Case study: the debate over ceo compensation

Assignment Help International Economics
Reference no: EM1367876

The most visible and highly paid person in most corporations is the chief executive officer (CEO). CEO compensation is particularly important to firms for three reasons. First, the compensation package is likely to be important in attracting and retaining good CEOs. Second, the form of the pay contract is likely to help determine whether the CEO focuses on value maximization or some other objective. Third, employees throughout the organization carefully follow their CEOâ??s pay. Important morale problems can occur when employees think that the CEO is overpaid. For instance, employees complain bitterly when they are asked to take pay cuts because the company is in trouble, yet at the same time the CEO gets a big raise.
Controversy over CEO pay has increased substantially in recent years. One charge is that the level of CEO pay is too high. CEO pay is so huge that people donâ??t believe they deserve it. It is easy to pint to many ECOS who report compensation in the millions of dollars (reported compensation figures typically include salary and bonus payments, as well as gains from the exercise of stock options). Consider the following two examples. Investors were outraged when E Trade Group Inc. disclosed it had paid out a $77 million compensation package for CEO Christos M. Cotsakos in 2001- a year in which the financial-services company lost $242 million. When Cotsakos pledged later to return $21 million, the complaints hardly subsided. In 2001 Qwest Communications posted a $4 billion loss and employees were laid off. However, Qwestâ??s CEO, Joseph Nacchio, received a $1.5 million bonus, $24 millions in cash, $74 million in exercised options, and was granted 7.25 million in new options. In 1980, CEO compensation was 42 times that of the average worker. In 2000, it was 531 times.
The second major criticism of CEO pay concerns how CEOs are paid. Critics argue that CEOs are agents of stockholders and that CEO pay should be based heavily on stock-price performance. In some celebrated cases CEO pay appears disconnected to CEO performance. For example, Ford Motor Co. reported $5.45 billion loss in 2001. Workers were laid off, and salaries for nearly everyone left suffered. Even though former Ford CEO Jacques Nasser was fired, he still received about $20 million in compensation for the year. Since 1980, the increasing use of stock options has boosted the sensitivity of the average CEOâ??s wealth to firm performance. However, the absolute sensitivity of CEO wealth to performance remains small. Research indicates that for a $1,000 change in firm value, the wealth of the average CEO of a large public corporation changes by only about $10.57. Some argue this relation (which is equivalent to the CEO owning 1.057 percent of the common stock) is too small and that most companies would be better off if they increased incentive pay for CEOs. Some support for this view seems to come from studies that document an increase in stock price when companies announce that they are increasing incentive pay for CEOs.
1. do you think the fact that most CEOs are paid so much more than rank and file employees suggests CEOs are overpaid? Explain
2. Japanese CEOs generally receive much lower levels of compensation than CEOs in the US. Does this imply that US CEOs are overpaid?
3. It is obvious $10.57 per thousand is too low of an incentive pay for CEOs? Explain.
4. Does the observation that the stock price increases when the firms increase incentive pay for CEOs suggest that most CEOs do not receive enough incentive compensation?explain.
5. Are they any reason any reasons why overpaying CEOs might be in the shareholder s interest?

Parkleigh Pharmacy is a small department store in Rochester NY, specializing in upscale, expensive personal accessories like sunglasses, beauty aids,leather goods, and home decorations like crystal,china,table lamps. Kaufmann s is a large department store chain based in Pennsylvania with several stores in the Rochester area. Kaufmann s carries broader range of products and caters more to middle income consumers.
Salespeople at Parkleigh are paid a straight hourly wage it does mean no commisions. In addition, they are entitled to a 30 percent discount on anything they buy at the store. By contrast, salespeople at Kaufmann s are paid an hourly wage which means lower than the the hourly wage paid at Parkleigh, plus a commission of 5 percent on sales they make. They receive no discount on product the buy at Kaufmann s.
1. why do you think the compensation plan differ at the two firms? In particular why do you think Kaufmann s pays commission to salespeople, while Parkleigh does not? Why does Parkleigh offer employees discounts on purchases, while Kaufmann s does not?
2. Assume for the moment , that neither store pays sales commisssions. Parkleigh offers hourly wage plus the employee discount. Kaufmann s offers only an hourly wage. Do you expect Kaufmann s hourly wage to be higher or lower than Parkleigh s? why?

 

Reference no: EM1367876

Questions Cloud

Difference between accounting and economic profit : What is the law of diminishing returns? Can you provide an example of when diminishing returns have set in (could set in) at a work place?
Clinical coach-preceptor or mentor : You are a clinical coach, preceptor, or mentor on your floor at St. Whocare's. You are working with two different Registered Nurses-one with one year of experience and the other with ten years.
Optimal pricing-consumer surplus : Find out the optimal price and quantity with standard pricing. Which is the per-customer profit for the gym? What is the consumer surplus?
Illustrate whether program will fit in address space : Will this program fit in address space? If page size were 512 bytes, would it fit? Remember that page may not contain parts of two different segments.
Case study: the debate over ceo compensation : The most visible and highly paid person in most corporations is the chief executive officer (CEO). CEO compensation is particularly important to firms for three reasons.
Illustrate implications of computing a multiple regression : Illustrate what are implications of computing a multiple regression when repressors are orthogonal. Illustrate what is significance of idempotent matrix.
Computing profit maximizing price and output level : Derive the profit maximizing price and the profits at this price. What is the demand elasticity at this price? What is the total demand when the monopolist charges a price P?
Elucidate how advertising can be employed to allow tots-r-us : Elucidate how advertising can be employed to allow Tots-R-Us to keep cost above average cost with encouraging entry.
Postmerger herfindahl hirschman index : Assume Fiat recently entered into an Agreement and Plan of Merger with Case for $4.3 billion. Prior to the merger, market for four wheel drive tractors consisted of 5-company's.

Reviews

Write a Review

 

International Economics Questions & Answers

  Define nafta

Define NAFTA using the internet to gather some information about NAFTA and why and when it was started?

  Determine the cross rate between francs and pounds

Assume the exchange rate between United State, dollars and the Swiss franc was SFr1.6=$1, and the exchange rate between United State dollars and British pound was L1=$1.50.

  The absolute and relative sizes of the public debt

Explain How do economists distinguish between the absolute and relative sizes of the public debt? Why is the distinction important?

  Floating exchange rates

Suppose that economic growth is slower in the U.S. than in its trading partners. Given a system of floating exchange rates, will the impact of this growth differential be for US with respect to exports and the value of the dollar?

  Exchange rate of the country

Suppose that a nation faces a balance of payments deficit with high unemployment. Determine what exchange-rate adjustment can be made to solve these problems?

  Determine the dollar price of the cars

The United State imports Japanese cars with a domestic price of 5,000,000 yen and the yen or dollar exchange rate is 120 on January 1, 2003.

  Calculate the average annual return and the variance

From the following data, calculate the average annual return, the variance, standard deviation,and coefficient of variation for each asset.

  Calculate exchange value of the pound

Assume that under the Bretton Woods system, dollar is pegged to gold at a rate of $35 a ounce and pound sterling is pegged to the dollar at a rate of $2 = £1.

  Expansionary fiscal policy and tight monetary policy

Determine the effects of one country pursuing expansionary fiscal policy and tight monetary policy?

  Aggregate demand slopes downward

With respect to aggregate supply and aggregate demand, what will be most likely to happen when quantity supplied exceeds the quantity demanded?

  What will be the effects of an increase in the money supply

What will be the effects of an increase in the money supply

  Impact of exchange rate on exports

Suppose that a country's real growth is 2% a year, while its real deficit is rising 5% per year. Can the country continue to afford such deficit indefinitely?

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd