Both globally and locally in the global automobile industry

Assignment Help Operation Management
Reference no: EM131367013

Mini Case study: Alliance Formation, Both Globally and Locally, in the Global Automobile Industry

The academic literature on alliances has some interesting recent findings, one of which is the rationale that because firms are often located in the same country, and often in the same region of the country, it is easier for them to collaborate on major projects. As such, they compete globally, but may cooperate locally. Historically, firms have learned to collaborate by establishing strategic alliances and froming cooperative strategies when there is intensive competition. This interesting paradox is due to several reasons. FIrst, when there is intense rivalry, it is difficult to maintain market power. As such, using a cooperative strategy can reduce market power through better norms of competition; this pertains to the idea of "mutual forbearance:. Another rationale that has emerged is based on the resource-based view of the firm. To compete, firms often need resources that they dont have but may be found in other firms in or outside of the local firms home industry. As such, these completementary resources are another rationale for why large firms form joint ventures and strateic alliances whithin the same industry or in vertically related industries. Beacuse firms are co located and have similar needs, its easir for them to jointly work together, for example, to produce engines and transmiisions as part of the powertrain. This is evident in the European alliance between Peugeot-Citroen and Open-Vauxhall. It is also the reason for a recent US alliance between For and General Motors in developing upgraded nine and ten speed transmiisons. Furthermore, Ford and GM are looking to develop, together, eleven and twelve speed automatic transmissions to improve fuel efficiency and help the firms meet new federal guidelines regarding such efficiency. In regard to resouce complementarity, a very successful alliance was fromed in 1999 by French based Renault and Japan based Nissan. Each of these firms lacked the neccessary size to develop economies of scale and economies of scope that were critical to succeed in the 1990s and beyond in the global automobile industyr. When the alliance was formed, each firm took an ownership stake in the other. THe larger of the two companies Renault holds a 43.3 percent stake in Nissan, while Nissan has a 15 percent stake in Renault. It is interesting to note that Carlos Ghosn serves as the CEO of both companies. Over time, this corpoorate level synergistic allaince has developed three values to guide the relationship between the two firms: 1. trust )work fairly, impartially, and profesionall) 2. respect (honor commitments, liabilites, and responsibilites) 3. transparency (be open, frank, and clear) Largely due to these established principes, the Renalut Nissan alliance is a recognized success. One could argue that the main reason for the success of this alliance is the complementary assets that the firms bring to the alliance; Nissan is strong in Asia, while Renault is strong in Europe. Together they have eben able to establish other production locations, such as those in Latin America, whihc they may not have obtained independently. Some firms enter alliances because they are squeezed in the middle; that is they have moderate volumes, mostly for the mass market, but need to collaborate to testablish viable encomies of scale. For exmaple, fiat- chrysler needs to boost its annual sales from 4.3 billion to something like $6 billion, and likewise needs to strengthen its presence in the booming Asian market to have enough global market power. As such, it is entering joint ventures with two undersized Japanese carmakers, Mazda and Suzuki. HOwever, the past history of Mazda and Suzuki with alliance may be a reason for thier not being overly enthusiastic about the prospects of the current alliances. Fiat broke up with GM, Chrysler with aimler, and Mazda with Ford. This is also the situation in Europe locally for Peugeot Citron of France, which is struggling for survival along with the GM European subsidiary, Open-Vauxhall, More specifically, Peugeot Citroen and Opel Vauhall have struck a tentative agreement to share platforms and engines to get the capital necessary for investment in future models. As such, in all these examples, the firms need additional market share,but also enough capital to make the investment necessary to realize more market power to compete. In summary, there are a number of rationales why competitiors no tonly compete but also cooperate in establishing strategic alliances and joint ventures in order to meet strategic needs for increased market power, take advatnges of complemnetary assets and cooperate with close neighbor, often in the same region of a country.

1. How can the resource-based view of the firm help us understand why firms develop and use cooperative strategies such as strategic allainces and joint ventures?

2. What is the relationship between the core competencies a firm possesses, the core competencies the firm feels it needs, and decisions to form cooperative strategies?

3. What does it mean to say that the partners of an alliance have complementary assets? What complemenarty assets do Renault and Nissan share?

4. What are the risks associated with the corporate level strategic alliance between Renault and Nissan? What have these firms done to mitigate these risks?

5. Is it possible that some of the firms mentioned in this Mini case (eg Renault, Nissan, Mazda, Peugot Citroen, Opel Vauxhall) might form a network cooperative strategy? If so, what conditions mihgt influence a decision by these firms to form this particular type of strategy?

Reference no: EM131367013

Questions Cloud

Identify the organizations primary product or service : You have been hired as an outside consultant to help Tyson foods to strengthen employee development. identify the organizations primary product or service. what is the current focus? what are the organizations overarching goals? what are the organiza..
Why is competitive bidding an imporant factor : Why is competitive bidding an imporant factor in major purchase decisons such as vehicles for a police force, and the construction of a bridge, or the manufacture of military uniforms?
Under staples easy rebates program : Under Staples, "easy rebates" program, customers can submit most of their rebate applications online for products purchased over the interentm through the catalog, and in Staples stores. Customers may also submit serveral rebates at once and recieve ..
Leading and developing a risk analysis for the community : What are some of the characteristics that are a mark of a good leader in leading and developing a risk analysis for the community? How are those characteristics carried over to the management of a disaster and overall community response after perform..
Both globally and locally in the global automobile industry : The academic literature on alliances has some interesting recent findings, one of which is the rationale that because firms are often located in the same country, and often in the same region of the country, it is easier for them to collaborate on ma..
Specializing in climate-controlled pet houses : Juki Mara is Dallas based company specializing in climate-controlled pet houses. According to the company’s VP of Operations, their market segments basically compromise of high-end customers who are either dog or cat owners and who want to pamper the..
How do these types of sales affect captical profitablility : Capital Motors, a car dealership, recently announced that it will rely less on high volume strategies such as discounts and rebates to improve it profitablility. Another strategy it will employ it to sell fewer cars to rental fleets, which eventually..
How many cases of bread to stock each week to meet demand : Katy Bread, Victoria packs 12 loaves of bread in each case. Katy Bread must decide how many cases of Bread to stock each week to meet demand. Each case cost $10 and sells for $12. Unsold cases are sold to a local grocers for $2 per case. If there is ..
Individual performance evaluations in project management : Search the web and find a resource that discusses team or individual performance evaluations in project management. Provide us with the URL, and summarize the key lessons to be learned from your resource.

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Operation Management Questions & Answers

  Discuss which kind of people tend to be more innovative

Discuss which kind of people tend to be more innovative in a given field: those who are knowledgeable or those who are inexperienced in the field. Provide an example of why you believe this to be true.

  What is characteristic of virtual enterprise

Why a company should not outsourced its core element within a product? What other factors can be outsourced? What is characteristic of virtual enterprise?

  Without repaying the loan

Lawrence loaned money to Moore, who died without repaying the loan. Lawrence claimed that when he mentioned the matter to Moore’s widow, she promised to pay the debt. She did not pay it, and Lawrence sued her on her promise. Does she have any defense..

  Reengineering-od intervention-incorporates

Reengineering, as an OD intervention, incorporates _____.

  Risk management memo by project manager

Even though you are the project manager and one ultimately responsible for planning and implementing the project plan-Draft a memo outlining your ideas how two of following team members could integrate risk management in their jobs:

  Find the effective gross hourly cost

A tool and die worker is paid $26.50 per hour. The work year consists of 52 40-hour weeks with overtime schedules for 26 Saturdays. The company allows 8 paid holidays and 10 days of vacation. Four days of sick leave are budgeted and have historically..

  Market conditions from response for request for quote

What could be inferred about the supplier market conditions from the response for the request for quote? How would the supplier market conditions influence the decision to expand outsourcing policy? Discuss and define the difference between single so..

  Vision statement and the mission statement

Many people believe that the Vision Statement and the Mission Statement should be aspirational. Do you think the aspirational approach is incompatible with a specific and achievable approach?

  Structure using the various descriptions

Describe IDEO's strategy in terms of size vs. structure using the various descriptions. Describe the size of their offices (number of people) and how they manage growth. Give reasons for why they manage the way they do.

  What was the need for the traceability system

What do you understand by Traceability System? What was the need for the traceability system? What are the different IT based Traceability systems?

  Determine the optimal order quantity and order frequency

The home goods department of a large department store sells 175 units per month of a certain large bath towel. The unit cost of a towel to the store is $2.50 and the cost of placing an order is estimated to be $12.00.

  Orders based on the on hand quantity in stock

A Manager was heard to complain, “I have some items that have a two week review interval, and it takes four weeks for resupply. Every two week, I place orders based on the on hand quantity in stock. Now I seem to have too much inventory.” What went w..

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd