Counterargument for causality
Course:- Science
Reference No.:- EM13758370

Assignment Help
Expertsmind Rated 4.9 / 5 based on 47215 reviews.
Review Site
Assignment Help >> Science

As you work through these questions, remember that association does not equal causation. If a statement sounds reasonable, you may find it helpful to try to refute any arguments for causation - think about reasons a factor is unlikely to operate as a cause. In fact, the best way to approach causality if often to try to create a counterargument for causality. For example, if the rooster crows at the break of dawn, then the rooster caused the sun to rise. We can refute this statement by hypothesizing that if we kill the rooster (or perhaps just sedate him for awhile), the sun will still rise. Imagine scenarios where your causal argument would not work, and move through the logic. This is what epidemiologists do every day!

Association does not necessarily mean causation. Consider the role of each component cause and a necessary cause (if there is one) in a completed sufficient cause. Be sure to ask yourself "what is a cause?"

Part A.

Read the online news clipping about the fictitious town of Epiville

Using your knowledge of causal criteria, which of the following statements best explains the Mayor's false belief that increasing the stork population would increase the birth rate? Explain why the other 2 are false.

1  The Mayor implied there was an association between the stork population and the birth rate that was not there.

2  The Mayor mistakenly thought that 2 factors which are statistically associated (the stork population and the birth rate) must be causally related.

3  The Mayor neglected to look at the statistical significance of the association. Only if the results were statistically significant could he conclude that a causal relationship exists.

Part B.

Imagine you are an intern at your state health department, which has just launched a new initiative to reduce risk-seeking behaviors among adolescents. The Commissioner asks you if you think that internet use among adolescents is "a cause" of risk-seeking behavior (e.g., smoking, drinking, skipped meals, irregular sleep habits, and sexual activity). You think back to your Introduction to Epidemiology class and recall that epidemiologists have a fairly distinct definition of "cause". Which of the following statements best describes the hypothesized causal link between internet use and risk-seeking behaviors, and why? For the other 2 statements, why do they not describe the causal link?

1  All individuals with long hours of Internet use during childhood will go on to risk-seeking behaviors in adolescence.

2  All individuals who initiate risk-seeking behaviors in adolescence would have been exposed to substantial internet use during childhood.

3  Individuals who spend a substantial amount of time on the internet in childhood are more likely to initiate risk-seeking behaviors in adolescence, compared with those individuals who use spend little or no time on the internet during childhood.

Part C.

You decide to draw some "causal pies" to help you think about how internet use might act as a cause of risk-seeking behavior in adolescence. Based on the causal pies given below, answer the following questions. Explain your answer - if it is true, what is the rationale? If it is false, why?

1407_causal pies.jpg

1. True or false: Internet use is a necessary cause of risk-seeking behavior.

2. True or false: Internet use is a cause of risk-seeking behavior that is neither necessary nor sufficient.

3. True or false: Internet use is a sufficient cause of risk-seeking behavior.

4. Do these sufficient causes yield alternative hypotheses about possible causes of risk-seeking behavior in adolescents?

Put your comment

Ask Question & Get Answers from Experts
Browse some more (Science) Materials
Brittany was a term infant born vaginally with no intrapartum complications. Birth weight was 8 pounds 1 ounce and current weight is 26 pounds 9 ounces.She was breastfed unt
Seena tells you that her preschooler is attending a Montessori program; you pick up your niece from her preschool and wonder if she might also be enrolled in this same type of
Assume that you have RCRA responsibilities at your manufacturing facility. As a refiner of petroleum products, you collect and drum waste material from the bottom of the dis
Traffic Network Analysis PPT Which transportation network type is appropriate to use in the traffic analysis of your city if you were a traffic planner (Radcliff, KY)? As an
Write a valid statement as to the support of this article, and its proposed information regarding whether humans are still evolving. Link: http://www.the-scientist.com/?art
How does aging influence calcium status? Is the effect different in men and women? Explain.Based on what you have learned about the ACA, how do you think this legislation wil
Government's Role in Energy There are two important sources of energy: renewable and non-renewable sources. Given the implications of externalities, this undermines the abil
A population of 500,000 around a nuclear facility receives an average wholebody dose of 0.5 rad as a result of an accidental release of radionuclides.(a) Estimate the collecti