Critical evaluation of court case

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM131016495

Critical Evaluation of Court Case

It is important to understand the impact an expert testimony may have in the ultimate decision made by a court. In addition, it is helpful for practitioners of forensic psychology to be able to read and understand legal cases.

Tasks: Click here or copy and paste https://www.courts.state.va.us/opinions/opnscvwp/1041454.pdf to review the case Commonwealth of Virginia v. Allen (2005).

The case describes an appellate legal opinion or court decision involving expert witness testimony. When a case is appealed, it goes to an appellate or to a higher court. The appellate court then reviews the findings of the lower court, which in this case was the trial court. The appellate court offered the following two opinions:

• The first opinion (Commonwealth of Virginia v. Allen, 2005, pp. 1-24) is the majority opinion and is the one that counts.

• The second opinion (Commonwealth of Virginia v. Allen, 2005, pp. 24-31) is an opinion filed by a minority of judges who concurred (agreed) in part and dissented (disagreed) in part with the majority of the judges who ruled.

After reading the appellate legal opinion, write a 2- to 3-page paper addressing the following:

• Discuss whether either of the expert witnesses in this case acted unethically. Support your opinion with the relevant APA or specialty ethical guidelines.

• Indicate whether you agree with the majority decision or the minority concurring or dissenting opinion. Explain why.

Reference no: EM131016495

Questions Cloud

The company has just opened a new plant to manufacture : McCracken Aerial, Inc., produces and sells a unique type of TV antenna.
Justify why the company should implement your recommendation : Metrics: Which metrics should the company track using the tool and strategy you have chosen? Why? Explain what each metric represents and why it is important.
Show the various ways that couples goals can be achive : Three retired couples each require an additional annual income of $2000 per year. Prepare a table for each couple showing the various ways that their goals can be achive.
What tactics can attorneys use to elicit estimony : What tactics can attorneys use to elicit or distort testimony from an expert witness? Describe any three tactics you know of from your readings and your experience. Use examples to illustrate your response
Critical evaluation of court case : Critical Evaluation of Court Case - It is important to understand the impact an expert testimony may have in the ultimate decision made by a court. In addition, it is helpful for practitioners of forensic psychology to be able to read and understa..
Describe the fields and options associated with user account : Workgroup networks are small. Domain networks are larger. List at least three other distinctions found in a comparison of workgroups and domains.
What are the potential ethical issues raised in scenario : What are the potential ethical issues raised in this scenario? Be sure to support your response with the appropriate ethical guidelines from the APA's Ethical Principles of Psychologists and Code of Conduct and Specialty Guidelines for Forensic Ps..
Discuss the successes and challenges of the pilot : Discuss the problem or challenge you addressed
Implementation of sophisticated derivative strategies : As the manager of a large, well-diversified school endowment fund, you are actively considering the implementation of sophisticated derivative strategies to protect your fund's market value in the event of a substantial decline in the overall leve..

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Measuring safety performance

Investigate how your current organization, or an organization with which you are familiar, measures safety performance.

  How much alpha energy was absorbed

The efficiency of a scintillation detector is 5.1%. It absorbs alpha radiaion, producing 41,100 photons of average wavelength 4800 angstroms. How much alpha energy was absorbed?

  Principles of the effective management of individual change

Discuss how your personal learning relates to general principles of the effective management of individual change. You should finish with an outline of your plans for changes that you will make to help you to achieve your future personal and caree..

  Price reduction to customers

When Whallans Gift Card Shop offers a price reduction to customers who buy Christmas cards the week after Christmas, Whallans is giving a(n) ________ discount.

  Discusses a medical ethics case

Find a news paper article that discusses a medical ethics case. Summarize the article and offer an opinion on whether the case is a legal, ethical, or bioethical one.

  Write a well-developed essay 750-1000 words that evaluates

write a well-developed essay 750-1000 words that evaluates a non-christian countrys criminal justice system and

  Why must sociologists be interested in stratification how

to talk about the rich the poor and the way society is economically stratified sounds like the job of economists. why

  What does the humanisticexistential approach say about free

what does the humanisticexistential approach say about free will? how does this conflict with what a behaviorist might

  What are the symptoms of the health issue

What is the health issue/condition? (Name, definition) What are the symptoms of the health issue, if any? What are the long-term consequences of the health issue, if any

  Diseases of nerves that affect muscles

Explain the disorder/damage and how it specifically impacts the muscle system (effects can be direct or indirect). Diseases of nerves that affect muscles (Parkinson's disease), Diseases of nerves that affect muscles (Multiple sclerosis)

  Techniques for correcting problems

Describe some types of problems resulting from digital photography/why you would want to manipulate an image? Describe some techniques for correcting problems resulting from digital photography.

  Explain need for clothing functional biologically-socially

Need for clothing is functional, both biologically and socially. Though, it is society (and particularly culture) and shapes what we wear, how we wear it, and meaning we give to clothing and fashion.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd