Discuss the legality of the plan

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics
Reference no: EM131390494

City of Richmond, Virginia (the City), adopted a Minority Business Utilization Plan requiring prime contractors awarded city construction contracts to subcontract at least 30 percent of the dollar amount of each contract to one or more Minority Business Enterprises (MBEs).

The plan defined an MBE to include a business from anywhere in the United States that is at least 51 percent owned and controlled by African-American, Spanish-speaking, Oriental, Native American, Eskimo, or Aleut citizens. Although the plan declared that it was ‘‘remedial'' in nature, it was adopted after a public hearing at which no direct evidence was presented that the City had discriminated on the basis of race in letting contracts or that its prime contractors had discriminated against minority subcontractors.

The evidence introduced in support of the plan included a statistical study indicating that, although the City's population was 50 percent African American, less than 1 percent of its prime construction contracts had been awarded to minority businesses in recent years.

Additional evidence showed that a variety of local contractors' trade associations had virtually no MBE members. J. A. Croson Co., the sole bidder on a city contract, was denied a waiver and lost its contract because of the plan. Discuss the legality of the plan.

Reference no: EM131390494

Questions Cloud

Determine the speed at which resonance would occur : As the rotating speed of a spring-supported motor is slowly increased from 200 to 500 rpm, the amplitude of the vibration due to the unbalance of the rotor is observed to decrease steadily from 8 mm to 2.5 mm.
Explain will local 705 succeed : Local 705 filed a complaint with the National Labor Relations Board, alleging that Berger had committed unfair labor practices in violation of the National Labor Relations Act. Will Local 705 succeed? Explain.
Various forms of pathogenicity of bacillus anthracis : What are the various forms of pathogenicity of Bacillus anthracis?
Point and non-point sources of land pollution : Here is my question: Discuss the difference between point and non-point sources of land pollution, and provide examples of each. What is TMDL, and how is it used to protect water resources from land pollution?
Discuss the legality of the plan : Additional evidence showed that a variety of local contractors' trade associations had virtually no MBE members. J. A. Croson Co., the sole bidder on a city contract, was denied a waiver and lost its contract because of the plan. Discuss the legal..
How would you summarize edward jenner accomplishments : How would you summarize Edward Jenner's accomplishments? All medical procedures, including vaccination, carry some risk. How much risk do you feel is acceptable? Should that risk be balanced between the individual and the general public, or is it m..
The texas department of community affairs : In order to comply with Title VII, must the Texas Department of Community Affairs hire Burdine as supervisor if she and the male candidate are equally qualified? Explain.
Find the corresponding maximum frequency : Two rods, each of mass m and length L, are welded together to form the assembly shown.
What are the assumptions behind different forms of evidence : What do we mean by qualitative evidence? What weight do we give to the validity and rigor of that evidence? What are the assumptions behind different forms of evidence?

Reviews

Write a Review

Business Law and Ethics Questions & Answers

  What are other factors affecting disproportionate minority

A Well-written paper supported by at least three scholarly references

  Explain role capitalism plays in corporate decision-making

Explain the role capitalism plays in corporate decision-making- Discuss if you believe it is possible for a company to cater to both its best interest and that of the consumer conjointly or if one always has to prevail. Justify your response.

  Incorporate normative ethics metaethics and applied ethics

in a 2-4-page paper describe a personal experience in which you or someone you know had to make a moral decision-for

  Analyse the package using the principles of contract law

Identify the key information about the holiday as set out in brochure and critically analyse the package using the principles of contract law found in case law and categorise the statements into representations, terms, conditionsand warranties.

  Explain the different issues related to sentencing

Explain the different issues related to sentencing. Within your discussion, include how the two main sentencing initiatives-guideline-based determinate sentencing and restorative justice-are at odds with each other. Your response should be at least 3..

  What removal options do ice officials have with eduardo

After serving his 5 year sentence, ICE officials take him into custody to process him for removal. From reading our lesson plan material this week, what removal options do ICE officials have with Eduardo

  Explain the various educational and treatment programs

Assess the Security, technology, management and control functions within correctional environments. Explain the various Educational and treatment programs used in rehabilitation efforts for institutional and community corrections

  Jesse james a 20-year old was arrested for killing a police

jesse james a 20-year old was arrested for killing a police officer. as a newly elected prosecutor you are responsible

  How does existential theory centered theory applies

How does Existential theory or person centered theory applies? Cite 2 professional and peer reviewed journals in APA format. Included your reaction and Write in 3rd person.

  Is there a bright line rule when it comes to classifying

Is there a bright line rule when it comes to classifying someone as an employee or an independent contractor? Are there actions that if taken will automatically classify someone as an employee or as an independent contractor

  Who would be the plaintiff in a civil case

What three things does the plaintiff have to prove to win this case? How much evidence does the plaintiff need in order to win?

  What does this phrase mean to you

What is the likelihood of the creation of a dystopian society in the name of security through acquiescence by the public? Generally speaking, do you feel that the majority of U.S. citizens are apathetic with regard to this debate? Explain.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd