Do employees have either a moral or legal right to park cars

Assignment Help Business Management
Reference no: EM131294875

Assignment: Workplace Ethics

Overview

This assignment will give you the opportunity to choose a case study, and then write about the ethical implications and the impact of the events that are described. Each case study includes a set of questions that you should answer. You can choose either Case Study 9.1: Unprofessional Conduct, or Case Study 8.4: Have Gun Will Travel.

You will be graded on the following criteria:

Write a four to six page paper in which you:

1. Analyze the questions associated with your chosen case study and discuss them using concepts you learned in this course.

2. Explain your rationale for each of your answers to your chosen case study.

3. Format your assignment according to the following formatting requirements:

a. Typed, double spaced, using Times New Roman font (size 12), with one-inch margins on all sides.

b. Include a cover page containing the title of the assignment, the student's name, the professor's name, the course title, and the date. The cover page is not included in the required page length.

c. Cite your textbook as a reference.

d. Include a reference page. Citations and references must follow APA format. The reference page is not included in the required page length.

CASE 8.4

Have Gun, Will Travel ... to Work

ORGANIZATIONAL THEORISTS AND EMPLOYEE advocates frequently emphasize the importance, from both a moral and a practical point of view, of companies' respecting the rights of their employees. Many employees spend long hours at work and remain tethered to the job by phone or computer even when they are off-site; not just their careers but also their friendships, social identity, and emotional lives are tied up with their work. All the more reason, it seems, that companies should recognize and respect their moral, political, and legal rights. But enshrined in our Constitution is one right that frequently gets overlooked in discussions of the workplace: the right to bear arms.88

In 2002 Weyerhaeuser, the Seattle-based timber-products company, fired several employees at an Oklahoma plant who were discovered to have violated company policy by keeping guns in their vehicles. Their dismissal provoked a response from the National Rifle Association (NRA) and other gun-rights advocates, which since then have been lobbying for legislation that would make it illegal for companies to bar employees from leaving guns in their cars in company parking lots. Although no state requires companies to allow workers to carry weapons into the workplace, four states have passed laws guaranteeing them the right to keep guns in their cars, and several other states are weighing whether to follow suit. Gun advocates argue that licensed gun owners should have access to their weapons in case they need them on the trek to and from work. If an employer can ban guns from workers' cars, "it would be a wrecking ball to the Second Amendment" of the U.S. Constitution, says Wayne LaPierre, executive vice president of the NRA.

Brian Siebel, a senior attorney at the Brady Center to Prevent Gun Violence, thinks otherwise. He sees these laws as "a systematic attempt to force guns into every nook and cranny in society and prohibit anyone, whether it's private employers or college campuses ... from barring guns from their premises." But that's not how UCLA law professor Eugene Volokh looks at it. "It's part of the general movement," he says, "to allow people to have guns for self-defense not only at home, but in public places where they're most likely needed." For his part, LaPierre of the NRA contends that the legal right of people to have guns for personal protection is largely nullified if employers can ban guns from the parking lot. "Saying you can protect yourself with a firearm when you get off work late at night," he argues, "is meaningless if you can't keep it in the trunk of your car when you're at work."

Interpreting the somewhat ambiguous language of the Second Amendment is not easy. It only says, "A well-regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed." All jurists agree, however, that the Second Amendment does not make all forms of gun control unconstitutional and that, like the rest of the Bill of Rights, it places restrictions only on what government, not private parties, may do.

In particular, the Second Amendment does not give gun owners a constitutionally protected right to carry their weapons onto somebody else's private property against the wishes of the owner. "If I said to somebody, ‘You can't bring your gun into my house,' that person's rights would not be violated," explains Mark Tushnet, a Harvard law professor. For this reason, the American Bar Association sides with business owners and endorses "the traditional property rights of private employers and other private property owners to exclude" people with firearms. Steve Halverson, president of a Jacksonville, Florida, construction company agrees that business owners should be allowed to decide whether to allow weapons in their parking lots. "The larger issue is property rights," he says, "and whether you as a homeowner and I as a business owner ought to have the right to say what comes onto our property." However, Tennessee state senator Paul Stanley, a Republican sponsor of legislation requiring that guns be allowed in company parking lots, begs to differ. "I respect property and business rights," he says. "But I also think that some issues need to overshadow this.... We have a right to keep and bear arms." Other gun advocates think that the property-rights argument is a red herring. Corporations are not individuals, they argue, but artificial legal entities, whose "rights" are entirely at the discretion of the state. What's really going on, they think, is that some companies have an anti-gun political agenda.

Property rights, however, aren't the only thing that companies are concerned about. Business and other organizations have a widely acknowledged duty to keep their workplaces-and their employees-as safe as possible, and that means, many of them believe, keeping their campuses free of weapons. There are more than five hundred workplace homicides per year; in addition, 1.5 million employees are assaulted at work, many of them by coworkers or former employees. Having guns anywhere in the vicinity, many employers worry, can only make volatile situations more deadly. "There's no need to allow guns [into] parking lots," says the Brady Center's Siebel. "The increased risks are obvious." Steve Halveson drives that point home, too. "I object to anyone telling me that we can't ... take steps necessary to protect our employees." For him it's no different from banning guns from his construction sites or requiring workers to wear hard hats. "The context is worker safety, and that's why it's important."

1.Do you have not only a legal, but a moral right to own a gun? Do you believe that you have either a moral or a legal right to park a car with a loaded gun in a privately owned parking lot, regardless of what the lot's owner wants

2.In your view, do employees have either a moral or a legal right to park cars with guns in them in the company parking lot? What do you believe should be the property rights and safety concerns of employers?

3.Do you think state legislatures are right to get involved, or should the matter be left to companies and employees to settle?

4.Because the workplace is the company's private property, the company could choose to allow employees to bring guns not only into the parking lot, but also into the workplace itself. Are there ever circumstances in which doing so might be reasonable? Or would the presence of guns automatically violate the rights of other employees to be guaranteed a safe working environment?

Reference no: EM131294875

Questions Cloud

Create an introduction that tells what your report is about : FIN100:Create an introduction that tells what your report is about.The introduction includes:Begin with a general introduction paragraph that gives the reader any needed background information on the company or problem.Include the Problem Statement t..
What are general tradeoffs that are involved in waiting line : What are the general tradeoffs that are involved in waiting line decisions? Who needs to be involved in assessing the cost of customers waiting for service? How has technology had an impact on analyzing waiting line systems?
Draw a diagram with aggregate demand : Draw a diagram with aggregate demand, short-run aggregate supply, and long-run aggregate supply. Be careful to label the axis correctly.
What interests do secured lenders : What interests do secured lenders, unsecured debt holders, trade creditors, preferred stockholders, common stockholders, and management have? What incentives or circumstances will induce them to support, or reject an out-of-court restructuring?
Do employees have either a moral or legal right to park cars : In your view, do employees have either a moral or a legal right to park cars with guns in them in the company parking lot? What do you believe should be the property rights and safety concerns of employers?
Calculate the probability that these two cards are an ace : Two cards are to be drawn from a standard deck of 52 cards. Calculate the probability that these two cards are an ace and a 10, drawn in any order.
How many different ways can two suppliers be chosen : An electronic component is available from five suppliers. How many different ways can two suppliers be chosen from the five available?
Describe the main points of each theory : Describe the main points of each theory.Relate McGregor's approach to Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs (1943), explaining how employees can be motivated and satisfy their different levels of needs under each of the theories proposed by McGregor.
How many different three-letter words can be made : How many different three-letter "words" can be made from the 26 letters of the English alphabet without regard to vowels if the letters can be used more than once per word?

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Business Management Questions & Answers

  Consequences of incorporating business

Advise a couple setting up a retail business what advantages and disadvantages they may encounter with an unincorporated business structure and explain the consequences of incorporating their business.

  Testing for employee selection

What are potential complicating factors in using personality testing for employee selection?

  Assignment-interpret the role of ethics in business

What is the role of ethics in business? Prepare a paper that addresses the following:

  Project approval presentation

Develop an executive level presentation (12-15 APA formatted slides) to gain support for your project. It will be necessary to include the right level of detail to support your position and sell the project to the right level of management who mus..

  Evaluate the competitiveness within the us laptop

Use Porter's Five-Forces Model to evaluate the competitiveness within the U.S. laptop computer market. Which of the Five-Forces is the strongest and most significant in this market?

  Find a presentation of interest on ted

Find a presentation of interest on TED and critique its content, visuals, and the presenter's skills (if applicable). Use this week's lecture to aid your analysis. Cite the presentation in your post, and document it in APA style

  Describe the benefits of flawless consultation

Describe the benefits of flawless consultation then explain the basic value of the term, "flawless consultation."After reading the Sensible Oxymoron listed in the "Readings" section, replace the word, "oxymoron" with a word

  Discuss problem recognition for the given product categories

Discuss problem recognition for the given product categories.-  Make a list of some ways marketers might try to stimulate problem recognition for each product.

  Basket of goods and services cost

1. If the total expenditures of a typical family equaled $35,000 per year in 2010 and the exact same basket of goods and services cost $40,000 in the year 2015, the family's cost of living:

  Illustrate what might be some negative effects

In addition to the obvious negative effects of illegitimate political behaviour on victims, such as those explained in the above case, illustrate what might be some negative effects on the perpetrators or on the organization as a whole?

  Required skills for a successful consultant

Discuss the skills and competencies needed for a successful consultant and use at least 2-sources to support your analysis.

  Europeans thought imperialism was a good idea

Why do you think Europeans thought imperialism was a good idea? Do you think European pro-imperialism statements were sincere, or were Europeans just trying to find a way to justify acquiring and controlling more profitable territory? Don't forg..

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd