Estimated the produce actual market value

Assignment Help Management Theories
Reference no: EM131049129

Case 31.2

FACTS Between 1987 and 1990, Inn Foods, Inc., imported frozen produce from six Mexican growers who agreed to issue invoices that understated the value of the produce. For each understated invoice, Inn Foods sent an order confirmation that estimated the produce's actual market value. Inn Foods later remitted the difference to the growers. Through this doubleinvoicing system, Inn Foods under valued its purchases by approximately $3.5 million and paid lower tariff taxes as a result. During an investigation by U.S. Customs and Border Protection, Inn Foods' accounting supervisor denied the existence of the double invoices. The federal government filed an action in the U.S. Court of International Trade against Inn Foods. The court held the defendant liable for fraud and assessed the amount of the unpaid taxes-$624,602.55-plus an additional penalty of $7.5 million. Inn Foods appealed, claiming that it had acted negligently, not fraudulently.

ISSUE Does an importer's use of a double-invoicing system constitute proof of an intent to defraud the government of import duties?

DECISION Yes. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit affirmed the lower court's judgment.

REASON The court reasoned that the evidence showed Inn Foods "knowingly entered goods by means of a material false statement." Each grower sent Inn Foods a copy of an undervalued invoice. The company knew that these invoices were "grossly undervalued and false"-the growers set out the details of the specific undervaluation in correspondence to Inn Foods. On receipt, Inn Foods adjusted the prices to reflect their true estimated value. The company entered the higher amount into its accounting system, sent a confirmation to the grower with the higher price, and paid the grower based on the confirmed price. But Inn Foods knew the false invoices would be used to import goods into the United States. The company used the undervalued invoices to declare the value of the produce to U.S. Customs and Border Protection for import. Moreover, Inn Foods concealed the existence of the double invoices during the government's investigation.

FOR CRITICAL ANALYSIS-Ethical Consideration After Inn Foods learned of the investigation, the company included a disclaimer on some shipments stating that the declared value "is strictly for customs clearance" while the company determines the "true transaction value." Does this disclaimer legally or ethically absolve the importer of intent to defraud?

Reference no: EM131049129

Questions Cloud

Calculate the equilibrium level of output : The economy of Yahooland is represented by the following: C=50+0.25Yd, T=1000, G=1000, I=100 (a) Calculate the equilibrium level of output. Graph your solution.
Describe what is meant by a publications departments : Describe what is meant by a publication's "departments". To insert a single dash instead of a hyphen in InDesign use: It's a good idea to include which elements on the contents page? (check all that apply).
What is the external rate of return : Aerotron Electronics is considering purchasing a water filtration system to assist in circuit board manufacturing. The system costs $40,000. It has an expected life of 7 years, at which time its salvage value will be $7,500. Operating and maintenance..
Determine average compression rate for each type of frame : The mpeg stat program can be used to display statistics for video streams
Estimated the produce actual market value : FACTS Between 1987 and 1990, Inn Foods, Inc., imported frozen produce from six Mexican growers who agreed to issue invoices that understated the value of the produce. For each understated invoice, Inn Foods sent an order confirmation that estimate..
Events on the aggregate expenditure : Explain and illustrate using the Keynesian model (AE/Y diagram) the effect of the following events on the Aggregate Expenditure (AE) curve and income.
Large lump sum deposit today instead of annual deposits : You would like to have $56,000 in 12 years. To accumulate this amount you plan to deposit each year an equal sum in the bank, which will earn 6 percent interest compounded annually. Your first payment will be made at the end of the year. If you decid..
What is the bonds yield to call today if investors expect : A bond is sold for its face value of $1,000 with a 25-year maturity, a 9% coupon, and interest paid semiannually. The bond is callable 5 years from issuance at an 11% premium over face value. What is the bond's yield to call today if investors expect..
What happens to the file size : Compress some already compressed files (try compressing with the same utility several times in sequence). What happens to the file size?

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Management Theories Questions & Answers

  The chesapeake chicken plant employs

The Chesapeake Chicken plant employs 5,000 workers in Thailand.  People come from all over the country to work at this plant. Chesapeake is known for hiring illegal aliens to work at the plant, but this has never been proven. You have been hired by C..

  Constitutes the major motif of the social history

It has been written, "The attempt of persons to understand the forces remaking their world and, by organization, to control them, constitutes the major motif of the social history of the late 19th century." Describe how this statement applies to work..

  Analyse the situation and the effect of the change request

Analyse the situation and the effect of the change request on the schedule, cost, and features.

  Analyse the australian car manufacturing industry

Your mission is to analyse the Australian car manufacturing industry by performing a 5 forces analysis and a life cycle analysis.  You may examine other industries if agreed to by your lecturer.

  Case sturdy malpo building the future

Case Sturdy. Malpo: Building the future

  Use of the technology s-curve model

Importing countries may use tariffs as a retaliatory measure against other nations as to ensure freely trading and efficient markets. However, are such uses of tariffs deemed as justifiable?

  The president of a multi hospital system

You are the president of a multi hospital system that is growing at a rapid pace. There are strains on resources, and pressures to find new ways to achieve an economic scale in operations. In a meeting with the staff, a suggestion was made to ..

  You manage a security team that is responsible for

a. you manage a security team that is responsible for protecting a centralized warehouse that distributes electronic

  Distinguish between autocratic leadership and democracy

Distinguish between autocratic leadership and democracy

  How japanese culture affect their corporate management style

Discuss how both Woodford and Kikukawa could have acted differently to resolve the prob- lems that Woodford had uncovered. Research what has happened with Olympus since this case was written in late 2012.

  Define what a value chain dispersal and integration strategy

Think about its objectives, how it chose its countries, what opportunities and constraints were apparent at the time, and what it needed to do to succeed in those markets.

  A legal way to increase market share advertising

A legal way to increase market share Advertising

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd