Do you think the supreme court agreed to hear the case

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM131288009

Discussion Board

While thousands of court cases make their way to the Supreme Court's "desk", less than 100 are heard. Your textbook highlights the rule of four--or the idea that four justices have to agree to hear a case--but what makes a justice likely to want to hear a particular case. In the following task, you'll learn the process the Supreme Court follows in the exercises of its power of judicial review. In general, we can discuss five reasons a case may be more likely to be heard and five reasons that would make it less likely to be heard.

Criteria for Choosing a Case:

1. Solicitor General Appeals: The solicitor general is the government's top attorney, in cases where he or she appeals the case to the Supreme Court, they may be more likely to hear it.

2. Inconsistent Lower Court Rulings: If lower court rulings are all over the place, the Supreme Court might want to step in an make a consistent, final ruling.

3. Serious Departures: If lower court rulings show a serious departure from previous precedent, the Supreme Court also may want to step in to avoid confusion.

4. Key Questions: Some legal questions are too big to avoid--for instance, health care, gay marriage, school desegregation.

5. Conflict with Prior Decisions: If lower court rulings have conflicted seriously with prior decisions the Supreme Court is also likely to hear the case, this is similar to the serious departures criteria mentioned above.

Criteria for Rejecting a Case:

1. Better Case in the Pipelines: Justices pay attention to major cases working their way through the system, if a "better case" is out there, they may wait.

2. Issue Hasn't "Percolated": If an issue suddenly appears on the radar, but hasn't seen many lower court rulings or court cases, the Supreme Court is unlikely to jump in.

3. Too Many Issues: If a petition raises too many questions, the Supreme Court is likely to reject the case, they prefer to focus on one issue.

4. Bad Vehicle: Some court cases just don't make a good "vehicle" for a decision--maybe there is some situation in the original case that raises eyebrows. In this case, the justices are going to look for a "better case."

5. Frivolous Cases: Anyone can appeal a case to the Supreme Court, but frivolous cases aren't likely to be heard!

For your final discussion forum posting, I'd like you to weigh in on one of the following writs of certiorari, which have been adapted from the Street Law (Links to an external site.) organization. In the forum below, answer the following questions for ONE of the case studies:

• Do you think the Supreme Court agreed to hear the case?
• Why or why not?

Case Study #1: In the spring semester of 2002, Scott County School District instituted a policy that allowed suspicion-less campus-wide drug sweeps with drug-sniffing dogs to be conducted at local schools. At Austin High School in Austin, Indiana, one such search turned up a handgun in a student's car. The student was charged with possession of a firearm on school property. At trial, the defendant moved to suppress the handgun, arguing that it was found as a result of an illegal search.

The court denied the motion and both the court of appeals and Indiana Supreme Court affirmed that decision. The petitioner argues that the Supreme Court needs to decide whether the Fourth Amendment allows suspicion-less drug sweeps such as this at school. The respondent argues that lower courts agree that suspicion-less, warrantless searches on school grounds are reasonable. No court has held that the Fourth Amendment prohibits this type of drug sweep at school.

Case Study #2: A federal law allowed for the allocation of federal aid to provide computer equipment in public and private schools for "secular, neutral and non-ideological" programs. In Jefferson Parrish, Louisiana, about 30% of the funding allocated under this law went to private schools, many of them religiously affiliated. Several public school parents sued, arguing that the federal law allocating funds for educational materials to private schools violated the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment.

The Fifth Circuit ruled that this provision did violate the First Amendment because it was an impermissible governmental aid to religious schools. The Ninth Circuit, in analyzing the same issue in a different case, said that there was no violation of the First Amendment. A recent Supreme Court decision already decided that it was okay for public school teachers to offer remedial courses in parochial school classrooms. The Solicitor General of the U.S. filed a brief asking the Court to grant certiorari.

The best responses will reflect a knowledge of the process the Supreme Court follows in the exercise of its power of judicial review and careful application of course materials.

Reference no: EM131288009

Questions Cloud

How did it differ in italy and northern europe : How did Renaissance art and the humanist movement reflect the political, economic, and social development of the period?
What is amount and character of any income-gain recognized : Aggie Corporation made a distribution of $547,000 to Rusty Cedar in partial liquidation of the company on December 31 of this year. Rusty, an individual, owns 100 percent of Aggie Corporation. What is the amount and character (capital gain or dividen..
Training and development can be completed : How does training and development of employee's help with conflicts? What type of training and development can be completed?
Discuss the potential influences of marketing on cultures : The focus of this chapter has mainly been the influence of culture on international marketing strategies. Try also to discuss the potential influences of marketing on cultures.
Do you think the supreme court agreed to hear the case : Do you think Supreme Court agreed to hear the case? In spring semester of 2002, Scott County School District instituted a policy that allowed suspicion-less campus-wide drug sweeps with drug-sniffing dogs to be conducted at local schools.
Same benefits to domestic partners : Once you have chosen a side, research the issue to find facts to support your belief. Prepare a one page executive summary and a cover letter addressed to the Director of Human Resources, detailing three to five arguments in support of your belief..
Different alternatives for redeeming some shares of stock : Bonnie and Clyde are the only two shareholders in Getaway Corporation. Bonnie owns 64 shares with a basis of $3,200, and Clyde owns the remaining 36 shares with a basis of $10,500. At year-end, Getaway is considering different alternatives for redeem..
Appropriateness of screening model used in given case : Discuss the appropriateness of the screening model used in this case.- Suggest another screening model that could be relevant for Philips Lighting to use in the Middle East.
Major sub disciplines of toxicology : Compare and discriminate between the major sub disciplines of toxicology and their roles in occupational safety and health and illustrate the mechanisms by which a toxicant passes through the cell membrane routes of absorption, the distribution pr..

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  I need you to write a journal about multiple intelligences

i need you to write a journal about multiple intelligences why is it important and explain 150 words as an

  Terms is not compatible with the other terms on the list

Which of the following terms is not compatible with the other terms on the list?

  The risks from nuclear and coal power plants

The Chernobyl accident may ultimately cause on the order of 10,000 extra cancer deaths (von Hippel and Cochrane 1991). How many would this come to per reactor-year?

  Developing a risk management plan and risk identification

What risk identification process has been undertaken and any categories used to assist in the identification or relevant risks

  What is the concept of social responsibility

What is the concept of social responsibility?

  Key factors involved in assessing the amount of trust

If you were in a position to persuade another person, explain whether or not you would slant information in such a way as to make your point seem more credible if you sincerely believed that your position was correct. Discuss the primary ethical d..

  How satisfied she will be with her life when she is elderly

Lettie is 30 years old and curious about how satisfied she will be with her life when she is elderly. The best predicator of this is her current:

  Definition of informed consent

Which of the following is not a required part of the definition of "informed consent"?

  What do you mean by tabular presentation why is it

what is meant by tabular presentation? why is it important to present some of an investigators collected data into

  Managed care organizations

Review at least two articles (online or offline) for each topic, and write a review for each source of information. Evaluate the main points of the articles, and relate it to your course and text readings. Write a summary for each topic tying togethe..

  Performance assessment particularly

Why is performance assessment particularly relevant with young children? Discuss at least 3 factors.

  Describe a community program or service

Describe a community program or service in your city or state that you think needs more public or government support. Why does this issue deserve attention?

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd