Can marshall and wyatt validly refuse to surrender

Assignment Help Econometrics
Reference no: EM131046891

SEC Regulation, Tax, and Working Papers Marshall and Wyatt, CPA, have been for several years the independent auditors of Interstate LDC Land Development Corporation of New Orleans, Louisiana. During these years, Interstate LDC prepared and filed its own annual income tax returns. During 20X3, Interstate LDC requested Marshall and Wyatt to audit all the necessary financial statements of the corporation to be submitted to the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) in connection with a multi-state public offering of one million shares of Interstate Land Development Corporation common stock. This public offering came under the provisions of the US Securities Act of 1933. The audit was performed carefully and the financial statements were fairly presented for the respective periods. These financial statements were included in the registration statement filed with the SEC. While the registration statement was being processed by the SEC, but before the effective date, the US taxing authority, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), obtained a federal court subpoena directing Marshall and Wyatt to turn over all of its working papers relating to Interstate LDC for the years 20X0-X2. Marshall and Wyatt initially refused to comply for two reasons. First, Marshall and Wyatt did not prepare Interstate LDC's tax returns. Second, Marshall and Wyatt claimed that the working papers were confidential matters subject to the privileged communications rule. Subsequently, however, Marshall and Wyatt did relinquish the subpoenaed working papers. Upon receiving the subpoena, Wyatt called Dan Dunkirk, the chairman of Interstate LDC's board of directors, and asked him about IRS investigation. Dunkirk responded, "I'm sure the IRS people are on a ‘fishing expedition' and that they will not find any material deficiencies." A few days later Chairman Dunkirk received a written memorandum from the IRS stating that Interstate LDC had underpaid its taxes during the period under review. The memorandum revealed that Interstate LDC was being assessed $800,000, including penalties and interest for the three years. Dunkirk forwarded a copy of this memorandum to Marshall and Wyatt. This $800,000 assessment was material relative to the financial statements as of December 31, 20X3. The amount for each year individually, exclusive of penalty and interest, was not material relative to each respective year.

Required:

A. In general terms, discuss the extent to which a US CPA firm's potential liability to third parities is increased in an SEC registration audit.

B. Discuss the implications of the IRS investigation, if any, relative to Marshall and Wyatt's audit of Interstate LDC's 20X3 financial statements. Discuss any additional investigative procedures that the auditors should undertake or any audit judgments that should be made as result of this investigation.

C. Can Marshall and Wyatt validly refuse to surrender the subpoenaed working papers to the IRS? Explain

Reference no: EM131046891

Questions Cloud

Constitution of national advisory committee : Section 210A concerning the Constitution of National Advisory Committee in Government for advice on the formulation and laying down of accounting policy and accounting standards for adoption by the companies or class of companies under the Act, ha..
What percent of the variation in price at the grocery store : What percent of the variation in price at the grocery store is explained by the linear relationship between the stores' prices
What are the legal requirements and liabilities for grc : 1. What are the legal requirements and liabilities for GRC? How have other organizations addressed similar situations? 2. Who are the stakeholders?
Write a paper on harassment - discrimination prevention tips : Write on a two page double spaced paper utilizing three references. The easiest way to find information is to do a google search.
Can marshall and wyatt validly refuse to surrender : Can Marshall and Wyatt validly refuse to surrender the subpoenaed working papers to the IRS? Explain
An ocean transfer cargo ship : An Ocean Transfer cargo ship was forced to jettison some cargo during a severe storm. The various interests in the voyage at the time the property was jettisoned are the following:
Essence of project management : Consider the following statement: "The essence of project management is risk management." What does it mean in terms of completing a project successfully? Support your response with evidence from the readings or other materials. Be sure to use APA..
Determining the balance sheet of the company : On April 1, 2013, stock of Rs. 2,25,000 was destroyed by fire. The company closes its account on 31st March. If the balance sheet of the company on 31st March, 2013 was finalized on 25th April, 2013, then the balance sheet will show the closing st..
Investigate the possibility of related parties : List the circumstances at D'orsay Dore that may indicate the existence of unidentified related parties. C. What audit procedures should Clement & Grandcourt perform to investigate the possibility of related parties?

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Econometrics Questions & Answers

  What is the minimum price the country with advantages

In a day of production, firms in Angola can produce 200 liters of oil or 100 kilograms of tungsten. Firms in Namibia can produce 160 liters of oil or 60 kilograms of tungsten. Which country has comparative advantage in tungstenabsolute advantage in..

  Equations to solve for market equilibrium price and quantity

Explain what would happen to equilibrium price and quantity in the market for Pepsi if the following occurred (be sure to indicate WHY it happens as well): a. The price of Coke decreases. b. Average household income falls from $50,000 to $43,..

  Determine what is the gdp of japanese goods

Within Japan, the market value of all the final goods and services produced by Americans is $50 billion, and the market value of all the final goods and services produced by Japanese is $100 billion. what is the GDP of Japan

  What is central planning

discuss both"the argument for relying on non profit organization for the public services For example:non profit organizations can provide public services better and more cheaply than state owned or private for profit organization and also they int..

  Calculate the total revenues for each price-quantity

Given the simple demand schedule information in the table above, calculate the coefficient of price elasticity of demand four times. Note that the coefficient of price elasticity of demand over the entire range of the demand schedule is 1, indicat..

  Why economy were operating at employment govt expenditure

Suppose that government expenditures are currently $700 billion and tax revenues are currently $550 billion. Assume further that the government estimates that if the economy were operating at full employment government expenditures would only be $..

  Determine what is the direct utility function

Consider the indirect utility function: v(p1; p2; m) = m /(p1 + p2) a. Derive the Marshallian demand functions.b. What is the expenditure function c. What is the direct utility function

  What is the taxable income at the end of year

An injection-molding machine can be purchased and installed for $90,000. It is in the seven-year GDS property class and is expected to be kept in service for eight years. It is believed that $10,000 can be obtained when the machine is disposed of ..

  What is marginal utility of money equal at lower income

An individual lives in a world where there are only two goods, X and Y. His utility function per period is given by: U = 25x - 0.5x^2 + 50y - y^2 The price of x is $4 and the price of y is $8.What is his marginal utility of money equal to at this l..

  Determine what is the macrs-gds property class

A high-precision programmable router for shaping furniture components is purchased by Henderson for $190,000. It is expected to last 12 years. Calculate the depreciation deduction and book value for each year using MACRS-GDS allowances.

  What combinations of income and consumption for a student

Real Disposable Income Planned Real Consumption 0 3,000 2,000 4,400 4,000 5,800 6,000 7,200 8,000 8,600 10,000 10,000 12,000 11,400 14,000 12,800 Refer to Table 12.1. The table gives the combinations of income and consumption.

  Define the internal rate of return method

Define the Internal Rate of Return (IRR) method in capital budgeting and state the IRR Decision rule.

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd