Are affirmative action plan goals evidence of discrimination

Assignment Help Operation Management
Reference no: EM131041737

Are Affirmative Action Plan Goals Evidence of Discrimination?

Xerox Corporation manufactures and markets copy machines and also provides facilities management services through Xerox Business Services (XBS). In the 1990s, Xerox started a Balanced Workforce Initiative (BWF) that involved the publication of specific affirmative action goals for each job and each salary grade level within the company. This plan was started in an effort to ensure proportional representation of all racial and gender groups throughout the company. The BWFs were based on government labor force data and established annually. Part of the annual performance evaluation for managers was how well they met the desired racial and gender compositions for their locations. In one instance, BWF reports compiled for the Houston office indicated that black employees were overrepresented and white employees were under-represented. Over a period of five years, steps were taken to reduce the percentage of black employees in the office in an effort to correct this imbalance. Six black employees filed suit against Xerox stating that they were denied promotion opportunities in the Houston office even though they were qualified for the jobs into which they wanted to be promoted. They also indicated that they felt the BWF data adversely affected their opportunity for advancement. Each plaintiff had a slightly different situation, but they collectively raised concerns that included denial of promotions, salary disparities, hostile work environment, and termination.

Questions

1. Based on the evidence presented, has discrimination occurred? If so, which type of discrimination (i.e., disparate treatment, disparate impact, both)? If you aren’t sure, what questions would you want to have answered to make your determination?

2. Which party (plaintiffs or defendant) has the burden of proof in this case? What defense could Xerox offer if the plaintiffs make a case of discrimination? Discuss how successful you think the company will be at defending its actions.

3. Could Xerox have achieved the same goals in a less discriminatory manner? If so, how? If not, why not?

4. How do the actions in this case differ from the intent and recommended practices for affirmative action?

Reference no: EM131041737

Questions Cloud

Bank today to begin retirement : Ed and Linda are near retirement. They expect to be in retirement for 25 years. Inflation is 4%, they need 47500 annually, and they are making 6.5% interest. How much do they need in the bank today to begin retirement.
How will expand my professional network : What is your personal marketing strategy; i.e., what do you plan to do to ensure you achieve your goals? (Some questions you might reflect on in your response include: How will I penetrate the hidden job market? How will expand my professional networ..
What are the weapons of competition : What are the "weapons of competition" that rival companies in the athletic footwear industry can use to gain sales and market share? What do you see as the key factors for being a successful competitor in your industry? List at least three.
What do your subordinates expect from you on the job : Briefly describe your current position and responsibility. What do your subordinates expect from you on the job? What are the major stress and challenges you face on the job?
Are affirmative action plan goals evidence of discrimination : Are Affirmative Action Plan Goals Evidence of Discrimination?. Xerox Corporation manufactures and markets copy machines and also provides facilities management services through Xerox Business Services (XBS). In the 1990s, Xerox started a Balanced Wor..
Determining the monthly payments : Jake wants to buy a new truck and he has saved $2,350 for a down payment and can make monthly payments of $575. The dealer will finance the truck over 60 months at 1.2% interest with monthly payments. Jack wants a truck costing $35,999; can Jake..
Start a new project and package called finalproject : Start a new project and package called FinalProject and set up your programs inside. his problem is designed to give you experience at creating arrays of objects and a custom constructor.
Marketing ethics and global marketing : At the end of Unit two, a 1600 word paper is due that summarizes your research with respect to one of the following topics: marketing ethics, global marketing, or ‘social media as a marketing tool’.
Consider evaluating the expression : Given a one-argument procedure p and an object a, p is said to ``halt'' on a if evaluating the expression (p a) returns a value (as opposed to terminating with an error message or running forever).

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Operation Management Questions & Answers

  Practicing international management case

The World Bank and the IMF had once argued that the leniency of debt forgiveness would make it more difficult for the lenders themselves to borrow cheaply on the world's capital markets. If you were a World Bank donor, would you support the HIPC Debt..

  Define a strategic advantage to japanese auto suppliers

Be sure to identify areas that provide a strategic advantage to Japanese auto suppliers, and those that provide a competitive threat that competitors may be able to exploit.

  Why is it important for managers to reduce the resistance

Why is it important for managers to reduce the resistance to change openly displayed or covertly practiced by employees?

  Negotiated an agreement covering pay rates

The employees of Powder Power Tools corp. were represented by a labor union that had negotiated an agreement covering pay rates. A number of employees did not receive the higher rates of pay specified in the union contract. The employer claimed that ..

  What is the reliability of the engine

A jet engine has ten components in series. The average reliability of each component is 0.998. What is the reliability of the engine? (Round your answer to 3 decimal places, the tolerance is +/-0.001)

  Determine the factors needed to get individual managers

Determine the factors needed to get individual managers to be more aware of the legal requirements of staffing systems and to take steps to ensure that they themselves engage in legal staffing actions. Support your position with evidence or exampl..

  What is stress and what are stressors

What is stress? What are stressors? Can stress be good? Describe the difference between a Type A and Type B personality? Which are you? Which would you prefer to manage? Why?

  Grand strategy for organization

Identify the best value discipline, generic strategy, and grand strategy for your organization.

  The firm terminates steven so that they can put

The firm terminates Steven so that they can put the old secretary back in her job. Steven asks you what you think he should do. What do you say?

  Analyzes the basic legal and social environment organization

Analyzes the basic legal, social, and economic environment in which the organizations operate. Analyzes the managerial, operational, and financial issues impacting the organizations including

  Determine the leadership approaches based on individuals

your manager tells you about a new department the company will be adding that is part of the companys strategic plan to

  Identify a number of the typical criteria

In one of your initial meetings with the chief executive officer (CEO), she asked you to identify a number of the typical criteria used when making new location decisions. Complete the following:

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd