Claims regarding the morality of abortion

Assignment Help Other Subject
Reference no: EM13522684

A. In all the questions that form part of this discussion make sure you give evidence from the texts in support of your views. Don Marquis makes the following claims regarding the morality of abortion:

1. The standard view against the killing of humans is that what makes ending a human’s life morally wrong is that it is a human life. 

2. Life does not begin at birth, not even at conception, because biologically there was life before conception.  The standard view is flawed because it would make contraception wrong.

3. What makes killing a human being wrong is depriving her/him of future value, some of which the person may not value now.

4. Fetuses have futures very much like ours. Their futures contain whatever ours contain and more. 

5. Therefore:  Given certain defensible assumptions and a few qualifications, abortion is immoral.

How would Joel Feinberg evaluate Marquis’ claims by applying the claims found in his “Abortion” essay?

B. J. Gay Williams has objections about the term “passive euthanasia.” What are the implications of those semantic objections for Klemens Kappel’s views about the morality of euthanasia? In other words, how would Williams judge Kappel’s views, given his (Williams’) objections to the concept

“passive euthanasia.”

C. Abortion and euthanasia are problematic moral issues because they are widely considered issues regarding homicide of innocent persons. In that sense, they go together as part of a consistent human life ethic.  Explain how you would decide the Feinberg-Marquis and Kappel-Williams debates and how your moral judgments in these two cases form part of a consistent human life ethic.

Reference no: EM13522684

Questions Cloud

Why are stoics potentially troublesome for autocratic regime : What is the appropriate way that the Stoic sage feels pain? Why are stoics potentially troublesome for autocratic regimes?
Ultimately essential for a stoic sage to have no regrets : What is ultimately essential for a Stoic sage to have no regrets?
What major advance in semantics did the stoics accomplish : What major advance in semantics did the Stoics accomplish?
Which is a good stoic slogan : Which is a good Stoic slogan?
Claims regarding the morality of abortion : The standard view against the killing of humans is that what makes ending a human’s life morally wrong is that it is a human life. Life does not begin at birth, not even at conception, because biologically there was life before conception.  The sta..
What is descartess evil demon or evil genius hypothesis : What is Descartes's "Evil Demon" or "Evil Genius" hypothesis?  Why does he bring it into his investigations?  What conclusions does he draw from his belief that it could conceivably be true?
What common sense principle does stoic physics violate : What common sense principle does Stoic physics violate?
Make an inductive generalization : When we make an inductive generalization, we draw a conclusion
The republicans proposal to cut taxes on capital gains : "The Republicans' proposal to cut taxes on capital gains (profits from selling real estate, stocks, and bonds) is not a sop for the wealthy. It is a way to stimulate investment and ultimately to create jobs. That's why it is in everyone's interest..

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Other Subject Questions & Answers

  Consequences mentioned in the readings

List and briefly explain three factors of subordinate group creation as defined by schaefer(2006) along with three consequences mentioned in the readings

  Consciousness raising-social action-community development

Pick any social issue.Suggest how these seven approaches could be applied to the issue: consciousness raising. social action. community development. community coalitions

  How can harley benefit from expanding abroad

How can Harley benefit from expanding abroad and what types of advantages can the firm obtain? What advantages acquired abroad can help Harley im-prove its performance in its home market?

  Average age-of-onset of schizophrenia

What are the gender differences in (1) the average age-of-onset of schizophrenia and (2)the severity of symptoms?

  How should the intermediate temperature be selected

Consider the combination of the two heat engines in series. How should the intermediate temperature be selected so the two heat engines have the same efficiency assuming Carnot cycle heat engines?

  What determines their distribution channels or strategy

Marketers determine which channels to use based on characteristics, positioning strategies, and branding tactics of the products. Think about products such as chewing gum, Coach products, and the new Ford Leaf. What determines their distribution chan..

  Communication during active listening

do you frame at the start of the communication or at other points in time of the communication (for instance during active listening)? Also do you frame even if you are unaware of the concept of framing?

  Sign-off on key deliverables

Scope ____________________ is often achieved by a customer inspection and then sign – off on key deliverables.

  Radio transponder and landing guidance system

Several years ago, a multilateral treaty came into effect among some 45 countries, including most of the major developed countries of the world. the treaty, known as the Outer Space Treaty, forbids any member state from claiming " any planet, satelli..

  What strategic alternatives are open to starbucks

"Starbucks' International Operations" in your text. Using your readings, the Cybrary and the Internet write responses to each of the following: What is your impression of the world wide operation of Starbucks. Conduct a SWOT Analysis of Starbucks.

  Minimum of two project charter templates-variety of sources

Research a minimum of two project charter templates from a variety of sources. Evaluate and describe what you did or did not like about each. Include the website URL where each template was found. Be sure to discuss what value you think the charter w..

  Wants to stop smoking cigarettes

A friend of yours wants to stop smoking cigarettes. Describe this proposed behavior change in terms of (a) one aspect of the Health Belief Model and one aspect of the Theory of Planned Behavior,

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd