A fundamental ethical problem in statistics arises

Assignment Help Basic Statistics
Reference no: EM13869835

A fundamental ethical problem in statistics arises in experimentation (i.e., in the context of studies of experimental drugs for treating AIDS). On one side, organizations such as the National Institute of Health insist on randomly assigning treatments such as flipping a coin for each patient to decide which treatment to assign. 

The advantage of randomized experiments is that they allow reliable conclusions without the need to worry about lurking variables. However, some groups of AIDS patients have opposed randomization, instead making the argument that each patient should be assigned the best available treatment (or to be more precise, whatever treatment is currently believed to be the best). The ethical dilemma is to balance the benefits to the patients in the study (who would like the opportunity to choose among available treatments) with future patients (who would be served by learning as soon as possible about the effectiveness of the competing treatments). 

The issue is complicated. On one hand, the randomized study is most trustworthy if all the patients in the study participate. If they are not treated respectfully, the patients might go outside the study and try other drugs, which could bias the estimates of treatment effects. On the other hand, the patients might benefit from being in an experimental study. Even if the treatment is randomized, the patients are getting close medical attention from the researchers. Current best practice is to design studies so that all subjects will be expected to benefit in some way, but still keeping the randomized element. For example, a study can compare two potentially beneficial experimental treatments, rather than comparing a treatment to an inert “control.” However, there will always be conflicts of interest between the patients in the study, the scientists conducting it, and the public at large.

In your original post, compare and contrast at least two research designs that might be used to research life threatening diseases/disorders. At least one design should present ethical issues and at least one design should minimize potential ethical issues. Provide at least one Scripture passage that supports your ethical perspectives on medical/public health research.

Reference no: EM13869835

Previous Q& A

  Discuss how makey uses its own products or services

Discuss how Makey uses its own products or services to enhance the total compensation for its employees.  Is this a common practice in other organizations?  Give real-life examples (employers by name). In your educated opinion do you think this is a ..

  The legality and exploitation of international mitm attacks

The legality and exploitation of international MiTM attacks (Individual Paper), ou will write a paper on this topic. Choose one of the MiTM cases discussed in this Week's lecture notes

  Investment income of $ 3,000 was received in cash

Investment income of $ 3,000 was received in cash The fund liabilities for interest on bonds in the amount of $ 50,000 and principal in the amount of $ 100,000 were recorded, and cash for the total amount was transferred to the fiscal agent.

  Cash for the total amount was transferred to the fiscal

The fund liabilities for interest in the amount of $ 37,500 and principal in the amount of $ 50,000 were recorded, and cash for the total amount was transferred to the fiscal agent.

  Prepare an investment interest revenue and premium

On January 1, 2010, Lynch Company acquired 13% bonds with a face value of $50,000.

  At that time, the ending quoted market price for the bonds

On December 31, 2009, the Leslie Company held an investment in bonds of Kaufmann Company which it categorized as being held to maturity.

  Watson township plans to build an auditorium

Watson Township plans to build an auditorium. The plans were drawn for $ 100,000 by an architect who will complete the plans and bill the city after the bonds are issued.

  The francisco company experienced financial difficulties

On June 1, 2010, the Hansen Company purchased ten $1,000 Francisco Company bonds at par and classified them as held to maturity.

  Write a c program to calculate

Write a C program to calculate the following Sum: Sum=1-x2/2! +x4/4!-x6/6!+x8/8!-x10/10! */

  Corporation could take tissue simply through the people

"A non-public corporation could take tissue simply through the people, administrators and also their particular loved ones". Comments or give your best opinion

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Similar Q& A

  Find minimum sample size required to estimate population

Use the given date to find the minimum sample size required to estimate a population proportion and populat mean. Margin of error: 0.004, confidence level, 90%, sample proportion (p) : = 0.45

  In the second community a random survey of 90 households

a firm wanted to see if there was a significant difference between two neighboring communities in terms of the mean

  Justify why the following statement is either true or false

data was collected consisting of the number of alcoholic drinks students have during the week and their gpa. the data

  Detailed explanation to paired t test

State the null and alternative hypotheses. Using the test statistic, degrees of freedom and p-value, what can you conclude about the null hypothesis? What is the 95% confidence interval of the difference? Interpret the 95% confidence interval using t..

  Create linear model to estimate number of points score

Create a linear model to estimate the number of points students will score on the next exam from the number of hours the student studies.

  Explain decisions made in third cycle of stimulation

State the reasons for your decision and include an explanation of why you did not follow the recommendations of the stakeholders.

  If np gt5 and nqgt5 estimate pmore than 9 with n14 and p03

if np gt5 and nqgt5 estimate pmore than 9 with n14 and p0.3 by using the normal distribution as an approximation

  Analyze and interpret the process behavior charts of

1 analyze and interpret the process behavior charts of selected quarterly earnings data of southwest airlines between

  Compute the coefficient of variation of the number

What is the standard deviation of the number of service calls and compute the coefficient of variation of the number of service calls.

  Describe the types of graphical descriptive statistics used

Analyze how the level of measurement and the distribution of the data influenced the type of graphical descriptions presented.

  A state administered standardized reading exam is given to

a state administered standardized reading exam is given to eighth grade students. the scores on this exam for all

  Hypothesis testing-effectiveness of aspirin

A physician's health study of the effectiveness of aspirin in the reduction of heart attacks was begun in 1982 and completed in 1987. Of 11,037 male medical doctors in the United States who took one 325 mg buffered aspirin tablet every other day

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd