Human rights violations crimes against humanity

Assignment Help Management Theories
Reference no: EM131049137

Case 31.3

FACTS The Khulumani plaintiffs, along with other plaintiff groups, filed class-action claims on behalf of victims of apartheid-related atrocities, human rights violations, crimes against humanity, and unfair and discriminatory forced-labor practices. The plaintiffs brought this action in federal district court under the Alien Tort Claims Act (ATCA) against a number of corporations, including Bank of America, Barclay National Bank, Citigroup, Credit Suisse Group, General Electric, and IBM. The district court dismissed the plaintiffs' complaints in their entirety. The court held that the plaintiffs had failed to establish subject-matter jurisdiction under the ATCA. The plaintiffs appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit.

ISSUE Can the plaintiffs bring a claim against U.S. and foreign companies under the ATCA for "aiding and abetting" human rights violations?
DECISION Yes. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit vacated the district court's dismissal of the plaintiffs' claims and remanded the case for further proceedings. According to the reviewing court, a plaintiff may plead a theory of aiding and abetting liability under the ATCA.

REASON The court stated that the district court "erred in holding that aiding and abetting violations of a customary international law cannot provide a basis for ATCA jurisdiction." The court reasoned that the United States Supreme Court has instructed courts in this nation to exercise caution and carefully evaluate international norms and potential adverse foreign policy consequences in deciding whether to hear ATCA claims. Thus, "the determination whether a norm is sufficiently definite to support a cause of action should (indeed, inevitably must) involve an element of judgment about the practical consequences of making that cause available to litigants in the federal courts." The court rejected the defendants' argument that an adjudication of the case by the U.S. court "would offend amicable working relationships with a foreign country."

FOR CRITICAL ANALYSIS-Ethical Consideration Should the companies cited as defendants in this case have refused all business dealings with South Africa during the era of apartheid when the country's white government severely limited the rights of the majority black African population?

Reference no: EM131049137

Questions Cloud

Estimated from straight-line depreciation : The maintenance costs for the gas furnace are covered under guarantee for the first five years. Themarket value of the gas furnace can be estimated from straight-line depreciation with a salvagevalue of $500 after 10 years. Using a MARR of 10 perc..
Same number of hours making toy cars : Mandy is a master wood-carver and Jerry is her apprentice. They will each work the same number of hours making toy cars. Each car requires 4 wheels and 1 body. Mandy makes wheels at the rate of 25 per hour and bodies at the rate of 10 per hour.
Preparation of a schedule of cost of goods manufactured : ACC200 Introduction to Management Accounting Group Assignment - Task Specification. Preparation of a Schedule of Cost of Goods Manufactured and Cost of Goods Sold. (The schedules may be in the appendix). Explain why some items have been excluded fr..
Bond is sold for its face value-bonds yield to maturity : A bond is sold for its face value of $1,000 with a 25-year maturity, a 9% coupon, and interest paid semiannually. The bond is callable 5 years from issuance at an 11% premium over face value. What is the bond's yield to call today if investors expect..
Human rights violations crimes against humanity : FACTS The Khulumani plaintiffs, along with other plaintiff groups, filed class-action claims on behalf of victims of apartheid-related atrocities, human rights violations, crimes against humanity, and unfair and discriminatory forced-labor practic..
Consumer responsiveness to price changes : Then tell the reader how these Determinants (or factors) affect the consumer responsiveness to price changes. Remember we discussed these significantly in our Discussion Board regarding the price of gasoline?
Implement fast-forward and reverse for mpeg streams : What problems do you run into if you limit your mechanism to displaying I frames only? If you don't, then to display a given frame in the fast-forward sequence, what is the largest number of frames in the original sequence you may have to decode?
Develop a java gui application using layout managers : COIT11134Object Oriented Programming - Develop a Java GUI application using layout managers and develop an application that uses two or more classes.
Calculate the equilibrium level of output : The economy of Yahooland is represented by the following: C=50+0.25Yd, T=1000, G=1000, I=100 (a) Calculate the equilibrium level of output. Graph your solution.

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Management Theories Questions & Answers

  Delegation affects employees

Delegation affects employees in all of the following ways except: A). increasing their motivation B).increasing their satisfaction

  Name all the basic and acidic oxides of period 3

Name all the basic and acidic oxides of period 3

  The dominant theoretical perspective on strategic management

The dominant theoretical perspective on strategic management is the Five Forces Model or framework associated with the work of Michael Porter.Critically discuss.

  Conduct a search for scholarly articles

Conduct a search for scholarly articles. Find five scholarly articles that you are interested in and provide a direct quotation with citation for each of the articles

  The average employee assigned to the concession stand

The manager must be able to solve problems, communicate, and lead teams toward the completion of a task. You are the manager of the northern branch of the Laurel City bowling alleys. The owner, Jill Espy, has 4 other bowling alleys around town. The a..

  What are the primary values of your organization

What are the primary values of your organization? How do you know? (e.g., mission statement, actions by managers)- Does your firm's culture match its professed values? What examples can you provide?

  The patriot act is coming up for a vote to renew

You are a member of Congress, and the Patriot Act is coming up for a vote to renew its provisions. What would you do and why?

  What contributed to the success of the initiative

1. Discuss an organizational change you have encountered that was successful. What contributed to the success of the initiative? What barriers were overcome to reach success?

  What is the nal of leasing

What is the NAL of leasing? (Do not round intermediate calculations and round your final answer to 2 decimal places. (e.g., 32.16)) How much debt is displaced by this lease? (Do not round intermediate calculations and round your final answer to 2..

  Identify three of the evaluation elements

Identify three of the evaluation "elements" that you believe would be among the most key indicators of a company's ability to successfully taken on a complex multi-organization EA program. Explain why you believe each of the three elements you cho..

  Southwest and value line cultures

1. List the reasons why Southwest's and Value Line's cultures differ so sharply. 2. Could Value Line's next CEO copy Southwest's culture?

  Dunn emporium experiences growth

Dunn's Emporium Experiences Growth

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd