An insurance brokers dilemma

Assignment Help Operation Management
Reference no: EM131430155

CASE 4.3: An Insurance Broker’s Dilemma

SYNOPSIS 4

A major museum currently obtains insurance from Haverford, through its insurance broker Ashton & Ashton (A&A). It is time for renewal of the policy, and A&A has obtained several bids. There is one lowball bid from a “shaky” company called Reliable. If A&A conveys the Reliable bid to the museum, the museum will probably accept it. A&A receives 10–15% of the premium as commission, 17% in the case of Haverford. Should A&A present the low bid? If it does not, could it be accused of conflict of interest?

ANALYSIS

It is helpful to view this as a case in professional ethics. It raises the question of what an insurance broker’s professional duties are, with respect to conflict of interest and advising clients. As noted in Chapter 2, professional duties are based on the obligation to meet expectations that the profession created in the public mind.

The conflict of interest matter is easy to resolve. While professionals are normally expected to avoid or minimize conflicts of interest, the conflicts are often inherent in the nature of the profession. If so, professionals are expected to make the right decision without being influenced by personal incentives. In the present case, the conflict of interest is a built-in characteristic of insurance brokerage and exists whether or not A&A presents the low bid. It should have no bearing on how A&A decides to deal with its client.

The main issue is how many choices A&A should present to its client. There are two basic policies. One is to present the client a full range of representative bids, give advice, and let the client decide. A second policy is to make some decisions for the client by screening out bids that the broker thinks are clearly inappropriate.

As a rule, brokers are expected to give advice and not make decisions. This is not true of all professionals. Physicians, for example, generally present only the alternatives that they believe are medically sound. They may refuse to perform a surgery even when the patient requests it. If the surgery is medically ill-advised and turns out badly, the physician gets the blame. This is not inappropriate, because making this sort of judgment is part of a physician’s professional promise. Public expectations appear to be evolving toward greater patient responsibility, but these expectations tend to be forgotten when a malpractice lawsuit is filed. Brokers, however, are generally expected to present the full range of alternatives, and the client is expected to take responsibility for the decision. Quoting the low bid is therefore consistent with professional ethics.

Furthermore, failing to quote the low bid seems inconsistent with professional duty. While a broker would not be expected to mention every option, it is important to provide a representative selection. One of the primary motivations for working through a broker is to make sure one is aware of the range of options. This may well reduce utility, because the museum is apparently unwilling or unable to make the right decision, even after hearing A&A’s advice. Yet there is no obligation to achieve higher utility through actions that are otherwise unethical. A&A can be as emphatic and detailed as it wants, however, when it advises the museum to reject the lowest bid, and there is probably a utilitarian obligation to do so.

The primary virtues at stake are honesty and loyalty to the client. An honest presentation of the alternatives, together with a stern warning about the risks of insuring with Reliable, seems consistent with these virtues.

The action of presenting the low bid can now be evaluated:

1. Generalization test: Pass.

2. Utilitarian test: Pass.

3. Virtue ethics test: Pass.

The action is not only permissible but also obligatory, because failing to present the low bid fails the generalization test.

Question:

You engage a real estate “agent” (actually, broker) to help you find a house in an unfamiliar city and give her the price range. She only shows you houses that are at the upper end of the range, because her commission is a fixed percentage of the sales price. Does her conduct conform to professional ethics?

Reference no: EM131430155

Questions Cloud

Write a procedure to implement a soft-fill algorithm : Write a procedure to implement a soft-fill algorithm. Carefully define what soft-fill algorithm is to accomplish and how colors are to be combined.
Find the probabilities for given five intervals : Find the probabilities for these five intervals using Table A. Then compute the expected number for each interval for a sample of 500. Finally, perform the goodness-of-fit test and summarize your results.
Definition for the industry in which patagonia operates : Provide a definition for the industry in which Patagonia operates. What are the industry's Driving Forces, What constitutes a substitute within the industry as you have defined it?
How many colors can be displayed at any at time : Consider an RGB raster system that has a 512-by-512 frame buffer with 20 bib per pixel and a color lookup table with 24 bits per pixel.
An insurance brokers dilemma : A major museum currently obtains insurance from Haverford, through its insurance broker Ashton & Ashton (A&A). It is time for renewal of the policy, and A&A has obtained several bids. There is one lowball bid from a “shaky” company called Reliable. Y..
What is the smallest possible size (in bytes) for the frame : Suppose you have a system with an 8 inch by 10 inch video screen that can display 100 pixels per inch. If a color lookup table with 64 positions is used with this system what is the smallest possible size (in bytes) for the frame buffer?
Analyze the disciplinary content in its own context : Analyze the disciplinary content in its own context and in relationship to the issues, questions, and positions of other disciplines. Compare and contrast differences and similarities among the disciplines in terms of central concerns, values, met..
Discuss the spending amount annually by cohort as a group : Spending amount annually by cohort as a group; saving patterns of this age group, etc.Product development for this age cohort: what product(s) would you recommendbe created for this group.Marketing (advertising and sales promotion) approaches to be ..
Which is factor in competing in market of foreign countries : Which one of the following is not a factor in competing in the markets of foreign countries? Which of the following statements concerning the effects of fluctuating exchange rates on companies competing in foreign markets is true?

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Operation Management Questions & Answers

  Discuss how these tools are applied in business analysis

Compare and contrast two software tools, and discuss how these tools are applied in business analysis. What could be done to improve these tools, in your opinion?

  Presentation to the supervisors in the company

You are making a presentation to the supervisors in the company on the Tuckman forming, storming, norming, and performing model.

  Leadership development plan to prepare an executive summary

Draw upon your Leadership Development Plan to prepare an executive summary of your paper (see final project description for definition of executive summary) and a PowerPoint presentation in which you present your global leadership credentials to a..

  Describe two benefits and two risks of hormone therapy

As the RN working in a family health clinic, you are providing education to a peri-menopausal woman who is seeking your guidance related to hormone therapy for management of hot flashes, mood swings and night sweats. Describe two (2) benefits and two..

  Concept of the kano model

Explain the concept of the Kano model. Why is it important for organizations to help customers establish Kano levels that are appropriately linked to the value trait of quality?

  Contrast how the concept of time and money spent

1. Briefly describe the guidelines for determining the overall arrangement in Retail Stores. 2. Briefly describe the advantages of Work Cells. 3. Compare/Contrast how the concept of time and money spent are considered for a Retail Stores vs. a Wor..

  How many programs should the baseball organization print

A professional baseball organization chooses to sell game day programs. Demand for game day programs is normally distributed with a mean of 2,000 and standard deviation of 300. If the marginal loss is $1 and the marginal profit is $3, how many progra..

  Newcomer affect the task and social dimensions of the group

Think of a situation (personal or hypothetical) where a newcomer came into a well-established group. How did the newcomer affect the task and social dimensions of the group? Was the acceptance into the group a smooth process?

  Labor contract with general dynamics is being renegotiated

Suppose a UAW labor contract with General Dynamics is being renegotiated. Some of the many issues on the table include job security, health benefits, and wages. If you are an executive in charge of human resource issues at General Dynamics, would you..

  Many organizations offer combination of goods

Many organizations offer a combination of goods and services to their customers. As you learned in Chapter 1 there are some key differences between production of goods and delivery of services. What are the implications of these differences relative ..

  Zero sum competition is based on the concept of winner

Zero sum competition is based on the concept of a winner and a loser in a business relationship. The cost shifting that Porter describes is an example of zero sum competition. This means using our definition of strategy – providing a service that is ..

  Democratic and delegative-laissez-faire leadership styles

Our readings this week discuss the application of the administrative functions of Planning, Organizing, Directing and Controlling in a public safety role. The supplemental reading on Leadership Style reviewed the application of Authoritarian/Autocrat..

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd