Do parents harm their children when they refuse treatment

Assignment Help English
Reference no: EM131306859

Issue : Do Parents harm their children when they refuse medical treatment on religious grounds?

There are few areas where the state can interfere with parent's raising of a child, but these issues addresses one of these areas; when it comes to children's health, the state has been able to infringe on the domain of the family. As the Massachusetts citizen for children mention, the deaths that have resulted from religious exemption laws are only those that have come to public attention. There may be many more unknown cases of death, injury, prolonged suffering, or permanent disability of children due to parents' refusal to seek medical treatment. It may seem cruel and unnecessary that children die to religious beliefs, yet many, like Sheldon, argue that a child's spiritual health should be the highest priority.

Much of the debate surrounding this topic has focused on Jehovah's witnesses, who refuse blood transfusions, a medical procedure that violates a fundamental tenet of their religion. But there are other religious groups for whom this debate is particularly contentious. Christian scientists, for example, refuse most types of medical interventions, both for themselves and their children, believing instead that through prayer the sick will be healed according to God's will. Does the debate's focus if it is on Jehovah's Witness's belief or those of Christian Scientists? Furthermore, although many health care professionals are familiar with the debate on Jehovah's Witness's denial of blood transfusion, many are incorrect in their understanding of why Jehovah's Witnesses hold such beliefs. You should consider why this is the case, and attempts to center the discussion on some methods for addressing health care professionals' lack of information.

Jehovah's witnesses contend that most of the children in their community decide to become Jehovah's witnesses themselves when they reach adulthood. For this reason, they say, a Jehovah's witnesses parent should be allowed to refuse a potentially life-saving blood transfusion for his or her child. You should consider however,whether a Jehovah's Witness can know that religion his or her child will choose. What if the minor as a child would agree with the parents' beliefs yet when he reached the age of consent decided against living his life as a Jehovah's Witness? Should doctors allow this child to die based simply on the parent's resumption that the child would have eventually followed their religion?

Shelton argues that one cannot know whether Jehovah's witnesses' beliefs about eternal life are substantiated. If the child of Jehovah's Witness grows up and chooses his parent's religion, will he be tortured by the fact that he had received a blood transfusion as a child? Will he lament that his life on earth was "wrongly" saved (against God's laws) and that he is therefore unable to attain eternal life? Will he blame his parents for allowing him to receive another's blood? Did doctors jeopardize what would otherwise have been a religiously law-abiding life experience of this child, and perhaps even provoke family shunning, because they had disrespected the parents' wishes to refuse a blood transfusion?

Culturally, there is our need to save lives instead of allowing individuals to die; yet the fact is that some Jehovah's witnesses do not consider their lives after transfusion worth living. Is "life" after such transfusions no longer akin to actual meaningful "life" for people of this religion? Should mortal life always take precedence over the possibility of eternal life? Who should make that decision?

Reference no: EM131306859

Questions Cloud

Should decision be made to hire someone from within company : Should the decision be made to hire someone from within the company, or someone new? Who would you choose for the new head of the department and why
Describe why communication is essential in an organization : Explain why communication is essential in an organization. Explain the types of situations where each channel or technique would be most effective. Provide examples and facts for your audience.
Find the arbitrage price : Find the arbitrage price Π0(Y) and show that Π0(Y) + Π0(Y) = 1/So - Does the equality Πt(Z1) = Πt(Z2) necessarily holds for every 0 ≤ t ≤ T?
Do you think a recession could look worse : Yet clearly not "everything" is counted. In 2008/2009, the United States was in a recession, and reported GDP was shrinking. Knowing not everything is counted, do you think a recession could "look" worse than what it is, due to how GDP is calculat..
Do parents harm their children when they refuse treatment : Do Parents harm their children when they refuse medical treatment on religious grounds?Will he blame his parents for allowing him to receive another's blood? Did doctors jeopardize what would otherwise have been a religiously law-abiding lif..
Prepare a paper of general background information of country : Prepare a Word document of the general background information regarding the country selected (e.g., location, size, and brief timeline of the main historical events and relevant exchange rate arrangements of the country.
Find weight and bias values that result in single-neuron per : For each of the four vectors given above, calculate the net input, n, and the network output, a, for the network you have designed. Verify that your network solves the problem.
Do you think another dust bowl could generate a depression : How do you think the Dust Bowl and the economic downturn impacted each other? Why? Do you think another Dust Bowl could generate a depression?
How these two religions coexist in a globalized world : When and how it was first founded,Details of initial leaders of the movement and spread of the religion,Explain the main principles of each religion's belief systems, the religious texts-if utilized-and the significant practices.

Reviews

Write a Review

 

English Questions & Answers

  Write an essay on report by complete college america

Write an essay on A September, 2013 report by Complete College America, a group seeking to raise college graduation rates, found that, in Texas, out of every 100 students who enroll in a public college.

  Define any themes that are evident

The conflict tears some of them apart internally, while others are faced with a desperate urgency to be vocal in order to save themselves. Explain and define any themes that are evident in "The Story of an African Farm"?

  What is the stanza structure of this poem

What is the stanza structure of this poem and what might the mushrooms symbolize in this poem?

  Meaning of health and the determinants of health

his week's course content focuses on the meaning of health and the determinants of health. It is appropriate then, at the start of your program of study, to turn the lens on yourself.

  Ensure that your adult learners are active and engaged

How would you facilitate the discussions to ensure that your adult learners are active and engaged?If you have experienced engaging discussions as an adult learner and/or facilitated engaging discussions, share ways in which those discussions were..

  Meatuse in a diet demands that humans find

Working Thesis Statement: Increase in taking aside between meatuse in a diet demands that humans find a way to obtain a balance between meats and vegetables in their diets.

  How shining movie locate horror in an overly society

Write a paper about How the "Shining" Movie Locate Horror in an Overly Permissive Society?

  Write a four pages essay about television

Write a four pages essay about television.

  What is the most affected population to obesity

What is the most affected population to obesity? What should we do to reduce childhood Obesity? How many children have sedentary lifestyle and poor nutrition?

  Understand the difference between narrative arguments

Why you're doing this: You're doing this to understand the difference between narrative arguments, which we explored in our last assignment, and evaluative arguments, which you'll need to create in future writing in your discipline and profession.

  Describes your current views on the nature of writing

describes your current views on the nature of writing and how your ideas about writing have changed this semester.

  The steps of your current writing approach.

Write a 150-to-200 word paragraph describing the steps of your current writing approach. For example, how do you approach writing an assignment for a class? In addition, outline the ways your process differs from or is similar to the writing p..

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd