A question of ethics portland shellfish

Assignment Help Management Theories
Reference no: EM131049290

A Question of Ethics Portland Shellfish Co. processes live shellfish in Maine. As one of the firm's two owners, Frank Wetmore held 300 voting and 150 nonvoting shares of the stock. Donna Holden held the other 300 voting shares. Donna's husband, Jeff, managed the company's daily operations, including production, procurement, and sales. The board of directors consisted of Frank and Jeff. In 2001, disagreements arose over the company's management. The Holdens invoked the "Shareholders' Agreement," which provided that "[i]n the event of a deadlock, the directors shall hire an accountant at [MacDonald, Page, Schatz, Fletcher & Co., LLC] to determine the value of the outstanding shares. [E]ach shareholder shall have the right to buy out the other shareholder(s) interest." MacDonald Page estimated the stock's "fair market value" to be $1.09 million. Donna offered to buy Frank's shares at a price equal to his proportionate share. Frank countered by offering $1.25 million for Donna's shares. Donna rejected Frank's offer and insisted that he sell his shares to her or she would sue. In the face of this threat, Frank sold his shares to Donna for $750,705. Believing the stock to be worth more than twice MacDonald Page's estimate, Frank filed a suit in a federal district court against the accountant

1 Frank claimed that in valuing the stock, the accountant disregarded "commonly accepted and reliable methods of valuation in favor of less reliable methods." He alleged negligence, among other things. MacDonald Page filed a motion to dismiss the complaint. What are the elements that establish negligence? Which is the most critical element in this case?

2 MacDonald Page evaluated the company's stock by identifying its "fair market value," defined as "[t]he price at which the property would change hands between a willing buyer and a willing seller, neither being under a compulsion to buy or sell and both having reasonable knowledge of relevant facts." The accountant knew that the shareholders would use its estimate to determine the price that one would pay to the other. Under these circumstances, was Frank's injury foreseeable? Explain.

3 What factor might have influenced Frank to sell his shares to Donna even if he thought that MacDonald Page's "fair market value" figure was less than half what it should have been? Does this factor represent an unfair, or unethical, advantage? Why or why not?

Reference no: EM131049290

Questions Cloud

What was your total return for the past year : You purchased a zero-coupon bond one year ago for $281.83. The market interest rate is now 9 percent. Required: If the bond had 15 years to maturity when you originally purchased it, what was your total return for the past year?
System of governance proven to be essential for efficiency : Explain the relationships among corporate shareholders, boards of directors, and managers? Why has such a system of governance proven to be essential for efficiency?
Determine the projects net annual after tax cash : An investment project is expected to generate earnings before taxes (ebt) of 70,000 per year. Annual depreciation from project is 30,000 and the firms tax rate is 40% . Determine the projects net annual after tax cash.
Do you want to tune up your bicycle or make your own repairs : Do you want to tune up your bicycle or make your own repairs? Come to the Campus Bicycle Resource and Repair Center.
A question of ethics portland shellfish : A Question of Ethics Portland Shellfish Co. processes live shellfish in Maine. As one of the firm's two owners, Frank Wetmore held 300 voting and 150 nonvoting shares of the stock. Donna Holden held the other 300 voting shares. Donna's husband, Je..
Hat amout will each plaintiff receive : A class-action suit against a utility company resulted in a settlement of $2.65 million for 79,000 customers. If the legal fees, which must be paid from the settlement, are $600,000, what amount will each plaintiff receive?
Market purchase by the federal reserve bank : Assume Required Reserve Rate is 10%, banks don't hold excess reserves, and public doesn't change their currency holdings. What will the change in deposits resulting from a $50 million open market purchase by the Federal Reserve Bank?
Calculate the costs of buying versus leasing : Use the following data: Purchase Costs Leasing Costs Down payment: $3,600 Security deposit: $1,200 Loan payment: $1,080 for 48 months Lease payment: $1,080 for 48 months Estimated value at end of loan: $4,700 End-of-lease charges: $705 Opportunity co..
The net present value of a microwave oven that costs : What would be the net present value of a microwave oven that costs $173 and will save you $82 a year in time and food away from home? Assume an average return on your savings of 5 percent for 5 years. (Hint: Calculate the present value of the annual ..

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Management Theories Questions & Answers

  Sustainable competitive advantage

Support or contradict this statement: ''Given the realities of today's economy and the rapid changes occurring in business technology, all competitive advantages are short-lived. There is no such thing as a sustainable competitive advantage that last..

  Global marketing management

Global marketing management leadership creates the strategic synergy capable of synthesizing strategic plans into purposeful action. Leadership instills global marketing control in three major governance modes: functional (e.g., global marketing mix)..

  Delegation affects employees

Delegation affects employees in all of the following ways except: A). increasing their motivation B).increasing their satisfaction

  Inconsistencies between attitudes and behaviors.

Clarify how individuals reconcile inconsistencies between attitudes and behaviors.

  Find the force in which the man feet press

A man of weight w=160lb holds one end of a rope that passes over a pulley vertically abouve his head and to the other end of which is attatched a weight Q=120lb.Find the force in which the man's feet press against the floor.

  Forecasting method and justification

Forecasting method and justification

  How has the ipad affected modern popular culture

Examine the appeal of the iPad. How has the iPad affected modern popular culture, and what does this say about the importance of technology in studying popular culture

  What should the court decide

The employer decided to cancel its policy of making deductions for less than eight-hour days and refunded the deductions that had been made. Some of the employees sued for unpaid overtime, and the company claimed that they were exempt employees. W..

  A periodical like a newspaper or business magazine

Blogs are in response to a periodical like a newspaper or business magazine that you find interesting .Answer 2 questions: 1) Why did you choose this article, what does it have to do with OB?

  Influence perceptions of a buyer organization

How can a seller organization influence perceptions of a buyer organization?

  Explain the impact and improvements

Explain the impact and improvements that the air traffic control system in the United States will gain from the introduction of the FAA's Next Generation Air Transportation System (NextGen). (Describe some issues and ways to improve those issues if y..

  Section-successful strategic planning

Jack Welch, former CEO of General Electric, is known as one of the most intriguing, yet intelligent corporate leaders of our time.  His famous quote "Manage Your Destiny, Or Someone Else Will", as mentioned in your text, has inspired numerous mana..

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd