal exertion. Would your answer differ if she wrote the story for her own satisfaction and only decided to sell
Using tax cash flows and no debt (pure equity), is prospect a positive NPV using ROE as the hurdle rate? Using the after tax cash flows and the firm's WACC, is this project
Marie and Ethan form Roundtree Corporation with the transfer of the following. Determine Marie and Ethan's current income, gain, or loss; calculate the basis that each t
As you review the tax burden consisting of income tax and sales tax, make a judgment about who in the state bears the tax burden. Is it shared equally by all citizens, more
Using an available tax service or the Internet, identify three basic tax planning ideas or tax tips suggested for year-end tax planning. Which basic tax strategy from this c
Bill (6), their son, lived with Carol the entire year. Carol has waived her right to Bill's exemption for 2015 by signing Form 8332. What is the taxpayer's correct and most f
There is a significant amount of gray area when interpreting tax regulations. There are several resources available to assist tax preparers in addressing these issues, such
Ryan, a lawyer, purchases shares of corporate stock for $20,000 in December of Year 1. At the end of Year 2, they are worth $17,000. He sells the shares in October of Year 3