Do you have any relief under federal precedent

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics
Reference no: EM13863971

You will prepare a report that briefs two cases and applies the law from the cases to a hypothetical fact pattern. You must include all of the elements of the brief. In addition, you must discuss what the outcome would be under the hypothetical fact pattern using the law from the case(s). (In other words, what are you going to do for your client, based upon what you have found out.)
The objective of this assignment is to help you become familiar with case briefing as a tool for presenting, analyzing, and applying case law.

The scenario for this case is as follows: (Read carefully, as each element has a particular purpose.)

You are a licensed attorney in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts. Your client has just been convicted of possession with intent to sell marijuana. The case proceeded as follows, namely, the Prosecution had evidence procured under a valid warrant that included twenty full grown marijuana plants. The warrant that seized the plants had been procured with probable cause, signed by a magistrate, to search inside the house, including the attic, and properly implemented at the house of the client. In order to procure the warrant, Officer Jones had noted a possible "grow light" in the attic of your client's house. This aroused his reasonable suspicion, based upon his years of service, so he returned on trash day, and went through the plastic bags on the curb next to your client's premises (that area known, in legal terms, as the "curtilage" of the premises), where he found marijuana seeds and drug paraphernalia. He took these to the magistrate as evidence of probable cause, and the warrant was issued. At trial you had objected to the warrant itself, and to the search of the trash without a warrant, which would make the evidence "the fruit of a poisonous tree" and subject to supression. The Court overruled both of your objections, and your client is now doing 20 years in Maximum Security.

You want to mount an Appeal. Is there any way that you might do so? Please answer the following questions, and brief the two cases as a part of your answer for support.

1. Do you have any relief under Federal precedent? Why or why not?

2. The Commonwealth is in full accord with the Federal precedent. Why is this important?

3. Is there any other State that might differ with Federal precedent? Why might you want to go to this length?

4. How might you use the precedents from all authorities, and what authority might give you a slight chance to prevail in the Massachusetts Court of Appeals?

(The above questions must be answered in at least Two pages.)

Cases: Federal precedent - California v. Greenwood 486 U.S. 35 (1988). (One page)
Foreign State precedent - State v. Goss 150 NH 46 (2003). (One page)
(note - each brief is worth 6 points.)

General Requirements

Use your own words. Do not copy word-for-word from the opinion or simply rearrange or replace words while leaving the basic sentence structure and syntax intact. In the event that limited text must be quoted directly from the case opinion, use appropriate methods (citation) to indicate that you are directly quoting from the case and cite the page of the opinion you are quoting. There will be a severe penalty assessed against anyone who extensively or inappropriately lifts text from the opinions (this is plagiarism!).

Verified Expert

Reference no: EM13863971

Describe the parties who were harmed or helped by this fraud

In July 2004, the US government filed civil and criminal charges against four former executives of Netherlands based Abhold's subsidiary of US Food Service Inc., an operator

Evaluate the effectiveness of officer stone efforts

Evaluate the effectiveness of Officer Stone's efforts. Analyze and discuss a key area of strength and weakness in his approach. Identify any fundamental legal issues that Of

Analyze proposal adequacy checklist for organizing proposal

Analyze the proposal adequacy checklist for organizing a proposal, and summarize the intrinsic value of two (2) of the suggestions on the checklist. Prepare and articulate a

Advantages and disadvantages of the business entity

What are the four forms of business entities/organizations? Compare the characteristics of each business entity in terms of the following:

What is the difference between an mo and a signature

What is the difference between an MO and a signature? Describe the background of each. For example, what are the driving forces or reasons behind a criminal's MO and signature

Explain the impact white release might have on daugherty

Explain how the history of probation and parole influences the decisions that are made in the Adult Court System toward the supervision of adult offenders, highlighting the

Define cbr a shorthand term used by law enforcement

What are some of the questions the defense may ask? How would you prepare the prosecutor for those questions? As you will be offering testimony in the case, what will you ha

What can demonstrative evidence be used to show

Identify and describe 8-10 different types of specific demonstrative evidence. What can demonstrative evidence be used to show? Explain. Define authentication (Rule 901, Feder


Write a Review

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd