Advise Anna - Australian Consumer Law Case
Course:- Business Law and Ethics
Length: 1200 Words
Reference No.:- EM132257615

Assignment Help
Expertsmind Rated 4.9 / 5 based on 47215 reviews.
Review Site
Assignment Help >> Business Law and Ethics

Australian Consumer Law Assignment -

FACTS - Anna runs a catering business 'Share Plate'. She has a large kitchen and 5 staff who work with her preparing food for various parties. Anna is keen to expand her business and create a line of pre-prepared meals for busy individuals and families. She creates a meal plan that includes a lot of curries, stews and pasta sauces that can freeze well. There is a lot of interest in her new business and she realises that she will need to buy new equipment to keep up with the demand.

Anna visits IncrEdible Kitchens, a Sydney based supplier of commercial kitchen equipment. She speaks with John, a senior sales person and tells him about her business and her need of several large slow cookers that are good for cooking the kinds of food she has in mind. John tells her about their new range of pressure cookers, called the IncrEdible X32 saying:

'The IncrEdible X32 is the new, top of the range model of pressure cooker. Intended for commercial use, it has a high capacity and cooks faster than traditional slow cookers while still ensuring that the meat stays tender.'

The IncrEdible X32 is actually manufactured by French company, Aliment Maison and is exclusively imported by IncrEdible Kitchens under their own brand.

Anna buys 6 of the IncrEdible X32 for a total price of $4800 and has them delivered to her kitchen. She has received a large volume of orders and is eager to get to work preparing and delivering meals. Due to the high demand, Anna's son George joins the Share Plate team in the kitchen to assist with preparing the meals. Three days after the IncrEdible X32s are delivered there is a loud explosion in the kitchen. The lid of one of the IncrEdible X32s has come loose during the cooking process due to a faulty seal and hot beef stew is sprayed across the kitchen. George and another one of Anna's staff, Beth, are badly injured with serious burns across their faces and arms. Anna rushes George and Beth to the hospital and then returns to her kitchen to sort out the mess. It turns out, two iPads that are used to display recipes and orders are also covered in hot stew and are unable to be repaired.

Anna calls IncrEdible Kitchens and tells John that she wants to return all of IncrEdible X32s (including the one that exploded) and asks for a refund. John tells Anna that she can return the malfunctioning IncrEdible X32 and exchange it for a new one but that IncrEdible Kitchens will not provide a refund for the remaining 5 IncrEdible X32s as they do not accept returns unless the stock is damaged or defective. John tells her that if she is really concerned she can bring the remaining IncrEdible X32s in to the store and IncrEdible Kitchens will send them away to be serviced and have their seals replaced. This will take approximately 2-3 weeks.

Anna is not happy and never wants to use the pressure cookers again. She asks to speak to John's manager.


1. Does the Australian Consumer Law (ACL) apply? Explain your answer.

2. Advise Anna.

3. Advise IncrEdible Kitchens.

In answering these questions you only need to look at the following provisions of the Australian Consumer Law 2010 (Cth) ss 2, 3, 7, 9, 11, 13, 16, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58, 59, 60, 64, 64A, 131, 132, 138, 139, 140, 141, 142, 143, 144, 145, 146, 147, 148, 149, 150, 236, 259, 260, 261, 262, 263, 264, 265, 266, 271, 272, 273, 274, 275, 276.

Not all these provisions are necessary for a complete answer. Some may not be relevant. Determining which provisions are relevant is part of the exercise.

Put your comment
View Conversion
  1. user image

    There are no marks attributed to individual questions. The mark will be determined by an overall correlation with the marking criteria: Interpretation of the task (identifying relevant legal issues and demonstrating an understanding of the task); The demonstration of a close reading of the given statutory provisions; Presentation of clear and concise arguments; Critical analysis (identify, comprehend and evaluate relevant legal and factual issues as applied to the problem); Accurate interpretation and application of the relevant legislation; Attention to form and expression (including correct spelling and grammar and correct uniform referencing); Conclusions (consideration of main points and arrival at outcomes based on analysis of the problem); and The extent to which you have followed the detailed instructions provided in the assignment.

Ask Question & Get Answers from Experts
Browse some more (Business Law and Ethics) Materials
Is the Jackson article important to the discussion related to college assaults? In what way? Based upon the article, are there any implications we can draw from knowing more
In a minimum 200 word response explain the problems that law enforcement officials have faced regarding the issues of federal, state, and local jurisdictions attempting to i
Analyze whether or not a director/officer can be held liable for the torts of the Greg Allen Construction Corporation. Discuss whether or not the facts would constitute the ty
Discuss the elements of impossibility of performance and the three situations where this defense can be used. Discuss commercial impracticability and its application to this c
What is the legal nature of Marwan's employment? Explain your answers and the terms you use. What actions and steps should Studio Five take against Marwan? Explain what act
Analyze commonly accepted forensic and contemporary specialized techniques. Consider the following questions when composing your response: What is the level of personal prot
The Sale of Goods Act 1979 lays down certain rules relating to the passing of risk.Critically evaluate these rules and consider whether risk always rests with the party who ou
Growth is never bad you need to grow to create opportunities for your employees.Growth can be bad if it creates quality issues or finacial stresses.Every business goes through