Counter-argument to training leaders

Assignment Help Business Management
Reference no: EM1326867

As a counter-argument to training leaders, organizations spend billions of dollars on leadership training every year. Some believe that much of this effort to train leaders is probably a waste of money; this position is based on two very basic assumptions that underlie leadership training.

The first assumption is that we know what leadership is, and yet we do not. Experts cannot agree if it is a trait, a characteristic, a behavior, a role, a style or an ability. The second basic assumption is that we can train people to lead. We do seem to be able teach individuals about leadership. Unfortunately, findings indicate we are not so good at teaching people how to lead. Apparently, some people may not have the right personality traits, and there is no evidence that individuals can substantially alter their basic leadership style. Additionally, the complexity of leadership theories makes it nearly impossible for any normal human being to assimilate all the variables and be capable of enacting the right behaviors in every situation.

The second basic assumption is that we can train people to lead. The evidence here is not very encouraging. While we appear able to teach individuals about leadership, findings indicate we "cannot" teach people to lead due to several possible explanations. To the degree that personality is a critical element in leadership effectiveness, some people may not have been born with the right personality traits. A second explanation is that there is no evidence that individuals can substantially alter their basic leadership style. A third possibility is that, even if certain theories could actually guide individuals in leadership situations and even if individuals could alter their style, the complexity of those theories make it nearly impossible for any of us to assimilate all the variables and be capable of enacting the right behaviors in every situation.

What is your reaction to these arguments?

Reference no: EM1326867

Questions Cloud

Creating leadership handbook for managers in organization : To help new managers in an organization, you have been asked to create a handbook. Create a leadership handbook by doing the following.
Economic policies which could have on the sales : Express the effects of government economic policies which could have on the sales of the Escalade
Explaining the law of hire-purchase : An antique collector, entered a contract for purchase of an antique watch, which was described in good faith, by Farid, the seller, as more than 100 years of age.
Discuss the effectiveness of these security features : Secure Web sites often include 'enhanced security questions' or 'security images' in an attempt to assure that only authorized users could access the sites. Research and discuss effectiveness of these security features.
Counter-argument to training leaders : A third possibility is that, even if certain theories could actually guide individuals in leadership situations and even if individuals could alter their style. What is your reaction to these arguments?
Students explore the reasons behind regulating banks : In the particular assignment due this week, students explore the reasons behind regulating banks also how that regulation relates.
Develop an application with the chosen dbms : A school intends to procure the integrated student management application holding all details of registered students including personal information, courses taken, and examination grades.
Discussing law of hire-purchase : Karim bought a second hand Toyota Hilux from Jamin Baik Sdn Bhd. On 15 January 2012, he signed a hire-purchase agreement for the car with OUR Bank.
Program that stores and converts a number : Write down a program that stores and converts a number entered in Roman numerals to an integer value. Your program should consist of a class named Roman.

Reviews

Write a Review

Business Management Questions & Answers

  Significance of learning about organizational behaviour

What is the meaning of Organizational Behaviour and significance of learning about Organizational Behaviour, values and ethics; workplace emotions and attitudes.

  Middle market segment between low-end products

Evaluate the extent to which there are any bases of relatedness among the four products. Identify two countries outside of the U.S. that you feel would be an opportunity for a potential business expansion and explain the basis for your selection.

  Key cultural or organizational legacy

Discuss 3 factors or characteristics that you think makes this individual (CEO) an effective leader. What do you think will be the key cultural or organizational legacy this leader will leave behind?

  Strengths and shortcomings of decentralized approach

What are some of strengths and shortcomings of decentralized approach to training managers and hourly employees.

  Leadership style use to approach employee

What leadership style would you use to approach this employee? If he doesn't bother anyone else and is productive, why are you concerned with what he does?

  Lens of quantitative analysis

You will inspect a problem or issue through the lens of Quantitative Analysis. This incomes that you must choose a project that is very specific, focused and one on which you have a grasp of the inputs, process and outputs.

  Leveraging the power of differences: workforce diversity

Leveraging the Power of Differences: Workforce Diversity and the Impact of Information Systems.

  Discuss how the combination of internet technologies

Discuss how the combination of Internet technologies and Robotics will displace jobs in the next ten years. Competitive Threats Acting on the e-Business.

  Cost categories of quality

Explain about the four main cost categories of quality.

  Identify two sources of resistance to change in the perrier

Identify two sources of resistance to change in the Perrier case study also describe Elucidate how the organization dealt with each type of resistance.

  How organizational ethics is product of societal

Describe how organizational ethics is a product of societal, professional, and individual ethics, and explain what happens when ethical behaviour is compromised.

  Propose three ways of mentor and new employee

Propose three ways that a mentor and a new employee orientation can assist employees with their career development.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd