Does the fourth amendment protect text messages sent

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM131446908

Assignment

In this assignment, you will be a Supreme Court Justice deciding on a Fourth Amendment case. Carefully read about the case in question, the summaries of related Supreme Court decisions, and directions for the assignment.

The Case "Doe v. City of Intrusia":

Trouble was brewing in the small, quiet city of Intrusia. Someone was selling methamphetamine to the local teenagers and a popular football player died after an overdose. The community was panicked and demanded that the police find the source of the meth and shut it down immediately. The police suspected that 20 year old Joe Doe was selling the meth but they didn't have much evidence.

The state prosecutor advised the police department to talk with the local cell phone carrier about "cloning" Mr. Doe's phone. The cell phone carrier created a "clone" phone which allowed the police to read text messages sent and received by Mr. Doe. In no time the police had evidence implicating Mr. Doe as a dealer and the location of the meth lab. Mr. Doe was convicted and the meth lab was closed.

Mr. Doe is appealing his conviction, claiming that the interception of text messages violated the unreasonable search and seizure protections of the Fourth Amendment. Furthermore, all evidence from the text messages should have been excluded from his trial.

The City of Intrusia argues that there was no physical intrusion into Mr. Doe's space and that police were acting quickly in order to uphold their duty to protect the community's safety.

Background:

In Silverman v. United States the Supreme Court held that that the Fourth Amendment does not protect conversations, therefore wiretapping does not constitute a search and seizure. The case was reversed in Katz v. United States, when Justice Harlan proposed a two pronged test of whether public actions should be considered private and therefore protected. 1) Has the person exhibited an expectation of privacy? and 2) is the expectation of privacy one that society is prepared to recognize as 'reasonable.'

In more recent decisions, the Supreme Court has found that society is not prepared to extend privacy rights to bank customers regarding their bank statements and that society was not prepared to recognize a privacy right-to grow a backyard crop of marijuana.

The Questions:

• Does the Fourth Amendment protect text messages sent over a cell phone?

• Is there a "reasonable expectation of privacy" when texts are sent?

o Did Mr. Doe exhibit an expectation of privacy when he sent the texts?

o Is there a societal expectation of privacy in the process of text messaging?

Related Supreme Court Decisions (each case is linked to a short description on Oyez.com):

Olmstead v. United States (1928)

Did the use of evidence disclosed in wiretapped private telephone conversations; violate the recorded party's Fourth and Fifth Amendments?
Katz v. United States (1967)

Does the Fourth Amendment protection against unreasonable searches and seizures require the police to obtain a search warrant in order to wiretap a public pay phone?

United States v. Miller (1975)

Were Miller's bank records illegally seized in violation of the Fourth Amendment?

Smith v. Maryland (1979)

Does the installation and use of a pen register constitute a search under the Fourth Amendment?

California v. Ciraolo (1986)

Did the warrantless, aerial observation of Ciraolo's back yard from an altitude of 1,000 feet constitute an illegal search and violate the Fourth Amendment?

Bond v. United States (2000)

Does a law enforcement officer's physical manipulation of a bus passenger's carry-on luggage violate the Fourth Amendment's protection against unreasonable searches?

Kyllo v. United States (2001)

Does the use of a thermal-imaging device to detect relative amounts of heat emanating from a private home constitute an unconstitutional search in violation of the Fourth Amendment?

The Assignment:

• Write an opinion as if you were a judge deciding this case. Please note that the term "opinion" here does NOT mean an expression of your personal views! Instead, it means a formal statement of the legal reasons and principles defending your conclusion of whether text messages are protected under the Fourth Amendment.

• To help you in making your decision, please read the summaries of past Fourth Amendment rulings.

• As you read through the Supreme Court decisions above, look at how justices have crafted their decisions, and learn from them. Use these as models for your paper.

• Write clearly and concisely. State your decision, and defend it.

• Cite precedent and the Constitution.

• Refer to at least 3 of the cases featured above.

• Write a minimum of 500 words.

• Use college-level writing.

Reference no: EM131446908

Questions Cloud

Who is proposing the legislation : Who is proposing the legislation [Full name of PERSON] When was it proposed/enacted [Month day and year] Year only will not be accepted! What the legislation is about. Minimum 2 paragraphs.
Pick one strategic imperative that separates whole foods : Draw a partial activity map for Whole Foods based off of Harvard Case Study 705-476 (contact me for the case study); post it and address questions
Patients and organizations viewpoints : Review one of them and identify the five requirements within that consent form; explain where and how each element is noted within the actual form itself.
What were the positive aspects of the od process : This individual needs to have a minimum of 10-yrs business experience, they must have a minimum of a Bachelors Degree in a business discipline. What were the positive aspects of the OD process
Does the fourth amendment protect text messages sent : Does the Fourth Amendment protect text messages sent over a cell phone? Is there a "reasonable expectation of privacy" when texts are sent? Did Mr. Doe exhibit an expectation of privacy when he sent the texts?
What type of team is this : What type of team is this? Explain how this team will operate and mention at least two of the problems that may occur during the process.
Statements about the financial planning process : Which of the following statements about the financial planning process are true? Management must monitor operations after implementing a financial plan to detect deviations from the plan and adjust accordingly.
Discussion-emotion in the workplace : Emotional Intelligence is our ability to perceive, express, and regulate emotions effectively. You may have heard of or seen an Emotional Intelligence test on the internet.
How much in cash or securities : You are bearish on Telecom and decide to sell short 100 shares at the current market price of $50 per share. How much in cash or securities must you put into your brokerage account if the broker's initial margin requirement is 50% of the value of the..

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Evaluate the effect of organizational structure

Evaluate the effect of organizational structure and governance, culture, and social responsibility focus on what happened in your chosen situation. Recommend how you would change the organization to prevent this situation in the future.

  Provide support to clients and healthcare staff

Remote healthcare can supplement the delivery of care, providing support to clients and healthcare staff. For this project we are using the Tunstall tele-health monitoring equipment as an example of the type of equipment that is used.

  Find and research three engineering failures or disasters

Find and research three engineering failures or disasters. Write separate papers on each of the 3 events covering the following items.

  Explain solar power to audience of other scientists

Explain what you have learned about Solar Power and present it as if you were at scientific conference and were presenting your research to the audience of other scientists.

  Psychological research the experiment is highly valued

In the world of psychological research the experiment is highly valued, as it is one of the key processes we can use to determine cause and effect. Associated with cause and effect is the critical identification of the variables involved in a researc..

  Concepts and applications

Nevid, J. S. (2015). Essentials of psychology: Concepts and applications(custom package) (4th ed.). Stamford, CT: Cengage Learning. ISBN: 9781305296275.

  Analyze the cost estimating relationship method

Analyze the differences between the Cost Estimating Relationship (CER) method and the Engineered Cost Estimate method and which approach to Life-Cycle Costing (LCC) approach would be best for the business.

  What issues of transference are displayed by the client

What issues of transference are displayed by the client

  Universal declaration of human rights

Need an essay for 3 pages in Universal Declaration of human rights  to answer the following question: Is it practical or non practical to expect the rights to be informed?

  Financial interdiction and investigation

How effective is financial interdiction and investigation? What is the role of intelligence in prevention of terrorism?

  Explain the key differences between the ethnocentrism and

describe the key differences between ethnocentrism and cultural relativism. how would the two approaches understand the

  Relationship between various agencies involved in homeland

Prepare a paper of 7-9 pages that analyzes the relationship between various agencies involved in homeland security, and develop at least 3 specific strategies to improve collaboration and cooperation between the agencies.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd