A disastrous development project

Assignment Help Management Theories
Reference no: EM131039053

A Disastrous Development Project

In 2004, Marin County in California decided to replace its aging financial management, payroll, and human resources systems with a modern SAP enterprise resource planning system. The county solicited proposals from various companies to act as software consultants on the implementation. Thirteen companies, including Oracle, PeopleSoft, and SAP, submitted proposals. In April 2005 the county selected Deloitte Consulting based on the firm's representations concerning its in-depth knowledge of SAP systems and the extensive experience of its consultants. From 2005 to 2009, Marin County paid increasing consulting fees to Deloitte as its staff grappled with serious fiscal problems. Essentially, the staff could not program the SAP system to perform even routine financial functions such as payroll and accounts receivable. A grand jury probe concluded that the system had cost taxpayers $28.6 million as of April 2009. At that time, Marin County voted to stop the ongoing SAP project, implicitly acknowledging that it had wasted some $30 million on software and related implementation services from Deloitte.

The Marin County Information Systems and Technology Group concluded that fixing the Deloitte-installed SAP system would cost nearly 25 percent more over a 10-year period than implementing a new system. In 2010, Marin County fi led a complaint alleging that Deloitte's representations were fraudulent. The complaint accused Deloitte of using the county's SAP project as a training ground to provide young consultants with public sector SAP experience, at the county's expense. It further charged that Deloitte intentionally failed to disclose its lack of SAP and public sector skills; withheld information about critical project risks; falsely represented to the county that the SAP system was ready to "go live" as originally planned; conducted inadequate testing; and concealed the fact that it had failed to perform necessary testing, thereby ensuring that system defects would remain hidden prior to the go-live date. Finally, the county maintained that, although it had paid substantial consulting fees to Deloitte, the system continued to have crippling problems. Deloitte fi led a counterclaim over the county's failure to pay more than $550,000 in fees and interest. The company maintained that it had fulfilled all of its obligations under the contract, as evidenced by the fact that all of Deloitte's work was approved by the county officials who were responsible for overseeing the project. In December 2010, Marin County sued Deloitte and two SAP subsidiaries, alleging that Deloitte had "engaged in a pattern of racketeering activity designed to defraud the county of more than $20 million." The county's lawsuit also names as a defendant Ernest Culver, a former county employee who served as director on the SAP project. The county alleged that Culver interviewed for jobs at Deloitte and SAP, where he now works in SAP's Public Services division.

It further claimed that during the SAP project, Culver "was approving Deloitte's deficient work on the project, approving payments, and causing Marin County to enter into new contracts with Deloitte and SAP Public Services, Inc." In late December 2011, a judge ruled that Marin County failed to allege sufficient facts to bring a racketeering claim against SAP under the terms of the federal Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act (RICO). However, he also ruled that Marin County could file an amended complaint. The judge further found that Marin County had alleged sufficient facts to bring a "plausible" bribery claim against SAP with respect to Culver. Finally, the judge denied SAP's motion to dismiss claims against its SAP America division. In mid-January 2012, Marin County filed an amended complaint in federal court related to its actions against SAP, Deloitte Consulting, and Ernest Culver. The president of the Marin County Board of Supervisors stated that the board is committed to ensuring accountability for its taxpayers. In early 2013, Marin County settled its lawsuit with Deloitte Consulting over the failed SAP project. The settlement followed the Court's dismissal of several of the county's claims as well as the county's conclusion, after a full investigation, that it should voluntarily dismiss its remaining fraud claims and its allegations of improper influence of a county employee (Culver) who managed the project.

According to the Marin Independent Journal, the county received $3.9 million from Deloitte, which is less than it paid in legal fees. It is important to note that neither Marin County nor Deloitte placed any blame on the SAP software. The dynamics between the customer and the system integrator caused this failure. Sources: Compiled from M. Krigsman, "Big Money: Marin County and Deloitte Settle ERP Lawsuit Under Gag Order," ZDNet, January 14, 2013; N. Johnson, "Marin County Cuts Its Losses, Settles Its Computer Lawsuit for $3.9 Million, " Marin Independent Journal, January 9, 2013; C. Kanaracus, "Judge Tosses Racketeering Claims in Marin County Lawsuit Against SAP," PC World, December 28, 2011; C. Kanaracus, "Marin County Alleges SAP, Deloitte Engaged in Racketeering," Computerworld, February 2, 2011; M. Krigsman, "Understanding Marin County's $30 Million ERP Failure," ZDNet, September 2, 2010; C. Kanaracus, "Marin County to Rip and Replace Ailing SAP System," IDG News Service, August 24, 2010; M. Krigsman, "Marin County Sues Deloitte: Alleges Fraud on SAP Project," ZDNet, June 3, 2010; J. Vijayan, "Deloitte Hit with $30M Lawsuit over ERP Project," Computerworld, June 3, 2010; T. Claburn, "Deloitte Sued Over Failed SAP Implementation," InformationWeek, June 1, 2010; www.co.marin.ca.us, www.deloitte.com, accessed March 14, 2013

Questions
1. Debate the lawsuit from the point of view of Deloitte and SAP.
2. Debate the lawsuit from the point of view of Marin County

Reference no: EM131039053

Questions Cloud

Describe how animals and humans experience positive emotions : Describes how animals and humans experience positive emotions and interact with others and with their surroundings
How old is the rock after four half-lives have passed : If an isotope has a half-life of 600 million years, how old is a rock that contains the isotope after 50% of the parent has decayed? How old is the rock after four half-lives have passed?
Create and embed a table that identifies the resources : Summarize youth-related issues that seem to be at the forefront of your community. Use specific examples to support your observations (newspaper headlines, community meetings, political platforms, etc.) and cite your text when appropriate.
Coordinates of two points : For each of the following sets, give the coordinates of two points where Pand Qare in the set, but the line from Pto Qgoes outside the set. For example, if the points are (1,2)and (3,4),enter in the format (1,2),(3,4)
A disastrous development project : In 2004, Marin County in California decided to replace its aging financial management, payroll, and human resources systems with a modern SAP enterprise resource planning system. The county solicited proposals from various companies to act as soft..
What price should he charge for each type of parker : Given these facts, what is the owner's appropriate objective? How can he ensure that members of each market segment effectively pay a different hourly price?
Anniston orthopedics and greenway medical technologies : Anniston Orthopedic Associates, P.A. (AOA) is a surgical group comprised of six physicians who provide services to the Calhoun County area of Alabama. As of mid-2012 the group had not updated its information systems for several years.
Identify two barriers in current school or community : What were your first impressions after watching and reading the various resources on building relationships and engaging adults? Which ideas really ‘jumped out' at you? What ideas (if any), that were presented are you currently seeing in your scho..
Customers of an on-line electronics : Customers of an on-line electronics store spend an average of $120 with a standard deviation of $80 and are also charged a shipping & handling fee of $5 per purchase. What is the chance that the next 100 customers will pay an average of more than ..

Reviews

Write a Review

 

Management Theories Questions & Answers

  More culturally sensitive place for students

Think about how your school (or workplace) can become a more culturally sensitive place for students (or employees) from different backgrounds. How can you help everyone feel more welcomed? Develop a list of at least five suggestions to improve cultu..

  How many units would have to be sold to just breakeven

Assuming that direct labor is a variable cost, how many units would the company have to sell at the price you computed in (2) above to achieve the T8% ROI? How many units would have to be sold to just breakeven?

  Describe your experience of earth

Describe your experience of Earth/space science from when you were a student in primary school. What misconceptions did you have about Earth's place in space?

  Describe a project you are of have been involved

Describe a project you are of have been involved

  What place is accorded to hrm as a function

In the changing corporate scenario, what place is accorded to HRM as a function? How does it affect the effectiveness of function as such? Analyse.

  Companies pay bonuses to failing performers

Review the article, "Management Without Consequences: 24% of Companies Pay Bonuses to Failing Performers." Compensation and benefits is a very important part of the strategic plan of an organization.

  Designed to efficently manage a consumer b2c website

A virtual organization is often designed to efficently manage a consumer (B2C) website

  Advertising age usually critiques the ads on monday

A.Write an overview (about 1/2 page) describing your observations about THIS YEAR'S Super Bowl commercials - Your likes, dislikes, and trends noticed.B. Compare your reactions to what the experts say:  USA Today has a thorough analysis that measures ..

  Do you see the utilization of computers

Do you see the utilization of computers and the subsequent increase in gathering of information as a primarily good or bad development?Defend your position by appealing to Utilitarian or Kantian arguments.

  Discuss the key components of team building process

What is the difference between Teams And groups? discuss the key components of team building process?

  Is it ethically forbidden to go out of the sales chain

Does Ilene have the obligation to push for broader changes within the system, rather than only changing her own job responsibilities to align with her personal ethics? Is it ethically forbidden to go out of the sales chain

  Question 1welcome to passion ocanemauritius premier

question 1welcome to passion oc?anemauritius premier eco-cruise companywe request you to explore our website for the

Free Assignment Quote

Assured A++ Grade

Get guaranteed satisfaction & time on delivery in every assignment order you paid with us! We ensure premium quality solution document along with free turntin report!

All rights reserved! Copyrights ©2019-2020 ExpertsMind IT Educational Pvt Ltd