Define the leader and manager approach to solving dilemma

Assignment Help Operation Management
Reference no: EM131192561

At 7:30 a.m., Juan Para hit the snooze alarm for the third time, but he knew he could never go back to sleep. Rubbing his eyes and shaking off a headache, Para first checked his IPHONE and read an urgent message from his boss, explaining that Jack Nixon, chief security analyst, had resigned last night and needed to be replaced immediately. Frustrated, Para lumbered toward the shower, hoping it would energize him to face another day. After last night’s management meeting, which had ended after midnight, he was reeling from the news that his employer, Protection Insurance, was spiraling toward a financial meltdown.

Para scratched his head and wondered, “How could one of the world’s largest insurance companies plummet from being the gold standard in the industry to one struggling for survival?” At the end of 2007, Protection had $100 billion in annual revenues, 65 million customers, and 96,000 employees in 130 countries. One year later and staggered by losses stemming from the credit crisis, Protection teetered on the brink of failure and was in need of emergency government assistance. Protection had been a victim of the meltdown in the credit markets. The collapse of this respected financial institution sent shock waves throughout the world’s economy.

Within Protection’s Manhattan office, Para and his coworkers felt growing pressure to respond to this crisis quickly and ethically. But morale was sagging and decision making was stalled. New projects were on hold, revenues weren’t coming in fast enough, and job cuts were imminent. Finger-pointing and resignations of key managers had become commonplace. Strong leadership was needed to guide employees to stay the course. Para knew his first priority was to replace Jack Nixon. When leaving the meeting last night, his boss had told him, “It’s critical that we keep key managers in place as we weather this storm. If we lose any, be sure you replace them with ones who can handle the stress and can make tough, maybe even unpopular, decisions.”

Working up a sweat as he rushed into his office, Para began sorting through the day’s priorities. His first task would be to consider internal candidates to replace Nixon. He pondered the characteristics required of a chief securities analyst and scribbled them on a notepad: experienced in security and regulatory issues; strong decision-making skills; high ethical standards; able to make job cuts; comfortable slashing budgets; and respected for calm leadership. Para immediately thought of June Jacob, a senior analyst who had been vocal about her desire to move up and had recently shown steady leadership as the organization started to crumble.

Jacob had worked her way up through the organization, becoming a respected expert in her field. She had developed a strong team of loyal employees and made training and job development a priority. She was likable, sensitive to her employees, and a consensus builder. While many managers within Protection had made questionable business decisions, June had held herself to a high ethical standard and created a culture of integrity. Jacob was focused on the future—a go-getter who knew how to get results.

With the future of the company at stake, however, Para wondered if Jacob could handle the tough challenges ahead. Although he valued her team-building skills, she could be soft when it came to holding employees accountable. A large part of her motivation was to have people like her. When she reported a shortfall in earnings in the last company meeting and came under fire, she’d become defensive and didn’t want to point fingers at employees who were to blame. In fact, Para recalled another instance when Jacob recoiled at the thought of firing an employee who had developed a pattern of poor attendance while caring for her sick husband. She confessed a hesitation to confront poor performers and employees struggling to balance home and work life.

Para stirred his morning coffee and wondered aloud, “Is June Jacob capable of balancing kindness and toughness during a crisis? Can I count on her to be decisive and focused on top- and bottom-line results? Is she too much of a people pleaser? Will it impact her ability to lead successfully?”

QUESTION:

Define the leader’s and manager’s approach (mindset) to solving the dilemma.

Determine Para’s solution if he used the leader’s perspective and then if he used the manager’s perspective. Do you see a difference? If so what differences? If not, why not? Could the outcome be the same and still benefit the company?

Reference no: EM131192561

Questions Cloud

Unemployment compensation insurance on the instructors : You have been hired as the new assistant manager of a U.S. flying school. The first day on the job, you learn that the school considers all of its flight instructors to be independent contractors. The school does not withhold payroll taxes or maintai..
Aggregation-adaptation and arbitrage : How should have consideration of the AAA Strategies (Aggregation, Adaptation and Arbitrage) affected the thinking of Vodafone executives while pondering this sale? How does sizeism factor in this sale?
Customer loyalty can be powerful competitive advantage : Customer loyalty can be a powerful competitive advantage. And customer loyalty is more than repeat purchasing. Customers who are loyal tend to buy more over time and, more importantly, tend to recommend a company to their family, friends, and colleag..
Most significant or descriptive home parameters : For this discussion, identify what you consider to be the three most significant or descriptive home parameters (that is, price mean, price mode, home size mean, home size mode, and so on) to give your clients an understanding of the Boca market, and..
Define the leader and manager approach to solving dilemma : Juan Para hit the snooze alarm for the third time, but he knew he could never go back to sleep. Rubbing his eyes and shaking off a headache, Para first checked his IPHONE and read an urgent message from his boss, explaining that Jack Nixon, chief sec..
Calculating maintenance cost and labor cost : A machine that produces a certain piece must be turned off by the operator after each piece is completed. The machine "coasts" for 15 seconds after it is turned off, thus preventing the operator from removing the piece quickly before producing the ne..
Work breakdown structure-activities for cell phone design : You work for Nokia in their global cell phone group. You have been made project manager for the design of a new cell phone. Your supervisors have already scoped the project so you have a list showing the work breakdown structure and this includes maj..
Most important factor contributing to motivation : Why do you think making progress ranks as the most important factor contributing to motivation according to a recent study? How can managers provide a sense of progress for employees working on long-range projects that might not show results for mont..
What specific customer service measures : Describe the advantages of using a balanced scorecard to measure and control organizational performance. Suppose you created a balanced scorecard for Walmart. What specific customer service measures would you include?

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Operation Management Questions & Answers

  Lincoln electric case study

What can we learn about the criteria for choosing among alternative foreign market entry modes from studying Lincoln Electric’s entry into India?

  What was his purpose in painting death of marat

How is the concept of art and idea illustrated in the life and work of Jacques-Louis David? What was his purpose in painting Death of Marat? Was he successful?

  Explain the process of the card campaign

Explain the process of the “card campaign”. When can a bargaining unit call for recognition? If the employer does not agree, what is the result?

  Decides to take approach to performance reward systems

The CEO of XYZ Corporation decides to take a similar approach to performance reward systems used by General Electric/Jack Welch and a number of other organizations. Top performers would receive the largest bonuses and raises while bottom performers w..

  What is you best choice using emv criterion

Dalton and Carla run a small bicycle shop called " D n C"Bicycles.They must order bicycles for the coming season. Orders for the bicycle must be placed in quantities of twenty(20).

  The behavior of many of his officers reflects a lack

Chief Draper has noticed that the behavior of many of his officers reflects a lack of understanding of many basic criminal justice concepts. Last week, he received a complaint about a patrol officer with ten years of experience on the force.

  What are the most challenging aspects of this decision

What are the most challenging aspects of this decision. What are the implications of your decision that you are most concerned about.

  Explain however, government constraints put a maximum

Explain however, government constraints put a maximum of 4,000 hours of overtime labour per month in April also May.

  Order to ensure that vital consumer information

What can marketers and organizations do in order to ensure that vital consumer information is private and that consumers feel comfortable visiting their websites and participating in data research?

  Describe the motivation for planning

Explain the Internet's effects on planning by how it influences 1) the motivation for planning, 2) the processes for planning, and 3) the outcomes of planning. Be sure to give complete explanations of each effect, using examples in your discussio..

  Important for the top management to use particular reports

Even within a same industry, giants such as Wallmart or Macys, have their own specialized AIS. It is important for the top management to use particular reports that will provide them with the best possible oversight of their business performance. Rep..

  Differences between structured and agile development methods

Your interview seemed to go well, but you did not get the job.During the meeting, the interviewer mentioned that they use structured analysis and rely heavily on modeling, prototyping, and CASE tools. What are the main differences between structured,..

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd