Reference no: EM131230919
Developing Diagnostic and Analytical Skills
Case Application 7: TIMING OF THE JOB OFFER
Does it make a difference when a job offer is made? For many, the answer may be no, but then, in HRM things are rarely cut and dried. Consider the events that took place in early 2005 at American Airlines.
In their quest to add flight attendants to their organization, company officials began a major recruiting effort. To deal with the numbers they anticipated, American representatives spent consider- able time screening applicants through extensive phone interviews. Those who passed this initial screening were invited to Dallas, Amer- ican’s headquarters, for group and individual interviews. For expedi- ency’s sake and for competitive reasons, successful candidates were then given a conditional job offer—conditioned on passing a drug test, a background investigation, and a medical exam. These individ- uals were then taken to the company’s on-site medical facility, where they were asked to complete a personal history questionnaire and give a blood sample. Shortly thereafter, the results were available, and three individuals had a questionable blood test result. After dis- cussing the matter with them, American officials learned that the three were HIV positive. Consequently, the company withdrew the conditional offer. As a result, the three applicants sued.
At issue from American’s perspective was that the three indi- viduals did not fully disclose their medical situation on the ques- tionnaire—thus they lied on their “application.” American held that the conditional job offer was just that—conditional. They hadn’t completed the entire hiring process—such as the background check—and only after all relevant information is in do they actually make a real or permanent job offer. They also cited that employ- ment law requires individuals to be honest in disclosing their med- ical conditions, which in this case the individuals did not. The first court to look at this matter agreed and dismissed the case in favor of American.
But the three individuals persevered. They appealed, and on appeal the court ruled that American had, in fact, made a real job offer, and then fired them for reasons that violate the Americans with Disabilities Act. In its decision, the appellate court said that a conditional offer should be made only after all nonmedical factors have been evaluated. In this case, American had not done everything prior to requesting the medical examination, thus they did not fol- low the standard hiring process they had in place. As a result, the lower court’s decision was overturned and the case was permitted to go to trial.
Questions:
1. Do you believe American Airlines has the right to rescind a conditional job offer? Why?
2. Is the fact that American did not follow their standard hiring process a problem here? Explain.
3. Do you believe American Airlines has the right to not hire someone who is HIV positive? Defend your position.
4. If you were the judge at the trial, given the facts presented above, who would you rule in favor of—American or the three individuals? Why?
Affect the performances of the group as a whole
: Explain the importance of establishing ground rules and respecting cultures amongst team members. How does diversity within members affect the performances of the group as a whole?
|
Fixed order quantity system model-cycle time
: Bookworld, a publishing Company, produces books for the retail market. Demand for a current book is expected to occur at a constant annual rate of 7500 copies. The cost of one copy of the book is $27.50. Using an appropriate Fixed Order Quantity syst..
|
Organizational culture and complex clinical workflows
: Why has implementation of information technology in health care and public health been so slow in comparison to other industries? Discuss the relative importance of factors such as financial incentives or disincentives, organizational culture, comple..
|
Provide comprehensive health insurance on nationwide scale
: What is the basis for the managed care ‘‘backlash’’ in the United States, and why has enrollment in PPOs grown while enrollment in HMOs has declined? How did the enactment process of the ACA differ from the previously failed attempts to provide compr..
|
Developing diagnostic-analytical skills-timing of job offer
: Does it make a difference when a job offer is made? For many, the answer may be no, but then, in HRM things are rarely cut and dried. Consider the events that took place in early 2005 at American Airlines. Do you believe American Airlines has the rig..
|
Your scarcest resource
: In the May, 2014 edition of Harvard Business Review there is an article entitled, "Your Scarcest Resource" This articles observes that time is money, but few organizations treat it that way. The article engages the problem that an organization's time..
|
Reinforcement in advertising
: Central to the subject of consumer behavior is the concept of reinforcement. We marketers have "borrowed" this from psychology, as we have done with many other concepts. Positive reinforcement is reward for doing something you should do. Punishment i..
|
Problems of external adaptation and internal integration
: Please explain how culture can impact solutions to problems of external adaptation and internal integration. Please apply this notion to a real-world example of a company that either ‘did’ or ‘should have’ considered culture when solving such problem..
|
Describe the product and service and the ad
: Maslow looked at the different levels of need satisfaction. Find two ads that are directed at each of the levels of satisfaction. Describe the product/service and the ad.
|