Did they provide enough detail to duplicate their work

Assignment Help Mechanical Engineering
Reference no: EM131109971

You will then write a full critique of your assigned article that will be anywhere from 2 to 5 pages long. The paper is due July 1st. All papers will be double spaced 11pt font Times New Roman. Your paper should be concise. Papers over 5 pages will not be accepted and will receive a zero!

Full Critique: (Due July 1st in class)
Your full critique should answer the following questions:What new information do the concluded results add to the body of scientific knowledge?How does this research pertain to thermodynamics?What thermodynamic principals are used?Is the research reproducible?Did they provide enough detail to duplicate their work?If not, what is missing? (Find something, ie. Frequency of samples taken, thermocouple type, erroranalysis, references) What is the next step to conducting the research?What research could you do to add to this research? (Be detailed, what would your hypothesis be, whatmight be some of your results and conclusions, what mathematical methods might you use)Finally give your honest opinion about the paper. Was it cool, crappy, revolutionary, mediocre? Beexpressive and detailed as to why you have that opinion.
You must reference the document with a references section following ASME format. Any plagiarism willresult in a zero. Use the third person except for your opinion paragraph. Have the writing center checkyour final write up and provide their edits with your final paper.

The effect of computer technology and simulations on introductory thermodynamics teaching and understanding does aid in assisting students to come up with a more vigorous way of analyzing thermodynamics with the help of simulations (Eileen L. Lewis, 1993). Studies indicate that students often have difficulties generalizing science instruction to the natural world (Eileen L. Lewis, 1993). The research was conducted by the introduction of simulation of real life problems of the students in the core curriculum. The investigation resulted in a tremendous increase in the number of students that were distinctly able to differentiate between heat energy and temperature as well as being able to give an explanation of the natural occurring phenomena. At the end of the research, the students had the ability to give a broad view of the model of insulation together with that of conduction.

Though the research was successful, some drawbacks were also experienced in that the comprehension of other concepts like thermal equilibrium was limited (Eileen L. Lewis, 1993). Despite the fact that the desired outcome was not attained, the concluded result does add new information to the body of scientific knowledge in that the integration of simulation in the curriculum especially when conducting real life thermodynamic problems is the way to go as a rational as well as tremendous improvement in the student's ability to analyze thermodynamics is attained. Therefore, integration of simulation in thermodynamics is of importance to the science knowledge as shown in the above discussion.

Eileen L. Lewis, J. L. (1993). The effect of computer simulations on introductory thermodynamics understanding.

Reference no: EM131109971

Questions Cloud

In repeated prisoner dilemma : In a repeated prisoner’s dilemma, a player that is playing tit-for-tat will:
What are the seller and buyer responsibilities : Please answer the following questions based on the material taught: What are the Seller´s and Buyer´s responsibilities? Is there a breach of contract under CISG? If there is a breach of contractwhat remedies are available
National health and nutrition examination survey : The Third National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES III, 1988-1994) was conducted by the National Center for Health Statistics, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Oligopoly market structure ok for free market-capitalist : There are many economists that cringe at the words: oligopoly and free market together. To them, it is an oxymoron, unjust and plain down 'wrong'. Why do you believe that is the case? Isn't an oligopoly market structure 'ok' for a free market/ capita..
Did they provide enough detail to duplicate their work : What new information do the concluded results add to the body of scientific knowledge? How does this research pertain to thermodynamics? What thermodynamic principals are used?Is the research reproducible? Did they provide enough detail to duplica..
The use of a balanced rss as opposed to an srs : You have been asked to justify the use of a balanced RSS as opposed to an SRS of the same size to obtain information about a population. Discuss the pros and cons of these two approaches to data collection.
Thinken technology recently merged with college electronic : How should Ott respond to Habbe's remark about firing non-vested employees?
How much money will be in this account : To get your MBA, you must take 20 courses. You can take 8 courses per year (2 courses per quarter including a summer semester). A course costs $3,500. Your company offers tuition reimbursement for 2 courses per term. Your company deposits $7,000 in a..
Calculate the total number of sample units : We would like to collect a balanced RSS of 24 observations from a population. List all of the (set size, cycle size) combinations that could be used to obtain this balanced RSS of size 24.

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Mechanical Engineering Questions & Answers

  An ideal reheat rankine cycle with water as the working

an ideal reheat rankine cycle with water as the working fluid operates the inlet of the high-pressure turbine at 8000

  Find the necessary static deflection of the isolator

If the instrument weighs 85N, find the necessary static deflection of the isolator.

  Determine the work done on the piston by the gas

This mixture is initially at 1800 K and 1 MPa and expands in an adiabatic, reversible process to 200 kPa. Determine the work done on the piston by the gas, in kJ/kg of mixture. Treat the water vapor as an ideal gas.

  Say the contact forces is 50 lb determine the internal

in an overhead smash a tennis player strikes the ball with the center of the head of the racquet. say the contact

  Determine the minimum thickness of fibreglas insulation

Determine the minimum thickness of fibreglas insulation that needs to be used in the wall in order to avoid condensation on the outer surfaces.

  Find the pressure at point b

Question 1: Find an expression for {density of water at 4°C} if the following are known: {acceleration due to gravity, specific gravity, fluid volume, weight} Question 2: Find the pressure at point B if the following are known:

  If the process occurs slowly enough that the temperature in

atank of 0.1-m3volume contains air at 298.15k 25degc and 101.33kpa.the tank is connected to a compressed-air line which

  Determine the slip factor using busemann''s method

A centrifugal pump is used to raise water against a static head of 18.0 m. The suction and delivery pipes, both 0.15 m diameter, have, respectively, friction head losses amounting to 2.25 and 7.5 times the dynamic head.

  Determine a the mass flow rate of saturated liquid and

a low quality-low pressure flow of saturated liquid-vapor mixture of water enters an insulated flash tank located in a

  Determine the maximum normal and shear stresses in the bar

A structural steel bar with a 25 mm x60 mm rectangular cross section is subjected to an axial load of 160 kN. Determine the maximum normal and shear stresses in the bar.

  When the sign is in place the cable height at the sign is 8

a 100-pound sign is supported at the midpoint of a cable stretched between anchor points that are separated by 86 feet.

  The developers could not gain market acceptance

Many good IT ideas have failed because the developers could not gain market acceptance or could not find a way to make money from their idea. In this Discussion, you will consider some business aspects of the Web. Consider the many Web search e..

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd