Ethical dilemma

Assignment Help Management Theories
Reference no: EM13803872

Ethical Dilemma

Dan Neville is the manager for a team of engineers at RFC, Inc. He is responsible for coordinating his team's efforts on a daily, weekly, and monthly basis, as well as assuring that they are keeping on schedule with teams in other offices around the country. Dan regularly communicates with his own team via e-mail, attaching memos and instructions prior to their regular face-to-face meetings. Clear, consistent, and timely communication is an essential element of Dan's job.

Dan usually has no trouble with any member of the team understanding his instructions, except for Kyle Trenton. Kyle always seems to misunderstand or misinterpret Dan's messages, even during face-to-face meetings. Kyle doesn't seem to be deliberately being obstinate; he honestly derives other meanings from Dan's communications, reading into the words Dan chooses and coming up with implied ideas that Dan never intended.

Inevitably, Dan has to meet with Kyle separately to be certain that Kyle understands the tasks at hand. If left to his own devices, Kyle wouldn't come to Dan to question his interpretation of the message, because he sincerely believes he "gets it." However, Kyle is rarely clear about Dan's meanings, and Dan must devote extra time and energy to reorient Kyle. Dan tries to be sympathetic, because Kyle is a nice person and a good worker, but Kyle requires twice as much time from Dan as everyone else and it is frustrating. Dan does worry that if Kyle would happen to misunderstand critical directions on a building project which are not corrected, someone could legitimately get hurt.

Dan has an opportunity to move Kyle onto a new position, where he would no longer have to work with Dan's current team and Dan would no longer have to communicate with Kyle. However, Dan knows that Ken Rothberg is the head of that team, and Ken is known for being a very poor communicator. Dan suspects that Ken wouldn't take any additional time to make certain that Kyle understood his instructions, and that could cause even more critical problems.
Questions:
Using consequential, rule-based and character theories (Chapter 2), evaluate Dan's options.
What should Dan do? Why? 

Reference no: EM13803872

Questions Cloud

Cost/managerial accounting exam : There should be 3-5 story problem type managerial/cost accounting problems (along with some multiple choice). The subject matter it's over is budgeting, product mix, LOTS on variance, allocating cost pools, ROI and other calculations. So please know ..
A wholesale distributor of consumer goods : The following data relate to the operations of Lim Corporation, a wholesale distributor of consumer goods: Current assets as of December 31:Cash $6,000 Accounts receivable $36,000 Inventory $9,800
Time value of money what will be the net present value : Time Value of Money- Deli Case The answer is already given, so step by step on arriving on that answer is required Christina hopes to open a Deli in 2015.The initial  investment will be $85,000.  She expects that  that the Deli will generate the posi..
What is the patient protection and health care : What is the Patient Protection and Health Care Affordability Law? Look it up online, and describe how this law will affect you in the next 5 years.
Ethical dilemma : Dan Neville is the manager for a team of engineers at RFC, Inc. He is responsible for coordinating his team's efforts on a daily, weekly, and monthly basis, as well as assuring that they are keeping on schedule with teams in other offices around the ..
For the year that ended in january 2000 walmart had revenu : For the year that ended in January 2000, Wal-Mart had revenues of $165 billion.  For the year ended in January 2012, it had revenues of $447 billion.  What has been the average compound growth rate?
What is integrative bargaining : What is integrative bargaining? When does it occur? What are the five "buckets" in a bucket bargaining model? What are AWLMCs? Explain their activities. How do gain-sharing plans benefit both employers and employees? What are the three components of ..
Classify the organization''s ethical orientation : How would you classify the organization's ethical orientation? What stage of moral development is it in? Overall, would you characterize the climate as positive or negative? Why? What factors shape the moral atmosphere? What role have leaders played ..
Registration of securities by the sec indicates to investors : True or false Registration of securities by the SEC indicates to investors that the risk of those securities is reasonable

Reviews

Write a Review

Management Theories Questions & Answers

  Ompanies that focus on shareholder value

Critique the following statement: "Companies that focus on shareholder value create healthier companies."

  Culture-sensitize its staff

What can a company do to culture-sensitize its staff?

  Describe lewin''s three-step change process

Describe Lewin's three-step change process

  Analyze most effective methods of competitive intelligence

Examples and also identify where the resources can be found to support your work. Research the various methods different companies use to gather competitive intelligence and then analyze the most effective methods by which companies should gather c..

  How is an organization like an iceberg

How is an organization like an iceberg? Use the iceberg metaphor to describe the field of organizational behavior.

  Demographic change

Demographic change means that developed countries often suffer from an aging population while developing countries are experiencing rapid population growth.

  Case study manage their own emotions on the job

To what extent do the three people featured in this case study manage their own emotions on the job. How would they accomplish this. To what extent do you think they effectively manage emotions under these circumstances

  What errors could arise in the way google collects performan

What errors could arise in the way Google collects performance data on managers? How could it be minimize these errors?

  Organizational behavior

Thesis paper using Kreitner 10th edition Organizational Behavior 10 pages including abstract page using APA format and citing correctly with 98% originality

  Electronic health records

Electronic Health Records

  An employee files a complaint with osha

If an employee files a complaint with OSHA, under which of the following would they be protected?

  Covers all three experiments

Write a complete laboratory report that covers all three experiments

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd