Experience of morgan spurlock

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM132204414

As noted in the syllabus, the reading for this module is pp. 51-119 of Ehrenreich's book. You also need to view the video "30 Days -- Getting by on Minimum Wage" with Morgan Spurlock.

One thing to note in this module is how the experience of Morgan Spurlock and his fiance Alex compares to the experience of Ehrenreich. As you watch the video, pay close attention to the ways that their experience is like Ehrenreich's, and the ways that it differs. We will be discussing this on the discussion board for this module.

Once again, the question of "testing" low-wage job applicants (including urine tests) comes up. At this point in the reading, Ehrenreich states what she thinks is the real purpose of these tests. Since we discussed this last week, has your perspective changed any after reading her analysis of such testing? Any way you look at it, such testing tells us something important about our society: either it is composed of many low-wage workerss who are untrustworthy, prone to theft, and likely drug abusers, or employers use these devices to maintain control and to intimidate those at the bottom rungs of our economic order. On the discussion board, I'll once again be asking you to weigh in on this question.

In addition to the usual impossibility of finding affordable housing, Ehrenreich brings in racial (and also to some degree, gender) issues in this particular reading. She chose to go to Maine because of how "white" it is. Having a smaller population of African Americans and Hispanics than her home state of Florida,she finds that racial and ethnic distinctions are less used in Maine to demarcate the lowest jobs and occupations. She also notes at one point, when she is being ignored as if "invisible" at the counter of a diner while ordering iced tea, that she might just be getting some sense of what it is like to be black in America. Thus, she raises in several ways the intersection between racial/ethnic divisions and class distinctions in our society. On the discussion board I'll be asking you to meditate on these issues she encounters.

This particular reading also addresses issues about how low-wage workers are seen or perceived by others. As a cleaning maid, she finds that some homeowners seem to enjoy seeing a cleaning lady on her knees, set up hidden cameras to "catch" any misdeeds such as stealing, and seem totally oblivious to the humanity of those who clean up after them. She also finds that, unlike waitressing, being a cleaning lady relegates one to the lowest of the low in the eyes of others, even in the eyes of other low-wage workers themselves. "They think we're stupid" is a comment that pretty well sums it up. Are such attitudes justified or not? What does this tell us about our society.

Ehrenreich also wants to debunk the notion that there is plenty of assistance available (at convenient times and ways) for those in need. She finds it practically impossible to obtain food assistance during any reasonable hours, and what she does get is unhealthy and somewhat impossible to consume in her circumstances. This again addresses a controversial question: does the U.S. give ample (many would say way too much) assistance to those at the bottom of the economic ladder? It is widely believed that our society is too generous -- the opposite of Ehrenreich's experience or belief.

And finally, this reading addresses the toll that is taken on one's self-image when you are treated as "nothing" or "invisible" or at minimum untrustworthy and unworthy. She finds her fellow cleaning maids to be dependent on and seeking approval from a "boss" that Ehrenreich finds loathsome, and mostly devoid of any sense that they deserved better. To Ehrenreich, who would love to see some "fight back" from her fellow workers, this is dispiriting.

We'll be discussing these types of issues on the Discussion Board. Remember that all discussion on this module ends at 6 PM on Saturday of this week. (Also, remember that 30% of your grade for the course depends on the quantity, and especially the quality, of your discussion participation.)

The final thing you need to do this module is write a paper in answer to the following question (paper is due by or before 6 PM Sunday, 24 hours after the discussion is due.)

QUESTION:

When she writes about the hardships that the working poor (her fellow workers) face, Barbara Ehrenreich generally does not blame the workers themselves for their major problems, Instead, she finds so many obstacles, indignities, and hardships built into the way that our society treats such workers that it appears that it is almost impossible in many cases for them to get out of poverty. Others, who don't see any big problems with the way our system treats different classes of people might view the same situation differently. They might argue that it is entirely (or primarily) the responsibility of poor workers themselves to individually better their own conditions.

Argue one side or the other of this dispute. (I know most will say it is BOTH, but I want you to take one side or the other as PRIMARILY more right than the other.) Who bears responsibility for guaranteeing a minimally decent life for the "working poor" in our society? The larger society or the workers themselves? Whichever side you take, be sure to provide evidence and strong arguments for your position, using examples from Ehrenreich's book and/or your own experiences to bolster your case. (You have until Sunday evening at 6 PM to get this paper in -- it must be submitted by then.)

Reference no: EM132204414

Questions Cloud

What types of resources does this organization : What types of resources does this organization provide to its members and others in the health care community?
Research to the widget company : Include atleast five slides that detail the recommendations you are making to the company executives.
Newspaper and circulars for advertisement : What are the costs of the advertised security training? Network certification? General computer training?
Re-write of the Plaintiff Statement of Claim : LAW3322 Assignment - Civil Procedure, University of Southern Queensland, Australia. Conduct an analysis and re-write of the Plaintiff's Statement of Claim
Experience of morgan spurlock : One thing to note in this module is how the experience of Morgan Spurlock and his fiance Alex compares to the experience of Ehrenreich. As you watch the video
Normal and crisis decision making : Explain the difference between normal and crisis decision making. Describe how decision makers use the "Boyd Cycle" to make timely and effective crisis decision
Does religion have a role in politics : Does religion have a role in politics? Why or why not? Should religion be a driving force in policy making and legislation?
Analyze the organizational structure : Choose two companies in the same industry and analyze the organizational structure (Nordstrom and Macy's)
Persuasive speech on us poverty : Just want to know if someone can do a persuasive speech on US Poverty (research), about 2 pages

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Community-based approaches to crime prevention

Examines situational, social, and community-based approaches to crime prevention. Which do you believe is the best approach to crime prevention.

  Patagonia nurtures the environment

Which approaches to employee development are used at Patagonia? How does employee development at Patagonia contribute to the company’s strategies relating to employee retention, building intellectual capital, and business growth?

  State the null hypothesis for your experiment

You conduct an experiment on a drug which is thought to enhance memory performance. The memory performance is judged using the standardized rat memory performance score (SRMP), for which a population of rats achieves on average 10.0 points, according..

  Is the team judgment appropriate in this given case

A 28-year-old male is admitted with bacterial endocarditis and needs a replacement of his prosthetic heart valve. Is the team's judgment appropriate in this case

  Emerging adulthood

What does the term emerging adulthood refer to? Do you support the concept of emerging adulthood and should it be considered a developmental stage? Explain.

  Information related to staffing levels and staffing quality

The text provide information related to staffing levels and staffing quality. Describe how Tanglewood is positioned with respect to these issues in this case. The nature of this assignment is relatively open-ended and allows you a great deal of discr..

  Describe the developmental processes

"Post a brief description of the fictional human character (i.e., cartoon character, film/TV character, virtual character) and the event/period of time.

  Explain what barrier might encounter when working with eboni

While some might question the data that supports these statements about women's experiences in society, it is clear that social workers must be sensitive to the influences of gender in their clients' lives in order to fully understand the issues t..

  Influencing group communication

What kinds of knowledge or skills might help leaders to be effective in influencing group communication?

  Describe the person background and psychological perspective

Write a 700- to 1,050-word paper in which you describe the person's background, psychological perspective, and the contribution he or she made to the field of psychology

  Explain the three tasks of adolescent development

Explain the three tasks of adolescent development that must be met in order for adolescents to experience full transition into adulthood

  What personal involvement problems would the researcher face

What personal involvement problems would the researcher face, and how could she or he avoid them. What ethical issues should the researcher take into account

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd