Formulate a philisophical response

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM13520584

Consider the following two scenerios. Formulate a philisophical response as to what you would do in each situation and give your reasons why.

Imagine you are hiking in a secluded region and you come across a group of armed thugs threatening to kill 10 people, who you strongly suspect to be perfectly innocent. The thugs capture you, and the leader gives you a choice. He says if you personally kill one of the prisoners, he will let the remaining 9 go free; otherwise, he will kill all 10. He gives you a knife and two armed thugs escort you to the prisoner. What do you suspect you would do and why?

Five of your loved ones require organ transplants to survive, but you are the only suitable organ match. If you sacrifice yourself, your organs can be used to save all of them. For the sake of the thought-experiment, assume you could legally do this. Would you do this, why or why not? Does your rationale rule out a physician sacrificing you without your consent for the same purposes?

Reference no: EM13520584

Questions Cloud

Various proofs of the existence of god : After reading about the various proofs of the existence of God, identify which of these arguments seems to be the best, and explain why you think so.
What augustine means by predestination and free will : Using quotations from On Rebuke and Grace, explain what Augustine means by “predestination” and “free will.”
Why are not there more news reports about police brutality : What issue is the speaker using to take a position in the following situation? Police brutality does not happen very often. Otherwise, it would not make headlines when it does happen. Why aren't there more news reports about police brutality?
What is real and how do we know what is real : Which answer Plato and Aristotle give to these questions: What is real And How do we know what is real? How would Aristotle explain what it is to be human?
Formulate a philisophical response : Imagine you are hiking in a secluded region and you come across a group of armed thugs threatening to kill 10 people, who you strongly suspect to be perfectly innocent. The thugs capture you, and the leader gives you a choice. He says if you perso..
Difference between subjective claims and objective claims : Explain how you would teach the difference between subjective claims and objective claims to someone who had never heard of critical thinking.
A hypothetical case : A hypothetical case and question You are a medical researcher who has discovered a means to cure mentally ill people. The people you can "cure" do not know who they are or who you are.
Is being off the grid possible in your current profession : Which specific electronic device or appliance could you not live without? Could you go “off the grid”? What might be good about going off the grid? Is being off the grid possible in your current profession?
Why bother changing a corrupt constitution : Whose advice is most practical?  Why bother changing a corrupt constitution (Politeia)?

Reviews

Write a Review

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Antidiuretic hormone

Explain how antidiuretic hormone can help regulate an abnormal increase in solute concentration in the extracellular fluid.

  Minimize your travel expenditures

You have been hired by the Mid-Atlantic division of Mc Donald's restaurant corporation to improve relations with their wholesale suppliers of chicken meat. Where should you go to meet with those companies in order to minimize your travel expenditures..

  What is organizational culture

What is organizational culture? Where does it come from? The sources of differences in ethics between people, companies and nations.

  How does encapsulation assist older thinkers

How does encapsulation assist older thinkers?  Which statement between adult learners and their younger counterparts is true?  What conclusion is most accurate regarding the research on ethnic differences in practical intelligence?

  Countercurrent contactor is most effiecent

If you have to separate an ideal mixture of 3 components how many ideal separators will you use? Prove that a countercurrent contactor is most effiecent than a concurrent one

  Describe relationship among professional values-ethics

Create the 700- to 1,050-word paper in which you describe the relationship among professional values, ethics, and career success. Ensure to address following items in your explanation.

  Manipulate independent variables

What are some ways researachers can manipulate independent variables?

  In a 2-3 page paper using good apa formatting briefly

in a 2-3 page paper using good apa formatting briefly review each of the 5 actions. next create a hypothetical

  Interaction between nature and nurture shapes development

What are some examples in various domains of development (such as emotional, language, cognitive, motor, etc.) where we can clearly see how the interaction between nature and nurture shapes development?

  Expectation of development scholars

The expectation of development scholars in the 1950s was that economic growth would bring about democratization worldwide. What was the link they saw between development and democracy? Consider whether the phenomenon of bureaucratic authoritarianism ..

  What role did black abolitionists play in movement slavery

What role did black abolitionists play in the movement against slavery and how did their philosophy compare to that of William Lloyd Garrison?

  Relationships among environment-technology-carrying capacity

What generalizations can you make about the relationships among environment, technology and carrying capacity?

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd