Describe the utilitarian implication of situation

Assignment Help Business Law and Ethics
Reference no: EM13672683 , Length: 749 Words

An industrial firm is confronted with the dilemma of whether it should include - on its balance sheet - a very costly liability for the clean-up of a hazardous waste pool that has accumulated over the past several years, this as a direct by-product of its operations. The company is in agreement that the cost of cleaning up the hazardous waste pool is a cost of doing business.

However, including this massive financial liability in the company's financial statements now will have the effect of immediately decreasing the total value of the company. In turn, because the company's worth will be deflated, the company's current stockholders will be harmed financially because the company will have lost much of its current value.

In contrast, if the company does not include the liability on its balance sheet, the company will clearly be overvalued, and will likely be viewed as dishonest in disclosure -- and anyone buying stock (or ownership) in the company will also be unknowingly buying shares of a company that is overvalued (i.e., the balance sheet will be misleading, showing the company as having greater net value than it actually has).

Let's assume that there are no accounting rules nor is there any clear guidance as to what this company should do. No matter what the company decides, innocent persons - whether its existing shareholders (if disclosure is made) or potential shareholders (if disclosure is not made - and is later required) will be seriously harmed as a result of either decision.

First and foremost, please describe the utilitarian implication of this situation. What do you think the company should do? Of secondary interest (if you'd like to respond), what would deontological ethics require? And what would Immanuel Kant require?

Verified Expert

Reference no: EM13672683

Describe which side should prevail

Trona Speedway denies any liability based upon the warning on the envelope and the known risk that spectators take when attending a race. At trial, which side should prevail

Evaluate the effectiveness of officer stone efforts

Evaluate the effectiveness of Officer Stone's efforts. Analyze and discuss a key area of strength and weakness in his approach. Identify any fundamental legal issues that Offi

What is the required mens rea in ohio

The mens rea for receiving stolen property varies from state to state. In some states, receivers have to know the goods are stolen. In others, believing the goods are stolen

Explain how would an opponent of these reforms respond

The Supreme Court has repeatedly asserted that a defendant is not entitled to a jury composed in whole or in part of persons of his own race. How would an opponent of these

Why would you take the actions you mentioned above

Will you approach these three men to question them? What would you say to them? What other actions might you engage in with regard to these men? Why would you take the actions

Performance on the law school admission test

Please set forth any circumstances you believe may have negatively affected your cumulative undergraduate grade-point average, your performance on the Law School Admission T

The international harvester dealership in sunny-side

Prior Brothers, Inc. (PBI) began financing its farming operations through Bank of California, N.A. (Bank). Bank's loans were secured by PBI's equipment and after-acquired prop

What approach to ethical decision making does jeremy use

Jeremy's ethical decision making is guided primarily by his belief that his self-interests should be promoted as long as he doesn't harm others. What approach to ethical dec

Reviews

Write a Review

 
Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd