Explain the purpose of the fourth amendment

Assignment Help Operation Management
Reference no: EM132182909

Question: The exclusionary rule prohibits the introduction of improperly seized evidence at trial. The foll...

The exclusionary rule prohibits the introduction of improperly seized evidence at trial. The following scenario illustrates how the exclusionary rule works:

Jeff owns a pawnshop with his father. Unbeknownst to Jeff, law enforcement has been investigating Jeff’s role in a motorbike theft ring. Two teams of officers stake out Jeff’s home and business around the clock. Team A’s officers frequently snoop through the windows of Jeff’s work van parked in the driveway of his home. One morning, the officers think they have hit the jackpot when they spot construction equipment in Jeff’s work van. Based on their hunch, the officers immediately seize the equipment. There was no reason to believe the evidence would be destroyed. In addition, the officers were standing on Jeff’s front lawn when they looked into the van. Jeff’s father is at home at the time and tries to no avail to convince the officers that the construction equipment belongs to him.

Meanwhile, at the pawnshop, Team B’s officers execute a search warrant based on probable cause that was established through tips from reliable police informants. What gave them probable cause? They seize the stolen motorbikes pursuant to the search warrant. They also arrest Jeff for theft of property.

At trial, the court would admit into evidence the motorbikes recovered from the pawnshop because they were seized pursuant to the search warrant. The court would exclude the construction equipment as evidence because the authorities seized it without a search warrant or a justification for seizing without a search warrant.

Consider the following scenario:

Before Simon returned home from his State B fishing trip, a State B wildlife officer, who overheard Simon’s conversation with the clerk, stopped Simon in the parking lot. As he peered through Simon’s car window, the wildlife officer asked Simon about the minnows. The wildlife officer explained that the minnows were contraband and asked Simon to turn them over so that he could confiscate them. Simon objected and told the wildlife officer that the minnows appeared to be healthy and that they were purchased from a reputable State A dealer. Simon demanded that the wildlife officer prove to him that the State A minnows had parasites. The wildlife officer declined. Eventually Simon turned over the minnows to the State B wildlife officer.

Simon feels that his Fourth Amendment rights have been violated. Is he right?

1. Explain the purpose of the Fourth Amendment.

2. Was a government actor involved in the seizure of Simon’s minnows?

3. Was there a legal basis for confiscating the minnows? Explain.

4. Did the seizure of the minnows from Simon’s car require a warrant? If not, did the confiscation of the minnows meet the warrant less search exception?

5. Did the seizure of the minnows meet the probable cause standard? Explain.

6. Explain the Fourth Amendment and how it protects citizens and others.

7. Also, analyze and conclude whether or not Simon’s Fourth Amendment rights were violated.

Reference no: EM132182909

Questions Cloud

Effective monitoring and control of the portfolio of project : You have decided to identify five project performance KPIs for effective monitoring and control of the portfolio of projects.
Negatively impact specific e-commerce business : Describe how these 3 factors may positively or negatively impact a specific e-commerce business.
Employers believe that freedom of contract should permit : Employers believe that freedom of contract should permit them to hire whom they please.
Measured the temperature of champagne bottles : For 108 consecutive days, a process engineer has measured the temperature of champagne bottles as they are made ready for serving.
Explain the purpose of the fourth amendment : Explain the purpose of the Fourth Amendment. Was there a legal basis for confiscating the minnows? Explain.
Discuss how tactical plans aretypically established : Discuss how tactical plans aretypically established? Discuss the challenges that confront middle managers charged with strategy implementation?
Emphasis in safety risk control as master degree : Can you help me find job titles that might fit under Organizational Change Leadership with emphasis in Safety Risk Control as a master degree?
Differences between serving internal and external customers : Discuss the similarities and the differences between serving internal and external customers.
What are ways to improve everything to run faster and better : Background Checks takes 2-8 days for it to come back. What are ways to improve everything to run faster and better?

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Operation Management Questions & Answers

  Use to classify employees and independent contracts

The three main tests courts use to classify employees and independent contracts are: Clarence works as an independent contractor for a law firm jointly owned and managed by Allan, Rose, and Grisham. Which of the following implications can be drawn fr..

  Describe a defining moment in your leadership career

Write a three page paper describing a defining moment in your leadership career that force you to "look in the mirror" and accept the need for personal change.

  Was the promise morally enforceable

Was the promise legally enforceable? Was the promise morally enforceable? Is it right to downsize Thompson? (Research ethical doctrines)

  What decision should be made according to the emv decision

What decision should be made according to the EMV decision rule? Solve using a decision tree.

  The idea of perceived organizational support

The idea of perceived organizational support is that if treated well, employees are motivated by.

  Health care costs are out of control

Discuss the following statement: “Health care costs are out of control in the United States, and increasing conflicts between employers and employees are likely as employers try to reduce their health-benefits costs.”

  Which map coordinates should the hub be located

Map coordinates and the shipping loads for a set of cities that we wish to connect through a central hub - Near which map coordinates should the hub be located and If the shipments from city A triple, how does this change the coordinates?

  Present for a contract to be valid is the agreement

elements that must be present for a contract to be valid is the Agreement

  Risk managers by increased importance of intangible assets

What the issues raised for risk managers by the increased importance of intangible assets?

  Pay as factor in making job decisions

As a supervisor, if you asked or surveyed your employees about the importance of pay as a factor in making job decisions, do you think employees would over-state or understate its value to them?

  Achieving success in virtual teams

Achieving Success in Virtual Teams Read the Case Study entitled, "Achieving Success in Virtual Teams" on pages 348-349. Then, answer the Questions at the end of the case. Groupon:Decisions! Decisions! Decisions!. Read the Case Study entitled,..

  Explain how has government reacted on the federal

explain how has government reacted on the federal, state, and/or local level to counter various global and domestic threats.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd