Did doe exhibit an expectation of privacy when he sent texts

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM131248213

Writing Assignment: Supreme Court Decision

In this assignment, you will be a Supreme Court Justice deciding on a Fourth Amendment case. Carefully read about the case in question, the summaries of related Supreme Court decisions, and directions for the assignment.

The Case "Doe v. City of Intrusia":

Trouble was brewing in the small, quiet city of Intrusia. Someone was selling methamphetamine to the local teenagers and a popular football player died after an overdose. The community was panicked and demanded that the police find the source of the meth and shut it down immediately. The police suspected that 20 year old Joe Doe was selling the meth but they didn't have much evidence.

The state prosecutor advised the police department to talk with the local cell phone carrier about "cloning" Mr. Doe's phone. The cell phone carrier created a "clone" phone which allowed the police to read text messages sent and received by Mr. Doe. In no time the police had evidence implicating Mr. Doe as a dealer and the location of the meth lab. Mr. Doe was convicted and the meth lab was closed.

Mr. Doe is appealing his conviction, claiming that the interception of text messages violated the unreasonable search and seizure protections of the Fourth Amendment. Furthermore, all evidence from the text messages should have been excluded from his trial.
The City of Intrusia argues that there was no physical intrusion into Mr. Doe's space and that police were acting quickly in order to uphold their duty to protect the community's safety.

Background:

In Silverman v. United States the Supreme Court held that that the Fourth Amendment does not protect conversations, therefore wiretapping does not constitute a search and seizure. The case was reversed in Katz v. United States, when Justice Harlan proposed a two pronged test of whether public actions should be considered private and therefore protected. 1) Has the person exhibited an expectation of privacy? and 2) is the expectation of privacy one that society is prepared to recognize as 'reasonable.'?

In more recent decisions, the Supreme Court has found that society is not prepared to extend privacy rights to bank customers regarding their bank statements and that society was not prepared to recognize a privacy right-to grow a backyard crop of marijuana.

The Questions:

• Does the Fourth Amendment protect text messages sent over a cell phone?
• Is there a "reasonable expectation of privacy" when texts are sent?

o Did Mr. Doe exhibit an expectation of privacy when he sent the texts?
o Is there a societal expectation of privacy in the process of text messaging?

Related Supreme Court Decisions (each case is linked to a short description on Oyez.com):

Court Case Question

Olmstead v. United States (1928)

Did the use of evidence disclosed in wiretapped private telephone conversations; violate the recorded party's Fourth and Fifth Amendments?
Katz v. United States (1967)

Does the Fourth Amendment protection against unreasonable searches and seizures require the police to obtain a search warrant in order to wiretap a public pay phone?

United States v. Miller (1975)

Were Miller's bank records illegally seized in violation of the Fourth Amendment?

Smith v. Maryland (1979)

Does the installation and use of a pen register constitute a search under the Fourth Amendment?

California v. Ciraolo (1986)

Did the warrantless, aerial observation of Ciraolo's back yard from an altitude of 1,000 feet constitute an illegal search and violate the Fourth Amendment?

Bond v. United States (2000)

Does a law enforcement officer's physical manipulation of a bus passenger's carry-on luggage violate the Fourth Amendment's protection against unreasonable searches?

Kyllo v. United States (2001)

Does the use of a thermal-imaging device to detect relative amounts of heat emanating from a private home constitute an unconstitutional search in violation of the Fourth Amendment?

The Assignment:

• Write an opinion as if you were a judge deciding this case. Please note that the term "opinion" here does NOT mean an expression of your personal views! Instead, it means a formal statement of the legal reasons and principles defending your conclusion of whether text messages are protected under the Fourth Amendment.

• To help you in making your decision, please read the summaries of past Fourth Amendment rulings.

• As you read through the Supreme Court decisions above, look at how justices have crafted their decisions, and learn from them. Use these as models for your paper.

• Write clearly and concisely. State your decision, and defend it.

• Cite precedent and the Constitution.

• Refer to at least 3 of the cases featured above.

• Write a minimum of 500 words.

Reference no: EM131248213

Questions Cloud

What is hypothesis testing : What is hypothesis testing? Explain the general process and the steps included in conducting a hypothesis test? What is the difference between parametric and nonparametric hypothesis testing?
Course materials to answer these questions : This is a brief, online quiz to prepare you for class on Tuesday, Oct. 18. You may use your books and notes. However, make sure you use only course materials to answer these questions. Anyone found copying (even a portion of your answer) from Wiki..
How health care financing in the united states may promote : Describe how health care financing in the United States may promote under access to health care services by some and overutilization by others.
The customer relationship management assignment : From the last few years, organizations are finding new ways through which they can sustain their position in the global market. The customer relationship management has become a new tool which organizations implement as a strategy in order to attract..
Did doe exhibit an expectation of privacy when he sent texts : Does the Fourth Amendment protect text messages sent over a cell phone? Is there a "reasonable expectation of privacy" when texts are sent? Did Mr. Doe exhibit an expectation of privacy when he sent the texts?
Find online job postings in profession : Find online job postings in your profession. Search for job postings in your field that have online applications. Select one based on your interests.
Pecking order with variable investment : Show that the separating outcome is the only perfect Bayesian equilibrium of the issuance game if and only if α α∗ for some threshold α∗.
Factors of resistance to change : Describe the organizational factors that create stress and discuss how they compare to the factors of resistance to change. How are they similar and different? Are the methods for managing change useful for managing stress caused by organizational..
Identify the null hypothesis and alternative hypothesis : In apulse rate research, a simple random sample of 40 men results in a mean of 80 beats per minute, and a standard deviation of 11.3 beats per minute. Based on the sample results, the researcher concludes that the pulse rates of men have a standar..

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Cultural differences among their students

Why is it important for teachers to discern the cultural differences among their students? How can a teacher learn more about the cultures of their students? How could this new information influence lesson planning and student learning?

  Public view of healthcare

For this assignment you're being asked to examine the public's view of healthcare and analyze how that perception was shaped by the primary actors within the U.S. health care system.

  Ethics and law in the field of counseling

Analyze and explain the relationship between ethics and the law in the field of counseling. how could you explain the interplay between the two?

  Do you want to make a political statement

Do you want to make a political statement or do you just want to make someone laugh? You may set your play anywhere, anytime and use as many or as few characters as you need.

  Explain extent and nature of disorder like number of people

you have researched the theoretical writings related to your selected mental disorder. examine the practice related to

  Explain a key objection to your position on this issue

Provide your position on the issue in the articles assigned to you. State and explain a key objection to your position on this issue.

  Get rid of incompetent management

Henry Manne believed that companies cannot become too incompetent or corrupt, as eventually their share price would fall and they could be taken over by another firm that would get rid of incompetent management.

  Create a coherently structured paper with an introduction

Develop a coherently structured paper with an introduction, body, and conclusion. Provide three relevant and credible sources to support claims.

  Key external factors-threats and opportunities

As you have studied about external and internal factors in an industry analysis. Your job is to identify only the key external factors (Threats and Opportunities) of Virtual University of Pakistan. You should point out at least 10 Opportunities and t..

  Why do you think the evaluator chose this specific analysis

Find an article that discusses a program evaluation where at least one of these was used. Why do you think the evaluator chose this specific analysis? How were the findings from the analysis applied to the overall evaluation?

  How are we to improve our system of care

Since we know that health care is not a right but can be an entitlement (Medicare, Medicaid, CHIP), how are we to improve our system of care for those who are without resources (insurance, funds to self-pay)?

  Developing research analysis skills

Effects of working under stress The purpose of the annotated bibliography is to assist you in developing research analysis skills including critical thinking, writing, and literature research skills. The annotated bibliography should include a par..

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd